AI transcript
0:00:04 Support for this show comes from Constant Contact.
0:00:07 If you struggle just to get your customers to notice you,
0:00:10 Constant Contact has what you need to grab their attention.
0:00:15 Constant Contact’s award-winning marketing platform offers all the automation,
0:00:20 integration, and reporting tools that get your marketing running seamlessly,
0:00:23 all backed by their expert live customer support.
0:00:27 It’s time to get going and growing with Constant Contact today.
0:00:30 Ready, set, grow.
0:00:34 Go to ConstantContact.ca and start your free trial today.
0:00:43 Go to ConstantContact.ca for your free trial, ConstantContact.ca.
0:00:45 Support for this show comes from Seven Rooms.
0:00:49 For the restaurant operators out there who want to create more regulars on the regular,
0:00:51 check out Seven Rooms.
0:00:55 Seven Rooms is an all-in-one CRM marketing and operations platform
0:00:59 that helps you make more money and more magic for your guests.
0:01:04 It gives your staff the tools to deliver service that keeps your guests coming back for more,
0:01:09 from direct reservations to smart table management to targeted text and email marketing.
0:01:14 Seven Rooms helps you grow your brand and your covers and not your workload.
0:01:17 Learn more at SevenRooms.com.
0:01:20 Seven Rooms. Make magic. Make money.
0:01:23 Support for this episode comes from AWS.
0:01:28 AWS Generative AI gives you the tools to power your business forward
0:01:31 with the security and speed of the world’s most experienced cloud.
0:01:37 Welcome to Raging Moderates. I’m Scott Galloway.
0:01:39 And I’m Jessica Tarleff.
0:01:40 Jessica, it’s time for banter.
0:01:42 Don’t do it.
0:01:44 It’s time for banter.
0:01:46 What were you worried I was going to do so I can do it?
0:01:48 I was going to say, where do I find you today?
0:01:50 And then I would say, in the same place, I always am.
0:01:52 But where are you?
0:01:54 I do not recognize this room.
0:01:56 I’m at home in London and we’re moving.
0:01:59 So I’ve been charged with, I am so good at purging.
0:02:02 I won’t even show it, but I’m literally throwing out like 200 pounds of clothing
0:02:05 and all sorts of stuff.
0:02:06 But I’m back in London.
0:02:07 I’ve been here two days.
0:02:10 Already can’t wait to get out.
0:02:14 The weather, I don’t know if you’ve heard the weather here is awful, Jess.
0:02:15 The weather here is awful.
0:02:16 I lived there six years.
0:02:20 I actually started using happy bulbs after like three.
0:02:23 I gave in and said, oh, this is legit depressing.
0:02:25 I need a lift at home.
0:02:26 So people don’t know this.
0:02:27 I don’t think people know.
0:02:29 You got a PhD at the London School of Economics.
0:02:30 Is that right?
0:02:31 It is right.
0:02:33 And what did you get your PhD in?
0:02:34 It was in the government department.
0:02:38 I guess it was like technically political economy, but yeah.
0:02:39 So impressive.
0:02:41 And did you enjoy living here?
0:02:42 Would you ever move back?
0:02:43 Yeah, we would love to do.
0:02:46 I mean, we never lived there together, me and my husband,
0:02:49 but he has an office there, which is appealing.
0:02:51 But I, as of now, couldn’t work there.
0:02:54 But once all of this pans out for us,
0:02:56 I’m sure I’ll be able to work anywhere in the world.
0:02:57 There you go.
0:02:59 So all right, our producer’s getting angry at me.
0:03:00 Let’s move on.
0:03:04 In today’s show, we’re discussing Biden’s pardon for a sunhunter,
0:03:08 Trump’s tariff proposals, and appointment of cash Patel,
0:03:11 and why companies are rolling back DEI initiatives.
0:03:12 All right, let’s do it.
0:03:16 On Sunday night, President Biden pardoned his sunhunter,
0:03:18 wiping out convictions for gun and tax crimes
0:03:22 and covering potential federal offenses from 2014 to 2024,
0:03:25 including his barisma dealings.
0:03:29 This reverses Biden’s earlier promise not to pardon hunter.
0:03:31 The clemency council sentencing emblocks
0:03:33 any future prosecution with courts expected
0:03:35 to dismiss all charges.
0:03:37 Reactions, as you might have guessed, have been mixed,
0:03:38 even among Democrats.
0:03:40 With Colorado’s governor, Jared Polis, tweeting,
0:03:43 while as a father, I certainly understand President Joe Biden’s
0:03:45 natural desire to help his son by pardoning him,
0:03:48 I am disappointed that he put his family ahead of the country.
0:03:52 Trump posted on Truth Social, does the pardon given by Joe
0:03:55 to Hunter, including the January 6th hostages who have now
0:03:57 been in prison for years, such an abuse
0:03:59 and miscarriage of justice?
0:04:02 J6’s referring to January 6th insurrection.
0:04:06 Jess, did you see this coming, and what are your thoughts here?
0:04:08 I guess I always thought it was feasible,
0:04:10 though we talked about it on air, and I said,
0:04:11 he said he’s not going to do it.
0:04:14 And you have to take him at his word.
0:04:16 I think that he thought he was going to win the election,
0:04:19 or that Kamala Harris was going to win the election,
0:04:21 and then maybe things were going to be different.
0:04:24 But back against the wall, the sentencing, I think,
0:04:26 is coming up this week.
0:04:30 And apparently, at NBC, I think, is reporting
0:04:35 that they decided in June to say that he was never
0:04:38 going to pardon Hunter, even though it was still on the table,
0:04:39 which feels definitely deceitful.
0:04:40 So there’s a lie, right?
0:04:43 There is a lie in this, in him saying that.
0:04:47 But I think with the timing that he saw Trump make
0:04:50 Charles Kushner, who–
0:04:54 Jared Kushner’s dad, who did one of the more insane things.
0:04:57 You know this story about how his brother-in-law was
0:04:59 cooperating with the feds against him,
0:05:01 so he sent a prostitute to seduce him,
0:05:04 and then sent the tape of it to his sister.
0:05:08 He exposed that her husband was cheating with a prostitute,
0:05:11 because he was cooperating on other crimes
0:05:13 that he actually didn’t end up being convicted of.
0:05:15 So I think he saw that Charles Kushner is going
0:05:17 to be the ambassador to France.
0:05:19 Trump’s pardoned everyone and their mother.
0:05:25 And he’s also appointing people to his cabinet,
0:05:31 who openly want to put Hunter away to avenge enemies
0:05:33 from the press, people who went after him
0:05:37 for the “Russia hoax,” “Russia collusion hoax.”
0:05:40 And so I think he just said, like, eff it.
0:05:44 Like, I have a few more months with power,
0:05:46 and I’m going to protect my kid.
0:05:48 I think you nailed it.
0:05:53 You know, on the downside here, we are kind of devolving
0:05:55 into that place, right?
0:05:58 I remember when Speaker McCarthy got so upset
0:06:02 about some of the holdouts, he kind of stormed up
0:06:05 the aisle of the rotunda, and it felt like we might
0:06:07 become that nation or South Korea that every 18 months,
0:06:11 the Congress breaks into fisticuffs.
0:06:13 And I feel like we become that nation.
0:06:18 And that is we now have people in power abusing their power.
0:06:20 This is an abuse of power.
0:06:22 And I don’t believe– I believe if Harris had won,
0:06:24 he wouldn’t have done it.
0:06:28 I think the expectations now have become so low,
0:06:33 and you get so little reward for trying to live up
0:06:36 to the expectations and acquit yourself
0:06:37 as past presidents have.
0:06:39 You actually get dinged for it.
0:06:41 It’s not even like no reward.
0:06:45 I feel like you’re penalized for being ethical.
0:06:47 Well, that’s a fair point.
0:06:50 And I just want to be clear.
0:06:53 If I were President Biden, I would do the exact same thing.
0:06:56 If I’m– I mean, the guy’s not going to be around,
0:07:00 I doubt, much longer, or he’s definitely on the back nine.
0:07:03 And my sense of his son, pure speculation,
0:07:06 struggled with addiction, loves his dad immensely,
0:07:09 trying to get his life together, I think.
0:07:10 A total fuck-up.
0:07:14 You know, one of his kids killed in an auto accident.
0:07:17 His other son died of a brain tumor.
0:07:20 His one son loves him immensely.
0:07:23 And then he sees, as you said, OK, let me get this.
0:07:27 The president’s son-in-law’s dad gets pardoned
0:07:30 and then becomes the ambassador to France.
0:07:31 Fuck it.
0:07:33 I mean, that’s exactly right.
0:07:35 I would have done the exact same thing.
0:07:39 And the problem is it’s become a race to the bottom
0:07:43 where no behavior now seems off limits or shocking.
0:07:47 So this is a weird analogy, but I’m aggressive on my taxes.
0:07:49 I don’t do anything illegal.
0:07:52 And for a long time, I’m like, no, it’s good to pay taxes.
0:07:55 And I thought, why am I disarming unilaterally?
0:07:58 You know, no one’s going to say at your funeral
0:08:00 that he was great, he paid more taxes
0:08:02 than he really needed to.
0:08:04 And it’s the same thing here.
0:08:05 It’s like, let me get this.
0:08:08 These guys, this guy’s going to pardon
0:08:11 the Duck Dynasty insurrectionists.
0:08:13 I’m going to potentially pardon people
0:08:15 who have been campaign donors.
0:08:16 You mentioned the Kushner.
0:08:18 By the way, that’s got to be–
0:08:22 I would love a Thanksgiving with the Kushners.
0:08:28 I know the kid, Jared, I like him, he was my student.
0:08:31 His brother seems like a total baller.
0:08:33 His brother’s also married to a supermodel.
0:08:35 I’ve always liked Ivanka, I’ve met her once or twice.
0:08:37 She’s always been nice to me.
0:08:44 But I definitely want the father, his wife, the prostitute.
0:08:46 I just think it would make for such an interesting Thanksgiving.
0:08:48 I got to think their Thanksgiving
0:08:50 is one of the more interesting Thanksgiving.
0:08:52 And we should do it at the US Ambassador’s Ship in Paris,
0:08:56 which, by the way, is literally the coolest
0:08:58 Ambassador residence in the world.
0:09:00 But back to our central theme here.
0:09:03 This is the problem with an administration
0:09:06 that is descended into essentially a kleptocracy
0:09:09 that has absolutely no moral standards.
0:09:13 Is the other side goes, well, why the fuck are we
0:09:17 trying to pretend to be ethical when there’s no payoff?
0:09:20 When the market and the public doesn’t seem to mind?
0:09:24 If I’m an 82-year-old father, yeah, I’m pardoning my son.
0:09:26 I would have done the exact same thing.
0:09:29 Yeah, that seems to be the overwhelming response,
0:09:32 putting aside Governor Polis, who also
0:09:35 had quite the hot take on RFK Jr.
0:09:39 that he got destroyed over when that nomination came out.
0:09:42 But generally speaking, hardcore Dems
0:09:44 seemed to be like, yeah, OK.
0:09:46 And it was also time to have some backbone.
0:09:50 And one of the main complaints that I feel like rank and file
0:09:53 Dems have is that we have no Mitch McConnells amongst us,
0:09:58 no one who’s ruthless enough to not give Garland a hearing.
0:10:03 And that they’re mad at Merrick Garland once he became AG,
0:10:06 that he took two years to appoint Jack Smith to look
0:10:10 into all of these crimes that Trump has alleged–
0:10:12 we’re supposed to say alleged, though everything’s
0:10:13 been dismissed now–
0:10:14 committed.
0:10:16 We just sat around for too long.
0:10:17 And now all of it is gone.
0:10:18 Poof.
0:10:20 The Republicans never would have done that.
0:10:22 They take every swing.
0:10:24 And if they miss, so what?
0:10:25 I’ll put someone in.
0:10:26 You swing with Matt Gaetz.
0:10:27 Guess what?
0:10:31 You got Pam Bondi, who’s kind of like Matt Gaetz in a dress
0:10:34 and a bit more confident, which I guess is a good thing.
0:10:36 We’ll see how that bears out.
0:10:40 But one point that Dave Weigel, friend of the pod,
0:10:41 if we can say that–
0:10:42 I always like that term–
0:10:48 made was that if you read the text of what Biden said,
0:10:51 his point was that he still believes in the rule of law,
0:10:55 but that this was an abuse of the law for political reasons.
0:10:59 And Weigel harkened back to the defense that Bill Clinton gave
0:11:01 in the ’90s, why he was pardoning people,
0:11:03 and he thought that all of it was just junk.
0:11:05 He’s like, this is all just politically motivated.
0:11:07 If you get me on something that’s actually a crime,
0:11:10 and he perjured himself, and that is bad,
0:11:11 and you shouldn’t have done that.
0:11:16 But the point is, no one cares about who I’m having sex with,
0:11:20 except for Ken Starr and rabid Republicans.
0:11:21 And so this doesn’t actually have anything
0:11:23 to do with my competency.
0:11:26 It doesn’t have anything to do with how I do my job.
0:11:29 And so I’m not going to treat this as the real world,
0:11:31 and I’m going to pardon people that are associated with it,
0:11:34 and I’m going to move on with my life, and frankly,
0:11:36 think pretty highly of myself still.
0:11:39 And that’s clearly the tack that Joe Biden was taking.
0:11:42 I thought that was a really interesting and smart take on this.
0:11:44 I don’t know if you have a ’90s reflection, but–
0:11:47 But don’t you think Republicans could claim the same thing
0:11:51 that the New York case, the Albenberg case against Donald
0:11:55 Trump, again, it was about sex, that that was also purely
0:12:01 politically motivated, and if so, should warrant a pardon?
0:12:03 Well, yeah, I don’t know.
0:12:07 I shouldn’t– that, yeah, sounded too enthusiastic for me.
0:12:14 I was always the weakest case, and I think part of living
0:12:17 in the conservative media world that I do because of work
0:12:22 is that I can see that it’s glaring at me, because I’m like,
0:12:24 OK, this is one that they can so easily take apart,
0:12:27 but they struggle more with the Mar-a-Lago documents, right?
0:12:29 Or I guess you could kind of tit for tat
0:12:31 wasn’t an insurrection or not, but there’s
0:12:34 so much testimony surrounding January 6
0:12:37 and how this was planned, that Trump was like,
0:12:38 this is how we’re going to do it.
0:12:40 We’re just going to overturn the elections.
0:12:42 We’re going to fan the lawyers out all the swing states,
0:12:43 et cetera.
0:12:45 So yeah, you could make that argument.
0:12:47 And Tish James hasn’t helped anyone
0:12:50 by giving 50 press conferences where she just says,
0:12:54 I will stop at nothing, right, until Donald Trump is behind bars.
0:12:57 So you could totally make that argument.
0:12:59 But I don’t know, there’s so much other stuff
0:13:04 that he was indicted on, and that juries found him guilty of,
0:13:06 that I think he goes beyond it.
0:13:09 But the Stormy Daniels case was always the weakest,
0:13:12 and it was annoying, frankly, that it happened,
0:13:13 and that it went first.
0:13:16 You brought up a really interesting point,
0:13:19 and that is we suffer from a lack of mendacious fucks.
0:13:23 And that is McConnell was always playing us,
0:13:27 and everyone was just so disgusted and disappointed.
0:13:29 I’m like, well, where are our Senator McConnells?
0:13:32 Is it Representative Nadler?
0:13:35 Quite frankly, and I hope this election does it.
0:13:37 I hope they just clean house the Democratic leadership.
0:13:39 I want to see Jeremy Raskin.
0:13:43 I think Speaker Pelosi has a touch of Machiavelli to her.
0:13:45 I think she’s outstanding.
0:13:48 Senator Schumer, I think is incredibly weak.
0:13:49 I think he’s weak.
0:13:51 I don’t think he has nearly the strategy or the sack
0:13:53 that McConnell has demonstrated.
0:13:57 And we need just some ruthless motherfuckers in there.
0:14:01 And it’ll be interesting to see if Representative Jeffries
0:14:04 brings that kind of Machiavellian strategy.
0:14:07 Everything against Hunter Biden was a function
0:14:10 of who they were or who they are, not of the crimes.
0:14:13 No one, had it not been Donald Trump,
0:14:16 if he paid off a mistress, a porn star,
0:14:18 I just don’t think that would have ended up in court.
0:14:22 I think that that is a misuse of prosecutorial resources.
0:14:24 Hunter Biden, that was bullshit.
0:14:26 He would have gotten some charges fine.
0:14:28 He would have been on probation.
0:14:30 This is the idea I like,
0:14:32 and I think you’re gonna like this.
0:14:34 All right, gun charge.
0:14:35 He’s handsome.
0:14:36 He’s made porn films.
0:14:37 He’s been pardoned.
0:14:39 I think he’s our answer.
0:14:40 I think he has,
0:14:41 I think he’s now the number three
0:14:43 or number four most likely Democratic nominee
0:14:45 for president in 2028.
0:14:48 I think Hunter Biden is the Democrat we need right now,
0:14:49 Jess.
0:14:50 What do you think?
0:14:51 I mean, I’m not against it.
0:14:54 Think of all the bumper stickers we have that we can use.
0:14:56 Biden, Biden for president, yeah.
0:15:00 Yeah, I mean, we have weirder things happen.
0:15:02 Maybe Donald Trump, yeah.
0:15:04 Right, all right, we need to move on.
0:15:07 All right, last week, Elon Musk celebrated Thanksgiving
0:15:08 with Trump at Mar-a-Lago,
0:15:11 as he gears up for his new dojo role
0:15:13 and meets with House Republicans this week.
0:15:15 Just before the holiday, President-elect Trump proposed
0:15:17 25% tariffs on goods from Mexico and Canada,
0:15:21 raising serious concerns among business and world leaders.
0:15:22 Mexico has warned that such a move
0:15:24 could cost nearly half a million U.S. jobs
0:15:27 while a company spirit will drive up prices for consumers.
0:15:29 President Biden is urging Trump to reconsider,
0:15:31 warning that tariffs could strain relationships
0:15:34 with key allies, have inflationary effects at home,
0:15:36 and result in higher prices across the board.
0:15:38 Jess, what do you think is gonna happen here?
0:15:40 Do you think it’ll fall through on this?
0:15:43 To some degree, I don’t think it’ll be a 25% tariff,
0:15:46 but I’m sure that he’ll sprinkle them around
0:15:49 and Scott Besen, who will be the Treasury Secretary,
0:15:52 is naturally not a tariff guy.
0:15:55 I think that was one of the kind of final sticking points
0:15:57 to make sure that he was gonna be on board
0:16:02 with this approach of using it as a way to cultivate results.
0:16:04 And I don’t think that that’s insane.
0:16:06 And we should, you gotta be honest about the fact
0:16:08 that Biden kept nearly all of the tariffs
0:16:10 that Trump had put on China.
0:16:13 He’s done things, I think a little bit smarter.
0:16:16 Like he put tariffs on things that we don’t get as much of,
0:16:18 like EVs, for instance.
0:16:20 We don’t get a ton of them from China.
0:16:22 So like it makes sense to kind of hike that up
0:16:25 so it doesn’t really hurt the American consumer base.
0:16:29 But tariffs aren’t unilaterally a stupid idea.
0:16:31 It’s stupid to say I’m gonna put 100% tariff on this
0:16:33 or I’m gonna put 25% on Canada and Mexico.
0:16:36 He doesn’t talk about, what is it like something insane?
0:16:39 Like 60% of our vegetables come from Mexico.
0:16:42 Our construction supplies that come from Canada.
0:16:45 But what I think is the interesting corollary
0:16:48 to Trump doing all this bluster
0:16:51 is what will the world leaders’ responses be?
0:16:53 Because we have two different prototypes now.
0:16:56 So Claudia Scheinbaum, the president of Mexico
0:16:57 had a very different response
0:16:59 than Justin Trudeau from Canada.
0:17:00 So Justin Trudeau is like,
0:17:02 “Hey, Donald, I’m coming to Mar-a-Lago for dinner.
0:17:04 “Let’s do the photo op, I’ll meet your people.
0:17:05 “This’ll be great.”
0:17:08 And Claudia Scheinbaum released a pretty scathing statement
0:17:09 that essentially said, like,
0:17:11 “You don’t know what you’re talking about.”
0:17:14 Because Trump said, “I’m gonna put this tariff on
0:17:17 “if you don’t stop sending migrants and drugs here.”
0:17:19 And she first of all said, “By the way,
0:17:22 “all of the guns that are here are from your country.”
0:17:23 So maybe you could figure that out.
0:17:26 And second of all, we have been stopping the migrants.
0:17:29 And according to your own CPV numbers,
0:17:32 it’s down, crossings are down 75% in the last year
0:17:35 because of a program that we put in.
0:17:38 Now, is anyone paying attention to the fact
0:17:39 that that’s what she said?
0:17:41 No, because Trump went and said,
0:17:44 “See, presto chango, it happened right away, right?
0:17:46 “Like I said jump and she said how high
0:17:48 “and now everything’s fine.”
0:17:50 As if he stopped migrants from crossing the border,
0:17:52 it happened under Biden.
0:17:54 But those are the two different models.
0:17:57 And I’m curious to see where other world leaders fall on that.
0:17:59 Like who will be going to kiss the ring
0:18:01 and who will be issuing sassy statements?
0:18:02 It will be the Jewish woman
0:18:04 that is issuing the sassy statement.
0:18:07 The Jewish climate scientist, that’s right.
0:18:09 Yeah, I love, it tickles my sensors
0:18:12 to see her saying this and she’s right.
0:18:13 Trudeau’s probably smarter.
0:18:16 My understanding is among world leaders
0:18:19 is just go kiss this guy’s ass, pull a Tim Cook.
0:18:23 Tim Cook goes there, shows him the new iPhone,
0:18:25 it tells him he’s handsome, complements him.
0:18:26 Love your playlist.
0:18:27 Love your playlist.
0:18:28 And what do you know?
0:18:30 Somehow the tariffs on China,
0:18:33 Apple manages to sequester the majority
0:18:36 of their components from those tariffs.
0:18:41 This sycophantry, this obvious pandering, it works.
0:18:43 And to be fair, some of the tariffs
0:18:47 that Trump increased on China, Biden kept in place.
0:18:49 While China is no longer our biggest trading partner,
0:18:53 it’s now a tossup between Mexico and Canada.
0:18:55 There’s just so many wrinkles here.
0:18:59 Most US cars have parts from Mexico or Canada.
0:19:02 And the way this all ends, in my view,
0:19:05 is he implements anything resembling these tariffs,
0:19:07 which any of these,
0:19:09 one of the most heartening things about these appointments
0:19:12 is it almost seems like I’m gonna fuck
0:19:14 with the American people, I’m just gonna reward loyalists.
0:19:16 I don’t care about the DOJ,
0:19:18 I don’t care about the education.
0:19:20 But when it comes to the economy,
0:19:23 it feels like he becomes remarkably adult.
0:19:26 And he wants adults in the room around the key,
0:19:27 key appointments around the economy.
0:19:29 I think the majority of those candidates
0:19:31 all seem like adults, all seem qualified.
0:19:33 I don’t think many of them are gonna go
0:19:34 for this tariff thing, at least nothing.
0:19:36 I think they’ll throw them a bone and say,
0:19:38 okay, we’ll increase tariffs here, here and here.
0:19:41 But the first quarter, or even the first month,
0:19:44 where it looks like there’s a spike,
0:19:47 a re-spike in inflation, or a reigniting of inflation,
0:19:50 and it’s reverse engineered to tariffs,
0:19:52 oh, there’s trouble in Mudville.
0:19:56 Because the thing that brings down nations
0:19:58 is not usually that they get invaded,
0:20:01 it’s they either go broke or there’s inflation.
0:20:03 Because you wanna talk about rage,
0:20:06 when you have to go from meat to chicken, chicken to rice,
0:20:08 and then you can’t pay for your kid’s summer camp,
0:20:10 you don’t care who’s in office.
0:20:11 When they realize 88% of gifts
0:20:14 under the Christmas tree are from China,
0:20:17 and that their prices might go up 10, 20, 50%,
0:20:19 and that to a certain extent,
0:20:23 Trump becomes a lame duck president sooner rather than later,
0:20:26 I think they find their backbone and say,
0:20:29 no, I am not down with these tariffs at all.
0:20:33 And the moment, the moment inflation starts to spike back,
0:20:36 which we’re already seeing some evidence of,
0:20:39 in someone reverse engineers it to tariffs, boom,
0:20:40 that dog won’t hunt.
0:20:43 I think this is much more,
0:20:45 much more hat than cattle, what’s the term?
0:20:47 That’s a Brian Williams term, hat and cattle.
0:20:49 All hat, no cattle.
0:20:50 All chip, no salsa.
0:20:51 – Sounds very Yellowstone.
0:20:53 – There you go.
0:20:54 By the way, I could never get into Yellowstone.
0:20:55 Did you like it?
0:20:56 – Really?
0:20:57 I did the first couple of years,
0:20:59 and then I just thought it was ridiculous, but.
0:21:01 – I just didn’t buy it, I just didn’t buy it.
0:21:04 I thought it was succession for Republicans.
0:21:05 I didn’t buy it.
0:21:07 – Well, they deserve to have joy too.
0:21:09 – Yeah, I don’t know, I don’t get it.
0:21:10 – Just to add to that,
0:21:13 it was interesting to see when Scott Besant
0:21:17 was the treasury pick, the market bumped up.
0:21:19 Was very excited with the news.
0:21:22 The next day, this was after his truth social post
0:21:24 about the tariffs coming, market goes down, right?
0:21:26 It was the same thing with RFK Junior, right?
0:21:30 Then all of the pharmaceutical stocks tanked.
0:21:33 So Trump is going to have to figure out
0:21:36 where his levers are, like how much he can push things,
0:21:41 how much he can pull things in order to keep us making 30%,
0:21:44 or whatever crazy amount the market has been going up,
0:21:47 because that is the only thing
0:21:49 that people are grading these administrations on.
0:21:51 It’s crazy, because all this other stuff
0:21:53 that went on during the Trump administration,
0:21:54 no one remembers it.
0:21:56 They only remember this feeling of,
0:21:59 this is what my gas costs, this is how much toilet paper was,
0:22:01 this is how before COVID came,
0:22:03 when obviously everything became terrible
0:22:03 and super expensive,
0:22:05 and people didn’t even blame him for that,
0:22:07 which is very annoying to me as a partisan,
0:22:11 but he just wants to leave with a good economic record
0:22:14 and probably put away some enemies if he can,
0:22:17 Hunter Biden included, definitely was gonna be on the list.
0:22:21 So I think he’ll just be watching those numbers closely.
0:22:23 And I remember when we first started
0:22:24 talking about the potential picks,
0:22:28 and you said, why not bring back Steve Mnuchin?
0:22:31 And Steve Mnuchin left completely unscathed, right?
0:22:33 His wife was this incredible viral meme
0:22:35 that I enjoyed all the time.
0:22:37 And it seems like he did a pretty good job,
0:22:39 and I imagine Scott Bassant will be similar.
0:22:41 Yeah. – He’s an adult.
0:22:43 And by the way, just you were right,
0:22:45 Mexico is now our biggest trading partner.
0:22:46 In the last seven years,
0:22:50 China’s gone from 22% of US imports,
0:22:53 it’s dropped to 14, that’s a dramatic decrease.
0:22:56 And Mexico has gone up from approximately 13
0:22:58 to now close to 16,
0:23:03 and Canada has gone from about 12 and a half to about 14.
0:23:08 So Mexico and Canada, it’s so interesting.
0:23:11 Trade is still largely a function of proximity.
0:23:14 Almost every country’s biggest trading partners usually,
0:23:15 they usually share a border with.
0:23:17 Anyways, some more fascinating insight
0:23:19 from the Northwestern School of Business.
0:23:22 All right, Jess, let’s take a quick break, stay with us.
0:23:29 Support for Prop G comes from Quintz.
0:23:32 Let’s be honest, not every gift we pick is a home run.
0:23:33 But what if I told you,
0:23:35 there was a secret reliable way
0:23:36 to get everyone on your list,
0:23:38 something they’ll actually enjoy,
0:23:39 one that doesn’t cost a fortune.
0:23:43 Okay, it’s not a secret actually, it’s just Quintz.
0:23:45 Quintz makes it easy to treat everyone in your life
0:23:48 to luxury quality clothing at frankly,
0:23:50 ridiculously affordable prices,
0:23:53 pieces including their iconic Mongolian cashmere sweaters,
0:23:54 which started just 50 bucks,
0:23:56 are guaranteed crowd pleasers.
0:23:58 They’re warm, stylish, and best of all, affordable.
0:24:01 In fact, all of Quintz’s luxury items are priced
0:24:03 50 to 80% less than similar brands.
0:24:06 Plus, Quintz says they only work with factories
0:24:07 that use safe, ethical,
0:24:10 and responsible manufacturing practices.
0:24:12 Our own Caroline Shagerin got to try out Quintz,
0:24:14 and she says she loves it.
0:24:16 Caroline loves her sage green Quintz sheets.
0:24:19 They’re comfortable and well made.
0:24:20 Gift luxury this holiday season
0:24:22 without the luxury price tag,
0:24:26 go to quintz.com/propg for 365 day returns,
0:24:28 plus free shipping on your order.
0:24:31 That’s Q-U-I-N-C-E.com/propg
0:24:34 to get free shipping and 365 day returns.
0:24:36 Quintz.com/propg.
0:24:42 Support for PropG comes from GiveDirectly.
0:24:43 The holidays are a great time
0:24:45 to make a charitable donation to a cause you care about.
0:24:46 But how do you know if your money
0:24:48 is actually helping the people who need it most?
0:24:51 Well, if you want to get cash directly to people in need,
0:24:54 consider donate to GiveDirectly.
0:24:56 GiveDirectly believes that cash allows people
0:24:58 the dignity and freedom to make their own decisions
0:25:00 about how they can improve their lives.
0:25:01 That’s because every person,
0:25:03 regardless of their financial status,
0:25:06 has their own specific needs, preferences, and aspirations.
0:25:09 And people living in poverty deserve to have a say
0:25:11 in how to best invest in their future,
0:25:14 whether that’s housing, education, business support,
0:25:14 and more.
0:25:18 In fact, many academic studies show that cash transfers
0:25:20 can improve earnings, health, education, and much more.
0:25:24 That’s why GiveDirectly lets you do exactly that.
0:25:25 GiveDirectly to those who need it.
0:25:27 Your donation this holiday season has the power
0:25:30 to lift families and entire communities
0:25:31 out of extreme poverty.
0:25:34 To learn more and send money directly to people
0:25:35 living in extreme poverty,
0:25:38 visit GiveDirectly.org/profty.
0:25:43 Support for Profty comes from open phone.
0:25:46 Running a small business means you’re wearing a lot of hats.
0:25:48 Your personal phone becomes your business phone,
0:25:49 and before you know it,
0:25:51 your juggling customer calls day and night.
0:25:53 As your team grows, it becomes impossible
0:25:54 to manage with your personal number.
0:25:56 That’s where open phone comes in.
0:25:59 Open phone is the business phone system
0:26:00 that can help you separate your personal life
0:26:03 from your growing business for just $15 a month.
0:26:06 Open phone works through an app on your phone or computer
0:26:09 and integrates with HubSpot and hundreds of other systems.
0:26:11 Their AI-powered transcription feature
0:26:13 can even summarize your phone calls
0:26:15 with action items as soon as you hang up.
0:26:16 And if you miss a call,
0:26:19 automated messages are sent directly to your customer,
0:26:20 meaning you’ll never miss an opportunity
0:26:22 to engage with them.
0:26:24 Right now, open phone is offering 20% off
0:26:28 your first six months when you go to openphone.com/profty.
0:26:31 That’s O-P-E-N-P-H-O-N-E.
0:26:35 .com/profty for 20% off six months.
0:26:37 Open phone.com/profty.
0:26:40 And if you have existing numbers with another service,
0:26:43 open phone will port them over at no extra charge.
0:26:49 – Welcome back on Saturday.
0:26:51 Trump shook things up.
0:26:52 That’s another statement.
0:26:55 By picking Cash Patel, a controversial maga loyalist
0:26:58 and deep state conspiracy theorist to lead the FBI.
0:27:00 This is an unusual move because FBI directors
0:27:03 typically serve 10-year terms to stay above politics.
0:27:06 This all comes as Trump considers firing Christopher Wray,
0:27:08 his own appointee with three years left on his term,
0:27:10 all while doubling down on promises
0:27:12 to prosecute political opponents.
0:27:14 What’s your take on this, Josh?
0:27:16 – Same as every week.
0:27:17 This is bad, no bueno.
0:27:18 This is very bad.
0:27:20 I mean, there’s so much to go through
0:27:23 in the craziness of Cash Patel.
0:27:26 But something that does stick out to me
0:27:31 is that other Trump loyalists have a worldview
0:27:34 that they come to the table with.
0:27:36 Like Steve Bannon wasn’t born the day
0:27:38 that Trump came down the golden staircase, right?
0:27:42 And Stephen Miller has had his views for a very long time.
0:27:46 Cash Patel is like a blank slate
0:27:49 that was created in Trump’s ideological likeness.
0:27:53 Like he has nothing seemingly that he believes in
0:27:56 that existed before Donald Trump.
0:28:00 And that’s what makes him uniquely frightening to me
0:28:03 because he just lives to please this guy.
0:28:06 I mean, he even wrote a children’s book about him.
0:28:09 Like he mimics everything he has.
0:28:14 He like hawks clothes.
0:28:15 He has a clothing line.
0:28:18 He works his business.
0:28:19 I think it’s the Cash Foundation,
0:28:21 which gives to people affected
0:28:24 by the terrible atrocities of January 6th,
0:28:27 like families of January 6thers, J6ers,
0:28:29 I think we’re supposed to call them.
0:28:31 He produced Justice for All,
0:28:32 which is a version of the national anthem
0:28:35 that the January 6th defendants
0:28:36 that Trump played at his first campaign rally.
0:28:40 Like he is so enmeshed in this world.
0:28:45 He feels like a Trump child more than the others do.
0:28:46 To me.
0:28:48 – Yeah, this guy is a little bit,
0:28:51 during his time where I believe he was,
0:28:52 what did he do?
0:28:54 He was a prosecutor.
0:28:54 – Yeah, he was a prosecutor.
0:28:56 He worked for Devin Nunes.
0:28:58 You remember him, who was crazy.
0:28:59 – Okay.
0:29:01 – And he did have some high level intel jobs.
0:29:04 He was the deputy to acting DNI, Rick Grinnell.
0:29:07 – He supposedly also fed Trump back channel information
0:29:09 on Ukraine that contributed to Trump’s plot
0:29:11 to push that nation to help him smear
0:29:14 his political opponents during his time.
0:29:17 Patel also authored a memo arguing that it was disloyal
0:29:19 for then defense secretary, Mark Esper,
0:29:20 who I’ve met and strikes me
0:29:22 as a world-class high character person,
0:29:25 to oppose a request by Trump to deploy military troops
0:29:26 against American citizens,
0:29:30 protesting police violence against black people.
0:29:32 After Trump lost to President Biden in 2020,
0:29:35 Patel pushed lies about the election being stolen
0:29:37 and argued that reporters debunking Trump’s election lies
0:29:39 should be targeted by the government.
0:29:42 He said, open quote, yes,
0:29:44 we’re going to come after the people in the media
0:29:46 who lied about American citizens
0:29:48 who helped Joe Biden rig presidential elections.
0:29:52 We’re going to come after you, close quote.
0:29:53 I mean, I don’t know.
0:29:56 And he’s also authored three children’s books
0:29:58 that are pro-Trump fan fiction.
0:30:01 So going after your political enemies
0:30:03 and finding time to write children’s books,
0:30:04 you gotta give it to the guy.
0:30:06 He’s at least a little,
0:30:08 he’s sort of a Renaissance man in hell, so to speak.
0:30:13 He’s just sort of this, he’s a bit of an odd duck.
0:30:14 And also I’ve always found that,
0:30:19 I thought Christopher Wray, it’s exactly what you want
0:30:22 as an appointee because when he sat in front of Congress,
0:30:24 I couldn’t tell if he was a Democrat or a Republican.
0:30:26 I just thought he was, you know,
0:30:29 like Joe Friday from “Dragonate”, just a fax, ma’am.
0:30:32 And he was, I just thought he was so good
0:30:33 and landed so much credibility
0:30:35 to the Trump administration that, okay,
0:30:37 in these important roles,
0:30:40 you have someone like this, you see above partisanship,
0:30:42 but, you know, the same way,
0:30:46 I do think he’s acting that way on the economics appointments.
0:30:47 And he used to act that way,
0:30:49 at least a little bit on security appointments
0:30:50 and defense appointments.
0:30:53 He seems to have totally lost that now.
0:30:57 And it’s so, just culturally,
0:30:59 it’s gotta be so demoralizing.
0:31:01 There are FBI agents.
0:31:04 I mean, first off, Tulsi Gabbard to me is by far,
0:31:06 other than gets as the most outrageous,
0:31:10 I actually think the most dangerous
0:31:11 is Representative Gabbard,
0:31:15 ’cause there are people that spend their entire lives,
0:31:16 the majority of their professional lives,
0:31:18 putting themselves in harm’s way,
0:31:19 knowing that if they caught,
0:31:20 they’re not just gonna be killed,
0:31:22 they’re gonna be tortured and killed,
0:31:24 implanting themselves in high-level positions
0:31:27 with a lot of access within our adversaries.
0:31:30 And there are only two people who know who they are.
0:31:34 There are Case Handler and the head of, you know,
0:31:37 the CIA or the head of the security services.
0:31:40 And I just gotta think, if I’m that person,
0:31:43 I do not want Representative Gabbard knowing who I am.
0:31:45 This is someone who met with Assad,
0:31:47 who’s been an apologist for the Kremlin.
0:31:49 There’s no evidence he’s an actual asset,
0:31:51 but I can see here, like,
0:31:55 if I’m an undercover agent or officer with the CIA,
0:31:57 and I think this individual might decide
0:32:01 it’s good for America to out all undercover assets
0:32:03 in the Kremlin, I’m out.
0:32:07 I’m not risking my life in limb and staying away
0:32:11 from my family when this person who doesn’t seem,
0:32:14 who seems to be more fond of Putin than of Democrats,
0:32:15 I’m out.
0:32:18 And the one thing that the majority of, I think,
0:32:21 our presidents and our directors of national security
0:32:23 and the heads of CIA have had,
0:32:26 I think George Bush was the head of the CIA and president.
0:32:27 I believe most case officers of the CIA
0:32:29 probably thought George Bush would die for me.
0:32:32 This is someone who would die for his country.
0:32:34 And I think these people are like,
0:32:37 no, they would let me die under some fucked up notion
0:32:41 of what they think is some sort of conspiracy theory.
0:32:43 This is, she is a dangerous appointment
0:32:46 and having this guy as head of the FBI,
0:32:51 I just gotta think that is so incredibly damaging
0:32:53 to morale ’cause I’ve always thought of the FBI
0:32:57 is there’s just a few places where they really,
0:32:59 they put country above politics.
0:33:02 They say, presidents are gonna come and go,
0:33:05 political parties are gonna come and go,
0:33:07 I am about our country, fidelity to the country
0:33:10 and finding bad guys.
0:33:14 And now this place has been weaponized politically
0:33:17 and I don’t know if I can trust these people.
0:33:18 – But there are millions of people who think
0:33:21 that it was the Democrats that weaponized the FBI
0:33:24 who look at Andy McCabe and his text messages
0:33:28 with Lisa Page, they go back to Jim Comey.
0:33:31 I mean, listen, the firing of Jim Comey,
0:33:34 I will never understand since I think he was
0:33:37 the key ingredient in Trump being able to win,
0:33:39 actually him coming out 11 days before the election
0:33:43 and saying, we looked at Anthony Wiener’s laptop again,
0:33:44 like no biggie though.
0:33:46 And then everyone thought that,
0:33:49 she had done something unbelievably evil.
0:33:54 But this is, Cash Patel is part of the wrecking ball approach
0:33:56 to all of these institutions.
0:34:01 And I don’t think that he would be able to get confirmed,
0:34:05 but it seems like that’s not even necessarily the approach
0:34:07 that Trump feels like he needs to go.
0:34:10 So Christopher Wray has a 10 year term,
0:34:11 so he’s three years left on his term,
0:34:12 but he can be fired.
0:34:16 So let’s say that happens January 21st, right, 2025.
0:34:19 And then using the federal vacancies reform act,
0:34:23 Patel can be there, I think 210 days without being confirmed.
0:34:28 So we might just again have a cabinet full of acting ex job.
0:34:32 And that’s how he’ll be able to do it.
0:34:36 The standard of luminaries within our party,
0:34:38 you know, lifelong Republicans,
0:34:40 people who have served, you know,
0:34:44 great Republican presidents like the Bill Bars of the world,
0:34:47 they just, it doesn’t matter anymore.
0:34:51 The general populace doesn’t believe in these institutions.
0:34:52 I mean, these quotes are crazy.
0:34:54 Like from Bill Bars book,
0:34:56 he said that Patel would be the deputy director
0:34:58 of the FBI over my dead body.
0:35:02 You have Mark Milley, who told him life looks really shitty
0:35:04 from behind bars.
0:35:06 Gina Haspel, who was the head of the CIA,
0:35:09 threatened to resign when Trump was gonna make him
0:35:11 the deputy director of the CIA.
0:35:13 Like these are all people that you,
0:35:15 you know, whether you like their politics or not,
0:35:18 and I certainly don’t like Bill Bars politics,
0:35:22 but I never felt like he couldn’t do the job.
0:35:24 I thought he, what he did around the Mueller report,
0:35:27 writing that little four page summary
0:35:29 was extremely deceptive,
0:35:33 but I never thought that he couldn’t do it.
0:35:34 You know what I mean?
0:35:35 Like I didn’t like that decision,
0:35:39 but it wasn’t someone that I would fear like a Cache Patel
0:35:42 who’s just there honestly to pay no reverence
0:35:45 to the institution at all.
0:35:46 He’s just there to break it
0:35:48 and that he will destroy, like you said,
0:35:51 the morale of the rank and file agents
0:35:54 who are what make it great and that our allies
0:35:58 and our enemies just will laugh at us for four years
0:36:00 and our allies won’t be sharing with us,
0:36:03 which is the big Tulsi Gabbard problem there for sure,
0:36:05 that everyone will just go about their business
0:36:07 and kind of cut us out.
0:36:10 Patel is concerning on a whole host of issues,
0:36:12 but that’s really it.
0:36:13 I just, I don’t want to,
0:36:15 I understand the argument for America first.
0:36:18 I understand how that resonated with voters
0:36:23 who didn’t feel like American lives were being prioritized,
0:36:27 whether it comes to the economy, national security, immigration,
0:36:30 but to me, this just doesn’t feel like the answer,
0:36:32 that you can find competent people
0:36:36 that have a little bit of your emphasis
0:36:38 on rooting out corruption within institutions
0:36:42 without having Cache Patel as the head of the FBI.
0:36:43 – What you mentioned,
0:36:44 which I think is really one of the,
0:36:47 probably the key drawback is that no one nation
0:36:49 is big enough or strong enough
0:36:51 to effectively monitor the world
0:36:53 or secure itself from all threats.
0:36:55 And one of the most powerful things we have
0:36:59 and with NATO and some of these alliances is that,
0:37:04 MI6, the Mossad, the CIA, our security services,
0:37:08 their security services, we share information.
0:37:11 And whether it’s Israel coordinating with Jordan
0:37:12 and the kingdom of South America
0:37:14 around incoming missile barrage, Moran,
0:37:18 the whole is greater than some of its parts,
0:37:20 and around intelligence and information,
0:37:23 identifying threats, whether it’s terrorist activity
0:37:26 or IP theft of key chip technology,
0:37:30 if all of a sudden our allies are much more remiss
0:37:33 to share information with us because they don’t trust us
0:37:35 and they think this guy has no business
0:37:37 and they don’t wanna compromise their own assets
0:37:39 or their own intelligence,
0:37:42 then we lose what is supposed to be,
0:37:44 largely what has kept the peace
0:37:47 is that in general democracies have said, all right,
0:37:48 we’re gonna create something,
0:37:52 we’re gonna create a unified military structure called NATO,
0:37:54 and we’re gonna cooperate with each other,
0:37:57 not only economically but around intelligence and militarily
0:38:00 because if we do in fact present a united front
0:38:01 and cooperate with each other,
0:38:03 we’re just much harder to fuck with.
0:38:07 And that has largely created unprecedented peace
0:38:10 and prosperity over the last since World War II,
0:38:13 over the last, what is that now, 80 years.
0:38:15 And if that goes away under this notion of America first
0:38:17 and some arrogance, I really do think we suffer
0:38:20 from too much prosperity and this delusion
0:38:23 that we can go it alone, we can’t.
0:38:26 There, you know, the European economy is as big
0:38:29 as the US economy, which largely indicates
0:38:32 their security services and their access to information
0:38:35 and their intelligence units are just as valuable
0:38:37 and have a diversity of thought,
0:38:40 a diversity of information, a diversity of sources.
0:38:42 And when we share information with each other,
0:38:44 you can bet there are a lot of bad things
0:38:46 that never happened that we can’t be grateful for
0:38:49 because they didn’t happen.
0:38:50 And this notion that our allies
0:38:52 might no longer share information with us
0:38:55 and we might no longer share information with them
0:38:58 is how you defeat an enemy and that as you atomize them,
0:39:00 you get them fighting with each other
0:39:01 and that is happening here.
0:39:04 – Okay, we have one more quick break, stay with us.
0:39:12 – Support for this show comes from Amazon Prime.
0:39:14 The feeling that makes the holidays so special
0:39:16 is made up of countless elements,
0:39:19 a classic dish here, a piece of decor there,
0:39:22 a song or movie you always go back to.
0:39:24 Amazon Prime can help you get the most
0:39:26 out of that holiday feeling.
0:39:28 Find everything you need to warm up your home
0:39:30 for the cold days ahead.
0:39:32 Maybe you just need a few more stocking stuffers,
0:39:34 one more set of string lights
0:39:36 and some candles to tie the room together.
0:39:39 With Prime, you can get fast delivery
0:39:42 on all your last minute supplies, gifts and decor.
0:39:45 And when it comes to gifts, you can even get creative
0:39:48 and curate a playlist for someone on Amazon Music.
0:39:50 And when you’re ready to curl up on the couch
0:39:51 for your holiday movie marathon,
0:39:54 pull up the classics on Prime Video.
0:39:56 Whatever you’re into this holiday season
0:39:58 from streaming to shopping, it’s on Prime.
0:40:00 Visit amazon.com/prime
0:40:02 to get more out of whatever you’re into.
0:40:06 – Support for this show comes from Seven Rooms.
0:40:08 What’s the recipe for taking your restaurant
0:40:09 to the next level?
0:40:11 Well, restaurant operators know a key part of it
0:40:15 is making more money and making sure it keeps coming in.
0:40:17 That’s why you wanna bring Seven Rooms to the table.
0:40:20 Seven Rooms is an all-in-one CRM marketing
0:40:23 and operations platform that helps you make more money
0:40:26 for your operation and more magic for your guests.
0:40:28 It equips your staff with the tools you need
0:40:30 to deliver service that keeps your guests
0:40:32 coming back for more.
0:40:34 You can wow diners with a host of tools
0:40:37 that let you create personalized experiences,
0:40:39 organize unforgettable events,
0:40:41 and deepen patron loyalty.
0:40:44 From direct reservations to smart table management
0:40:46 and targeted email marketing,
0:40:49 Seven Rooms helps you grow your brand and your covers
0:40:51 and not your workload.
0:40:53 Learn more at SevenRooms.com.
0:40:57 Seven Rooms, make magic, make money.
0:41:00 – Support for this episode comes from AWS.
0:41:02 AWS Generative AI gives you the tools
0:41:05 to power your business forward with the security
0:41:08 and speed of the world’s most experienced cloud.
0:41:12 – Welcome back.
0:41:15 Walmart announced its scaling back its diversity, equity,
0:41:17 and inclusion DEI efforts.
0:41:19 This includes ending racial equity training for employees,
0:41:22 reevaluating programs supporting minority-owned suppliers,
0:41:25 and winding down its center for racial equity and nonprofit
0:41:28 it created to address systemic racism.
0:41:29 Walmart isn’t alone.
0:41:33 Other major companies, including Lowe’s, Ford, Harley-Davidson,
0:41:36 and John Deere are also pulling back on DEI initiatives
0:41:38 as well as reducing their support for Pride marches
0:41:40 and LGBTQ events.
0:41:42 Many had embraced DEI programs in response
0:41:44 to the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests
0:41:47 and the murder of George Floyd.
0:41:49 Jess, do you think these changes are happening
0:41:51 because Trump won the election?
0:41:53 What do you think is inspiring
0:41:55 this kind of pullback or rollback?
0:41:58 – Well, it’s been going on for a while
0:41:59 for the last couple of years.
0:42:02 I think that it’s getting more intense
0:42:06 because of what life will be like under a Trump presidency
0:42:09 and the kind of folks that he’s associated with,
0:42:12 but also who are just kind of in the ecosystem,
0:42:15 like activists like Christopher Rufo,
0:42:19 who was the principal kind of attack hound
0:42:22 over Claudine Gay, the president of Harvard,
0:42:25 who was pushed out for a multitude of reasons,
0:42:28 including the response to the anti-Semitism issues
0:42:30 on campus, but also the plagiarism scandal
0:42:34 which came from Chris Rufo originally.
0:42:38 But the numbers on the DEI roles going down
0:42:40 are pretty astronomical.
0:42:43 So there was a 29% uptick after George Floyd was murdered
0:42:47 between November, 2020 and November, 2021.
0:42:50 Then there was a 23% decline in the amount of jobs posting
0:42:55 with DEI in the title between November, 2022 and 2023.
0:42:58 And it’s down as much as 43% as of this summer.
0:43:02 So that’s obviously the trend line and where we’re going.
0:43:04 And that’s in part, I think that a lot of these roles
0:43:08 were invented for self-soothing to make people feel better
0:43:12 about it, also to communicate to consumers
0:43:14 and internal stakeholders.
0:43:16 We really care about these issues
0:43:18 without having a thoughtful plan of how to do it
0:43:20 or what you actually need.
0:43:23 Like, do you need there to be 100 roles like this?
0:43:25 Or do you need 10 really good people
0:43:28 that are gonna come in and make important changes
0:43:31 and help you reflect your values?
0:43:34 Which is what you hear over and over from organizations
0:43:36 that they need help being able to communicate
0:43:38 what their values are to internal
0:43:40 and external stakeholders.
0:43:42 So I think it’s the combination of everything coupled
0:43:45 with as well the affirmative action decision
0:43:49 from the Supreme Court, which has changed the way
0:43:52 a lot of people think about admissions to college
0:43:56 and beyond meritocracy in terms of getting your jobs.
0:44:00 And I know the UC system doesn’t do race-based admissions,
0:44:00 right?
0:44:03 – I think this is what often happens
0:44:07 with democratic initiatives or an orthodoxy
0:44:10 and that is it’s a good idea and then the world chains
0:44:12 they don’t change with it or it goes too far.
0:44:17 I still think there’s a need to focus on diversity
0:44:21 or ensuring that if you have a company
0:44:23 where the majority of your consumers
0:44:26 and endorsed athletes are non-white, i.e. Nike,
0:44:28 and pretty much your entire board is white dude
0:44:31 so you have a problem and you should be called out for it.
0:44:34 So there’s still work to be done here.
0:44:37 I have generally found that any company
0:44:41 or any university with a DEI officer or department
0:44:43 is already one of the most diverse
0:44:45 and inclusive places on the planet.
0:44:50 And what I have generally found at universities
0:44:54 is DEI is filled with a lot of virtue signaling
0:44:56 and they become impervious.
0:44:58 These jobs are impossible to do away with
0:45:01 because you’re kind of called implicitly
0:45:02 although what’s happening now are racist
0:45:05 if you’re in any way question them.
0:45:07 And they’re generally very expensive.
0:45:08 They never go away.
0:45:10 It’s resulted this among other things
0:45:12 whether it’s ethics or leadership, that’s my favorite.
0:45:13 We teach ethics at Stern.
0:45:15 Give me a fucking break.
0:45:18 I can’t give my 14 year old to make us bed
0:45:21 and I’m gonna teach a 28 year old to be more ethical.
0:45:22 These departments never go away.
0:45:25 We bring in formerly important people.
0:45:26 We pay them a lot of money
0:45:28 so they can talk about war stories,
0:45:30 teach them leadership or anything
0:45:32 with the term studies on it means that
0:45:34 if you take this course you might get four stars
0:45:37 instead of three as an Uber driver or barista.
0:45:40 We have totally lost the mission in my opinion in the script.
0:45:43 There are now 16 employees at MIT
0:45:46 for everyone who actually teaches.
0:45:48 And we invent these departments.
0:45:52 Sustainability, leadership, ethics, DEI
0:45:56 and all of this translates to student debt.
0:45:58 And where we’ve lost the script around DEI
0:46:02 is we’ve decided okay, essentially the easiest way
0:46:06 to identify or put forward an orthodoxy around DEI
0:46:10 is it oppressors over here, oppressed over here.
0:46:13 Oh and by the way, if you’re white and wealthy
0:46:14 you’re probably an oppressor
0:46:19 and whose ground zero for white and wealthy, Jews.
0:46:22 And what you have seen on campus is a level of bigotry
0:46:23 that I don’t think you’ve seen
0:46:26 in other American institutions in a long time.
0:46:29 And a lot of it started and was inspired
0:46:31 by this weird virtue signaling
0:46:33 and everyone barking up the same tree,
0:46:38 largely inspired or somewhat inspired by these DEI initiatives.
0:46:40 I can’t wait to see these things go on campus.
0:46:44 We, the whole DEI initiative on campus
0:46:46 has been nothing but a misdirect.
0:46:50 And that is Harvard obsesses over quote unquote diversity.
0:46:52 Meanwhile, they sit on an endowment
0:46:55 that’s the GDP of Costa Rica, $54 billion
0:46:58 and they refuse to expand their freshman class.
0:47:00 They’ve grown their endowment 4,000%.
0:47:03 They’ve grown their freshman class in 40 years, 4%.
0:47:07 So they create a misdirect around who gets in.
0:47:09 The conversation shouldn’t be around who gets in.
0:47:11 It should be around how many get in.
0:47:14 Let in more trans kids, let in more black kids,
0:47:17 let in more gay kids, let in more white kids
0:47:19 from rural states.
0:47:20 The question shouldn’t be who gets in.
0:47:21 It should be how many.
0:47:24 You know who doesn’t have a DEI problem?
0:47:26 Junior colleges.
0:47:28 Because they say if you show up and you want to better yourself
0:47:31 and you can pay a couple hundred bucks per credit, you’re in.
0:47:33 And the reason all this bullshit agita,
0:47:37 it also ends up creating more racism than it solves on campus
0:47:40 because the kid next to you who might not be non-white,
0:47:42 you wonder if he or she deserves to be there.
0:47:44 And it creates all of this resentment
0:47:47 among good kids who don’t get into school
0:47:48 because they don’t have a story of adversity.
0:47:50 And you brought up the University of California,
0:47:54 one of the great gifts to American society.
0:47:57 In 1990, was either four or seven, they said,
0:48:00 we’re no longer about race-based affirmative action.
0:48:03 We’re about an adversity score.
0:48:05 And I’m a beneficiary of affirmative action
0:48:07 because my household income was less than $40,000.
0:48:10 I got free Pell Grants or I got Pell Grants
0:48:12 or aren’t even loans.
0:48:13 So the DEI apparatus,
0:48:17 I hope it is disassembled immediately across campuses.
0:48:20 I still think there’s work to be done in corporations
0:48:22 as someone who serves on boards,
0:48:24 who knows a lot of senior management.
0:48:27 There’s still too many people with outdoor plumbing
0:48:28 running these companies.
0:48:30 And I don’t think it’s ever gonna be 50/50
0:48:31 ’cause I think more women will decide
0:48:34 to exit the workforce for a variety of reasons.
0:48:36 Anyways, that was my TED Talk.
0:48:37 Any thoughts?
0:48:38 – I think I actually have heard that
0:48:39 as one of your TED Talks.
0:48:41 And I enjoyed it then and I enjoyed it this time as well.
0:48:42 – Oh!
0:48:45 – No, I generally agree with it.
0:48:48 And I also, I thought that Harvard’s response
0:48:51 after the Supreme Court decision made a lot of sense
0:48:53 where they said, okay, well, we’re going to find a way
0:48:55 to ensure that we have a diverse class
0:48:57 no matter how you say we need to do it.
0:49:00 And there are other things that you can look at
0:49:02 in terms of an application or a background of a student
0:49:06 to make sure that you have the widest swath
0:49:09 of students represented.
0:49:11 And increasingly, this is a conversation
0:49:12 that I’m having with my friends
0:49:14 even down to the preschool level
0:49:15 where people aren’t as concerned anymore
0:49:18 about racial diversity because knock on wood,
0:49:22 thank God we have generally become less racist, right?
0:49:25 Like the Cheerios commercial with the biracial couple
0:49:27 that kind of broke all testing standards
0:49:29 where little kids, they showed it to a five-year-old
0:49:32 and to their parents and all the parents noticed
0:49:35 that it was a biracial couple and none of the kids did
0:49:38 because that’s life for them now, that they see mixed race,
0:49:41 everything is getting more of a melting pot
0:49:42 and that is a good thing.
0:49:46 But what is not happening is we are just hanging out
0:49:48 with people from our same socioeconomic background.
0:49:51 And that’s really what people are hunting
0:49:52 in terms of diversity.
0:49:53 Like I think about that all the time.
0:49:56 Will Cleo, my daughter have friends
0:49:59 who don’t have every toy that they want, right?
0:50:00 Will she go to someone’s house
0:50:03 who doesn’t have a playroom in the building?
0:50:07 You know, those kinds of things are much more top of mind
0:50:10 for us than worrying about whether she’s going to think
0:50:14 that a kid who is black or brown is less than.
0:50:16 And it was so important, I think for the evolution
0:50:19 of this discussion, that it was Asian Americans
0:50:22 that brought that lawsuit about being discriminated against
0:50:24 versus making it, we always think of it
0:50:27 as a black, brown issue or a person of color issue.
0:50:31 And we don’t tend to lump in Asians in that bucket,
0:50:33 which is something that they’ve had to be up against.
0:50:35 And I’ve had a lot of difficulty with that.
0:50:38 And it made me think about the change in New York City
0:50:39 as I’ve grown up.
0:50:43 So when I went and took the test to get into Stuyvesant,
0:50:46 which is a premier public school here in New York,
0:50:48 one of the main filters to Harvard,
0:50:51 it was predominantly white kids that were getting in.
0:50:53 And now, and I live in the neighborhood,
0:50:55 I rarely see a kid coming out of Stuyvesant
0:50:57 who is an Asian, right?
0:50:59 It is totally meritocratic.
0:51:02 However, you do on the test is whether you get in or not.
0:51:06 And the fact that they were then going on to be discriminated
0:51:09 against in terms of getting into these top universities,
0:51:10 which we should note as well as something
0:51:12 that happened to Jewish students at a certain point,
0:51:13 like a couple of decades ago,
0:51:15 then it started being pushed back against Jews,
0:51:17 there were too many of them getting in
0:51:19 as a proportion of the population,
0:51:20 then it moved on to Asians.
0:51:22 And I think that it allowed us
0:51:25 to actually have a more honest conversation
0:51:28 about these admission systems and how society is structured
0:51:31 because it wasn’t a black versus white issue
0:51:33 because everyone just tunes out then and just says,
0:51:37 well, of course I’m for equal opportunity.
0:51:40 And the reframing has led to more discussions like this,
0:51:43 which I think are important for people to have
0:51:45 and then to also integrate into it
0:51:47 the socioeconomic aspect of it,
0:51:50 which is the real dividing line in all of this.
0:51:54 Like there aren’t enough opportunities for poor white kids
0:51:56 to be able to get on the ladder,
0:51:57 whether it’s about going to school
0:51:59 or getting the jobs that they want,
0:52:01 the same way that we would have discussions
0:52:05 about poor black kids or poor Latino kids.
0:52:06 Anyway, that was my TED talk.
0:52:08 I don’t know if I would have gotten it though.
0:52:09 It was good, all right.
0:52:11 – In the United States today,
0:52:16 you would rather be born non-white or gay than poor.
0:52:20 54% of gay men will get a college degree,
0:52:22 it’s 34% for straight men,
0:52:25 and that goes into a variety of issues.
0:52:27 But affirmative action is a wonderful thing.
0:52:28 We should lift people up.
0:52:29 There’s just some people,
0:52:31 and I even think a majority of Republicans feel that,
0:52:34 okay, there’s some people with so much wind in their face,
0:52:37 let’s widen their aperture, let’s widen the perspective,
0:52:38 let’s give some people a hand up.
0:52:39 I just think,
0:52:41 I gotta think most people believe that, that okay,
0:52:42 it’s easy to talk about.
0:52:44 – And they’ve been beneficiaries of it to some degree,
0:52:46 however it has manifested.
0:52:47 Yeah.
0:52:50 – Case in point, Pell Grants for a straight white male,
0:52:52 but it should be based on color.
0:52:55 And that color is the following, green.
0:52:57 We should help poor kids.
0:52:58 They’re the ones,
0:52:59 they’re the ones,
0:53:01 the biggest forward-looking indicator of your success,
0:53:03 unfortunately in our nation,
0:53:05 has become how rich your parents are.
0:53:07 Basically your zip code and your parents’ income.
0:53:10 And we need something that helps kids
0:53:11 brought up in low-income neighborhoods,
0:53:13 regardless of the color of their skin,
0:53:15 regardless of their sexual orientation,
0:53:18 regardless of their gender.
0:53:20 All right, you have grown up
0:53:21 in what is in a capitalist society,
0:53:23 the biggest headwind in your face,
0:53:25 and that is you don’t have money.
0:53:29 And I think it would solve so many problems
0:53:31 and move away from this identity politics
0:53:34 where unfortunately the Democratic Party
0:53:36 has become totally obsessed.
0:53:39 So we’re gonna save the easy stuff for the end here, Jess.
0:53:41 – Can I say before we do the end?
0:53:41 – Of course.
0:53:45 – But in the dissent and the SCOTUS opinion,
0:53:49 Justice Jackson essentially accuses Clarence Thomas
0:53:51 of turning his back on the system
0:53:53 that got Clarence Thomas where he was going.
0:53:56 And I don’t know if I’m ready to fully throw the baby out
0:53:59 with the bathwater and say that there should be no,
0:54:01 race should not be considered at all.
0:54:03 Because I think there are systemic challenges
0:54:06 that face people of color that are different
0:54:09 than the socioeconomic challenges that are out there.
0:54:13 I just, I’m like 75% there.
0:54:18 And I thought that there was some compelling arguments
0:54:21 made by the liberal justices to maintain it.
0:54:22 – But wouldn’t most of that,
0:54:24 so the reason, one of the reasons I love economic based
0:54:27 affirmative action is that it would actually
0:54:30 impact 70% of the same people.
0:54:32 ‘Cause we do still have, you could argue,
0:54:34 an economic apartheid in the United States.
0:54:37 If you’re the daughter of a private equity billionaire
0:54:39 from Taiwan, that’s not diversity.
0:54:41 You don’t need our help, right?
0:54:46 And a lot of kids or a lot of non-whites, like I said,
0:54:50 if you have money, most of those problems
0:54:52 can be addressed and handled.
0:54:54 Anyways, point taken.
0:54:56 This week is a big moment for transgender rights
0:54:59 as the Supreme Court takes on its biggest case yet.
0:55:02 The issue at hand is a Tennessee law banning puberty blockers
0:55:05 and hormone treatments for transgender minors
0:55:07 with over two dozen states having similar laws.
0:55:10 The case is sparking tensions among conservatives
0:55:12 even challenging their usual stance on parental rights.
0:55:16 Jess, what do you think might happen here?
0:55:17 – I mean, it’s a conservative court.
0:55:22 So I imagine it’ll go as many things have now
0:55:23 and they’ll go six, three.
0:55:27 But 26 states now have laws restricting treatments
0:55:28 like puberty blocking drugs.
0:55:30 And what’s interesting about this case,
0:55:32 and it’ll be used as the model.
0:55:36 So it’s the ACLU plus the Biden administration, the DOJ,
0:55:38 I should say, not the Biden administration bringing this.
0:55:41 The problem or what they’re identifying or using
0:55:43 is the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment
0:55:46 that essentially these drugs are being authorized
0:55:48 for non-transgender youths.
0:55:51 So all of the kids that are bringing this case
0:55:53 have been diagnosed with gender dysphoria.
0:55:56 So there are doctors that have said you have this
0:55:58 and they are not getting access to these medications
0:56:02 that kids who do not have gender dysphoria have access to.
0:56:04 So they’re saying it’s discrimination on the basis
0:56:07 of Equal Protection because they’re transgender.
0:56:10 Again, I imagine it’ll get shot down by the court.
0:56:12 I like that they’re taking it at least
0:56:14 and so that we can have this discussion.
0:56:16 It’s when you think that this is going on in 206 states
0:56:18 and even how prominent of a role it played
0:56:22 in our election, conversations around trans issues
0:56:25 and people believing that kids go to school
0:56:27 and come home a different gender.
0:56:29 It’s obviously top of mind for people,
0:56:32 but I’m not optimistic that they’re going to rule
0:56:35 in favor of as one transgender girl
0:56:38 and two transgender boys that have brought the case.
0:56:40 – Yeah, I thought that was great
0:56:42 and I’m gonna plead the fifth on this.
0:56:45 This is something we talk a lot about on Pivot
0:56:47 and I finally come to the conclusion
0:56:49 that I have no fucking idea what I’m talking about
0:56:54 and this issue is so sensitive, so complicated
0:56:59 that I can just see all sides of this issue
0:57:01 or not all sides.
0:57:04 I empathize with so many different viewpoints
0:57:07 and I think this is really another instance
0:57:10 of where government should kind of be out of people’s lives
0:57:15 and let the family and the doctor and the right professionals
0:57:17 and the American Pediatric Association
0:57:19 decide the best solution here.
0:57:21 I think it’s government outreach.
0:57:23 I think the Democratic party has become too obsessed
0:57:26 with this issue and it’s cost us dearly.
0:57:29 At the same time, I’m just absolutely horrified
0:57:31 by the demonization of this group.
0:57:34 At this one, I really do think this is government.
0:57:39 I understand cases that get elevated to the Supreme Court.
0:57:41 This does feel, it’s just so weird.
0:57:44 I feel like Republicans talk such a big game
0:57:46 about staying out of people’s lives and small government
0:57:51 and on the most sensitive, complex, nuanced decisions
0:57:56 they wanna weigh in and it just feels like law enforcement,
0:58:01 the courts should not be in the business of this.
0:58:03 – To that point, the Dobs decision is referenced
0:58:08 over 10 times in this suit for that exact reason.
0:58:13 So small government no more when it comes to sex,
0:58:18 reproduction, trans issues, yeah.
0:58:20 – Yeah, when the left and the right agree on something
0:58:22 it’s usually reckless spending.
0:58:24 All right, that’s all for this episode.
0:58:26 Thank you for listening to Raging Moderates.
0:58:28 Our producers are Caroline Shagren and David Toledo.
0:58:30 Our technical director is Drew Burroughs.
0:58:33 You can find Raging Moderates on its own feed every Tuesday.
0:58:37 That’s right, please if you’re enjoying this episode,
0:58:40 please subscribe to Raging Moderates on its own feed.
0:58:42 Do it right now, follow it up.
0:58:45 Please follow us wherever you get your podcasts.
0:58:47 Just have a great rest of the week.
0:58:48 I’m glad you’re doing it.
0:58:49 – You too, have a great move.
0:58:50 – Yeah.
0:58:58 – Support for this episode comes from AWS.
0:59:01 AWS Generative AI gives you the tools
0:59:03 to power your business forward
0:59:04 with the security and speed
0:59:06 of the world’s most experienced cloud.
0:59:10 (upbeat music)
0:59:14 Autograph Collection Hotels offer over 300
0:59:16 independent hotels around the world,
0:59:19 each exactly like nothing else.
0:59:21 Hands selected for their inherent craft,
0:59:24 each hotel tells its own unique story
0:59:26 through distinctive design and immersive experiences
0:59:30 from medieval falconry to volcanic wine tasting.
0:59:33 Autograph Collection is part of the Marriott Bonvoy
0:59:37 portfolio of over 30 hotel brands around the world.
0:59:40 Find the unforgettable at AutographCollection.com.
0:59:42 you
0:00:07 If you struggle just to get your customers to notice you,
0:00:10 Constant Contact has what you need to grab their attention.
0:00:15 Constant Contact’s award-winning marketing platform offers all the automation,
0:00:20 integration, and reporting tools that get your marketing running seamlessly,
0:00:23 all backed by their expert live customer support.
0:00:27 It’s time to get going and growing with Constant Contact today.
0:00:30 Ready, set, grow.
0:00:34 Go to ConstantContact.ca and start your free trial today.
0:00:43 Go to ConstantContact.ca for your free trial, ConstantContact.ca.
0:00:45 Support for this show comes from Seven Rooms.
0:00:49 For the restaurant operators out there who want to create more regulars on the regular,
0:00:51 check out Seven Rooms.
0:00:55 Seven Rooms is an all-in-one CRM marketing and operations platform
0:00:59 that helps you make more money and more magic for your guests.
0:01:04 It gives your staff the tools to deliver service that keeps your guests coming back for more,
0:01:09 from direct reservations to smart table management to targeted text and email marketing.
0:01:14 Seven Rooms helps you grow your brand and your covers and not your workload.
0:01:17 Learn more at SevenRooms.com.
0:01:20 Seven Rooms. Make magic. Make money.
0:01:23 Support for this episode comes from AWS.
0:01:28 AWS Generative AI gives you the tools to power your business forward
0:01:31 with the security and speed of the world’s most experienced cloud.
0:01:37 Welcome to Raging Moderates. I’m Scott Galloway.
0:01:39 And I’m Jessica Tarleff.
0:01:40 Jessica, it’s time for banter.
0:01:42 Don’t do it.
0:01:44 It’s time for banter.
0:01:46 What were you worried I was going to do so I can do it?
0:01:48 I was going to say, where do I find you today?
0:01:50 And then I would say, in the same place, I always am.
0:01:52 But where are you?
0:01:54 I do not recognize this room.
0:01:56 I’m at home in London and we’re moving.
0:01:59 So I’ve been charged with, I am so good at purging.
0:02:02 I won’t even show it, but I’m literally throwing out like 200 pounds of clothing
0:02:05 and all sorts of stuff.
0:02:06 But I’m back in London.
0:02:07 I’ve been here two days.
0:02:10 Already can’t wait to get out.
0:02:14 The weather, I don’t know if you’ve heard the weather here is awful, Jess.
0:02:15 The weather here is awful.
0:02:16 I lived there six years.
0:02:20 I actually started using happy bulbs after like three.
0:02:23 I gave in and said, oh, this is legit depressing.
0:02:25 I need a lift at home.
0:02:26 So people don’t know this.
0:02:27 I don’t think people know.
0:02:29 You got a PhD at the London School of Economics.
0:02:30 Is that right?
0:02:31 It is right.
0:02:33 And what did you get your PhD in?
0:02:34 It was in the government department.
0:02:38 I guess it was like technically political economy, but yeah.
0:02:39 So impressive.
0:02:41 And did you enjoy living here?
0:02:42 Would you ever move back?
0:02:43 Yeah, we would love to do.
0:02:46 I mean, we never lived there together, me and my husband,
0:02:49 but he has an office there, which is appealing.
0:02:51 But I, as of now, couldn’t work there.
0:02:54 But once all of this pans out for us,
0:02:56 I’m sure I’ll be able to work anywhere in the world.
0:02:57 There you go.
0:02:59 So all right, our producer’s getting angry at me.
0:03:00 Let’s move on.
0:03:04 In today’s show, we’re discussing Biden’s pardon for a sunhunter,
0:03:08 Trump’s tariff proposals, and appointment of cash Patel,
0:03:11 and why companies are rolling back DEI initiatives.
0:03:12 All right, let’s do it.
0:03:16 On Sunday night, President Biden pardoned his sunhunter,
0:03:18 wiping out convictions for gun and tax crimes
0:03:22 and covering potential federal offenses from 2014 to 2024,
0:03:25 including his barisma dealings.
0:03:29 This reverses Biden’s earlier promise not to pardon hunter.
0:03:31 The clemency council sentencing emblocks
0:03:33 any future prosecution with courts expected
0:03:35 to dismiss all charges.
0:03:37 Reactions, as you might have guessed, have been mixed,
0:03:38 even among Democrats.
0:03:40 With Colorado’s governor, Jared Polis, tweeting,
0:03:43 while as a father, I certainly understand President Joe Biden’s
0:03:45 natural desire to help his son by pardoning him,
0:03:48 I am disappointed that he put his family ahead of the country.
0:03:52 Trump posted on Truth Social, does the pardon given by Joe
0:03:55 to Hunter, including the January 6th hostages who have now
0:03:57 been in prison for years, such an abuse
0:03:59 and miscarriage of justice?
0:04:02 J6’s referring to January 6th insurrection.
0:04:06 Jess, did you see this coming, and what are your thoughts here?
0:04:08 I guess I always thought it was feasible,
0:04:10 though we talked about it on air, and I said,
0:04:11 he said he’s not going to do it.
0:04:14 And you have to take him at his word.
0:04:16 I think that he thought he was going to win the election,
0:04:19 or that Kamala Harris was going to win the election,
0:04:21 and then maybe things were going to be different.
0:04:24 But back against the wall, the sentencing, I think,
0:04:26 is coming up this week.
0:04:30 And apparently, at NBC, I think, is reporting
0:04:35 that they decided in June to say that he was never
0:04:38 going to pardon Hunter, even though it was still on the table,
0:04:39 which feels definitely deceitful.
0:04:40 So there’s a lie, right?
0:04:43 There is a lie in this, in him saying that.
0:04:47 But I think with the timing that he saw Trump make
0:04:50 Charles Kushner, who–
0:04:54 Jared Kushner’s dad, who did one of the more insane things.
0:04:57 You know this story about how his brother-in-law was
0:04:59 cooperating with the feds against him,
0:05:01 so he sent a prostitute to seduce him,
0:05:04 and then sent the tape of it to his sister.
0:05:08 He exposed that her husband was cheating with a prostitute,
0:05:11 because he was cooperating on other crimes
0:05:13 that he actually didn’t end up being convicted of.
0:05:15 So I think he saw that Charles Kushner is going
0:05:17 to be the ambassador to France.
0:05:19 Trump’s pardoned everyone and their mother.
0:05:25 And he’s also appointing people to his cabinet,
0:05:31 who openly want to put Hunter away to avenge enemies
0:05:33 from the press, people who went after him
0:05:37 for the “Russia hoax,” “Russia collusion hoax.”
0:05:40 And so I think he just said, like, eff it.
0:05:44 Like, I have a few more months with power,
0:05:46 and I’m going to protect my kid.
0:05:48 I think you nailed it.
0:05:53 You know, on the downside here, we are kind of devolving
0:05:55 into that place, right?
0:05:58 I remember when Speaker McCarthy got so upset
0:06:02 about some of the holdouts, he kind of stormed up
0:06:05 the aisle of the rotunda, and it felt like we might
0:06:07 become that nation or South Korea that every 18 months,
0:06:11 the Congress breaks into fisticuffs.
0:06:13 And I feel like we become that nation.
0:06:18 And that is we now have people in power abusing their power.
0:06:20 This is an abuse of power.
0:06:22 And I don’t believe– I believe if Harris had won,
0:06:24 he wouldn’t have done it.
0:06:28 I think the expectations now have become so low,
0:06:33 and you get so little reward for trying to live up
0:06:36 to the expectations and acquit yourself
0:06:37 as past presidents have.
0:06:39 You actually get dinged for it.
0:06:41 It’s not even like no reward.
0:06:45 I feel like you’re penalized for being ethical.
0:06:47 Well, that’s a fair point.
0:06:50 And I just want to be clear.
0:06:53 If I were President Biden, I would do the exact same thing.
0:06:56 If I’m– I mean, the guy’s not going to be around,
0:07:00 I doubt, much longer, or he’s definitely on the back nine.
0:07:03 And my sense of his son, pure speculation,
0:07:06 struggled with addiction, loves his dad immensely,
0:07:09 trying to get his life together, I think.
0:07:10 A total fuck-up.
0:07:14 You know, one of his kids killed in an auto accident.
0:07:17 His other son died of a brain tumor.
0:07:20 His one son loves him immensely.
0:07:23 And then he sees, as you said, OK, let me get this.
0:07:27 The president’s son-in-law’s dad gets pardoned
0:07:30 and then becomes the ambassador to France.
0:07:31 Fuck it.
0:07:33 I mean, that’s exactly right.
0:07:35 I would have done the exact same thing.
0:07:39 And the problem is it’s become a race to the bottom
0:07:43 where no behavior now seems off limits or shocking.
0:07:47 So this is a weird analogy, but I’m aggressive on my taxes.
0:07:49 I don’t do anything illegal.
0:07:52 And for a long time, I’m like, no, it’s good to pay taxes.
0:07:55 And I thought, why am I disarming unilaterally?
0:07:58 You know, no one’s going to say at your funeral
0:08:00 that he was great, he paid more taxes
0:08:02 than he really needed to.
0:08:04 And it’s the same thing here.
0:08:05 It’s like, let me get this.
0:08:08 These guys, this guy’s going to pardon
0:08:11 the Duck Dynasty insurrectionists.
0:08:13 I’m going to potentially pardon people
0:08:15 who have been campaign donors.
0:08:16 You mentioned the Kushner.
0:08:18 By the way, that’s got to be–
0:08:22 I would love a Thanksgiving with the Kushners.
0:08:28 I know the kid, Jared, I like him, he was my student.
0:08:31 His brother seems like a total baller.
0:08:33 His brother’s also married to a supermodel.
0:08:35 I’ve always liked Ivanka, I’ve met her once or twice.
0:08:37 She’s always been nice to me.
0:08:44 But I definitely want the father, his wife, the prostitute.
0:08:46 I just think it would make for such an interesting Thanksgiving.
0:08:48 I got to think their Thanksgiving
0:08:50 is one of the more interesting Thanksgiving.
0:08:52 And we should do it at the US Ambassador’s Ship in Paris,
0:08:56 which, by the way, is literally the coolest
0:08:58 Ambassador residence in the world.
0:09:00 But back to our central theme here.
0:09:03 This is the problem with an administration
0:09:06 that is descended into essentially a kleptocracy
0:09:09 that has absolutely no moral standards.
0:09:13 Is the other side goes, well, why the fuck are we
0:09:17 trying to pretend to be ethical when there’s no payoff?
0:09:20 When the market and the public doesn’t seem to mind?
0:09:24 If I’m an 82-year-old father, yeah, I’m pardoning my son.
0:09:26 I would have done the exact same thing.
0:09:29 Yeah, that seems to be the overwhelming response,
0:09:32 putting aside Governor Polis, who also
0:09:35 had quite the hot take on RFK Jr.
0:09:39 that he got destroyed over when that nomination came out.
0:09:42 But generally speaking, hardcore Dems
0:09:44 seemed to be like, yeah, OK.
0:09:46 And it was also time to have some backbone.
0:09:50 And one of the main complaints that I feel like rank and file
0:09:53 Dems have is that we have no Mitch McConnells amongst us,
0:09:58 no one who’s ruthless enough to not give Garland a hearing.
0:10:03 And that they’re mad at Merrick Garland once he became AG,
0:10:06 that he took two years to appoint Jack Smith to look
0:10:10 into all of these crimes that Trump has alleged–
0:10:12 we’re supposed to say alleged, though everything’s
0:10:13 been dismissed now–
0:10:14 committed.
0:10:16 We just sat around for too long.
0:10:17 And now all of it is gone.
0:10:18 Poof.
0:10:20 The Republicans never would have done that.
0:10:22 They take every swing.
0:10:24 And if they miss, so what?
0:10:25 I’ll put someone in.
0:10:26 You swing with Matt Gaetz.
0:10:27 Guess what?
0:10:31 You got Pam Bondi, who’s kind of like Matt Gaetz in a dress
0:10:34 and a bit more confident, which I guess is a good thing.
0:10:36 We’ll see how that bears out.
0:10:40 But one point that Dave Weigel, friend of the pod,
0:10:41 if we can say that–
0:10:42 I always like that term–
0:10:48 made was that if you read the text of what Biden said,
0:10:51 his point was that he still believes in the rule of law,
0:10:55 but that this was an abuse of the law for political reasons.
0:10:59 And Weigel harkened back to the defense that Bill Clinton gave
0:11:01 in the ’90s, why he was pardoning people,
0:11:03 and he thought that all of it was just junk.
0:11:05 He’s like, this is all just politically motivated.
0:11:07 If you get me on something that’s actually a crime,
0:11:10 and he perjured himself, and that is bad,
0:11:11 and you shouldn’t have done that.
0:11:16 But the point is, no one cares about who I’m having sex with,
0:11:20 except for Ken Starr and rabid Republicans.
0:11:21 And so this doesn’t actually have anything
0:11:23 to do with my competency.
0:11:26 It doesn’t have anything to do with how I do my job.
0:11:29 And so I’m not going to treat this as the real world,
0:11:31 and I’m going to pardon people that are associated with it,
0:11:34 and I’m going to move on with my life, and frankly,
0:11:36 think pretty highly of myself still.
0:11:39 And that’s clearly the tack that Joe Biden was taking.
0:11:42 I thought that was a really interesting and smart take on this.
0:11:44 I don’t know if you have a ’90s reflection, but–
0:11:47 But don’t you think Republicans could claim the same thing
0:11:51 that the New York case, the Albenberg case against Donald
0:11:55 Trump, again, it was about sex, that that was also purely
0:12:01 politically motivated, and if so, should warrant a pardon?
0:12:03 Well, yeah, I don’t know.
0:12:07 I shouldn’t– that, yeah, sounded too enthusiastic for me.
0:12:14 I was always the weakest case, and I think part of living
0:12:17 in the conservative media world that I do because of work
0:12:22 is that I can see that it’s glaring at me, because I’m like,
0:12:24 OK, this is one that they can so easily take apart,
0:12:27 but they struggle more with the Mar-a-Lago documents, right?
0:12:29 Or I guess you could kind of tit for tat
0:12:31 wasn’t an insurrection or not, but there’s
0:12:34 so much testimony surrounding January 6
0:12:37 and how this was planned, that Trump was like,
0:12:38 this is how we’re going to do it.
0:12:40 We’re just going to overturn the elections.
0:12:42 We’re going to fan the lawyers out all the swing states,
0:12:43 et cetera.
0:12:45 So yeah, you could make that argument.
0:12:47 And Tish James hasn’t helped anyone
0:12:50 by giving 50 press conferences where she just says,
0:12:54 I will stop at nothing, right, until Donald Trump is behind bars.
0:12:57 So you could totally make that argument.
0:12:59 But I don’t know, there’s so much other stuff
0:13:04 that he was indicted on, and that juries found him guilty of,
0:13:06 that I think he goes beyond it.
0:13:09 But the Stormy Daniels case was always the weakest,
0:13:12 and it was annoying, frankly, that it happened,
0:13:13 and that it went first.
0:13:16 You brought up a really interesting point,
0:13:19 and that is we suffer from a lack of mendacious fucks.
0:13:23 And that is McConnell was always playing us,
0:13:27 and everyone was just so disgusted and disappointed.
0:13:29 I’m like, well, where are our Senator McConnells?
0:13:32 Is it Representative Nadler?
0:13:35 Quite frankly, and I hope this election does it.
0:13:37 I hope they just clean house the Democratic leadership.
0:13:39 I want to see Jeremy Raskin.
0:13:43 I think Speaker Pelosi has a touch of Machiavelli to her.
0:13:45 I think she’s outstanding.
0:13:48 Senator Schumer, I think is incredibly weak.
0:13:49 I think he’s weak.
0:13:51 I don’t think he has nearly the strategy or the sack
0:13:53 that McConnell has demonstrated.
0:13:57 And we need just some ruthless motherfuckers in there.
0:14:01 And it’ll be interesting to see if Representative Jeffries
0:14:04 brings that kind of Machiavellian strategy.
0:14:07 Everything against Hunter Biden was a function
0:14:10 of who they were or who they are, not of the crimes.
0:14:13 No one, had it not been Donald Trump,
0:14:16 if he paid off a mistress, a porn star,
0:14:18 I just don’t think that would have ended up in court.
0:14:22 I think that that is a misuse of prosecutorial resources.
0:14:24 Hunter Biden, that was bullshit.
0:14:26 He would have gotten some charges fine.
0:14:28 He would have been on probation.
0:14:30 This is the idea I like,
0:14:32 and I think you’re gonna like this.
0:14:34 All right, gun charge.
0:14:35 He’s handsome.
0:14:36 He’s made porn films.
0:14:37 He’s been pardoned.
0:14:39 I think he’s our answer.
0:14:40 I think he has,
0:14:41 I think he’s now the number three
0:14:43 or number four most likely Democratic nominee
0:14:45 for president in 2028.
0:14:48 I think Hunter Biden is the Democrat we need right now,
0:14:49 Jess.
0:14:50 What do you think?
0:14:51 I mean, I’m not against it.
0:14:54 Think of all the bumper stickers we have that we can use.
0:14:56 Biden, Biden for president, yeah.
0:15:00 Yeah, I mean, we have weirder things happen.
0:15:02 Maybe Donald Trump, yeah.
0:15:04 Right, all right, we need to move on.
0:15:07 All right, last week, Elon Musk celebrated Thanksgiving
0:15:08 with Trump at Mar-a-Lago,
0:15:11 as he gears up for his new dojo role
0:15:13 and meets with House Republicans this week.
0:15:15 Just before the holiday, President-elect Trump proposed
0:15:17 25% tariffs on goods from Mexico and Canada,
0:15:21 raising serious concerns among business and world leaders.
0:15:22 Mexico has warned that such a move
0:15:24 could cost nearly half a million U.S. jobs
0:15:27 while a company spirit will drive up prices for consumers.
0:15:29 President Biden is urging Trump to reconsider,
0:15:31 warning that tariffs could strain relationships
0:15:34 with key allies, have inflationary effects at home,
0:15:36 and result in higher prices across the board.
0:15:38 Jess, what do you think is gonna happen here?
0:15:40 Do you think it’ll fall through on this?
0:15:43 To some degree, I don’t think it’ll be a 25% tariff,
0:15:46 but I’m sure that he’ll sprinkle them around
0:15:49 and Scott Besen, who will be the Treasury Secretary,
0:15:52 is naturally not a tariff guy.
0:15:55 I think that was one of the kind of final sticking points
0:15:57 to make sure that he was gonna be on board
0:16:02 with this approach of using it as a way to cultivate results.
0:16:04 And I don’t think that that’s insane.
0:16:06 And we should, you gotta be honest about the fact
0:16:08 that Biden kept nearly all of the tariffs
0:16:10 that Trump had put on China.
0:16:13 He’s done things, I think a little bit smarter.
0:16:16 Like he put tariffs on things that we don’t get as much of,
0:16:18 like EVs, for instance.
0:16:20 We don’t get a ton of them from China.
0:16:22 So like it makes sense to kind of hike that up
0:16:25 so it doesn’t really hurt the American consumer base.
0:16:29 But tariffs aren’t unilaterally a stupid idea.
0:16:31 It’s stupid to say I’m gonna put 100% tariff on this
0:16:33 or I’m gonna put 25% on Canada and Mexico.
0:16:36 He doesn’t talk about, what is it like something insane?
0:16:39 Like 60% of our vegetables come from Mexico.
0:16:42 Our construction supplies that come from Canada.
0:16:45 But what I think is the interesting corollary
0:16:48 to Trump doing all this bluster
0:16:51 is what will the world leaders’ responses be?
0:16:53 Because we have two different prototypes now.
0:16:56 So Claudia Scheinbaum, the president of Mexico
0:16:57 had a very different response
0:16:59 than Justin Trudeau from Canada.
0:17:00 So Justin Trudeau is like,
0:17:02 “Hey, Donald, I’m coming to Mar-a-Lago for dinner.
0:17:04 “Let’s do the photo op, I’ll meet your people.
0:17:05 “This’ll be great.”
0:17:08 And Claudia Scheinbaum released a pretty scathing statement
0:17:09 that essentially said, like,
0:17:11 “You don’t know what you’re talking about.”
0:17:14 Because Trump said, “I’m gonna put this tariff on
0:17:17 “if you don’t stop sending migrants and drugs here.”
0:17:19 And she first of all said, “By the way,
0:17:22 “all of the guns that are here are from your country.”
0:17:23 So maybe you could figure that out.
0:17:26 And second of all, we have been stopping the migrants.
0:17:29 And according to your own CPV numbers,
0:17:32 it’s down, crossings are down 75% in the last year
0:17:35 because of a program that we put in.
0:17:38 Now, is anyone paying attention to the fact
0:17:39 that that’s what she said?
0:17:41 No, because Trump went and said,
0:17:44 “See, presto chango, it happened right away, right?
0:17:46 “Like I said jump and she said how high
0:17:48 “and now everything’s fine.”
0:17:50 As if he stopped migrants from crossing the border,
0:17:52 it happened under Biden.
0:17:54 But those are the two different models.
0:17:57 And I’m curious to see where other world leaders fall on that.
0:17:59 Like who will be going to kiss the ring
0:18:01 and who will be issuing sassy statements?
0:18:02 It will be the Jewish woman
0:18:04 that is issuing the sassy statement.
0:18:07 The Jewish climate scientist, that’s right.
0:18:09 Yeah, I love, it tickles my sensors
0:18:12 to see her saying this and she’s right.
0:18:13 Trudeau’s probably smarter.
0:18:16 My understanding is among world leaders
0:18:19 is just go kiss this guy’s ass, pull a Tim Cook.
0:18:23 Tim Cook goes there, shows him the new iPhone,
0:18:25 it tells him he’s handsome, complements him.
0:18:26 Love your playlist.
0:18:27 Love your playlist.
0:18:28 And what do you know?
0:18:30 Somehow the tariffs on China,
0:18:33 Apple manages to sequester the majority
0:18:36 of their components from those tariffs.
0:18:41 This sycophantry, this obvious pandering, it works.
0:18:43 And to be fair, some of the tariffs
0:18:47 that Trump increased on China, Biden kept in place.
0:18:49 While China is no longer our biggest trading partner,
0:18:53 it’s now a tossup between Mexico and Canada.
0:18:55 There’s just so many wrinkles here.
0:18:59 Most US cars have parts from Mexico or Canada.
0:19:02 And the way this all ends, in my view,
0:19:05 is he implements anything resembling these tariffs,
0:19:07 which any of these,
0:19:09 one of the most heartening things about these appointments
0:19:12 is it almost seems like I’m gonna fuck
0:19:14 with the American people, I’m just gonna reward loyalists.
0:19:16 I don’t care about the DOJ,
0:19:18 I don’t care about the education.
0:19:20 But when it comes to the economy,
0:19:23 it feels like he becomes remarkably adult.
0:19:26 And he wants adults in the room around the key,
0:19:27 key appointments around the economy.
0:19:29 I think the majority of those candidates
0:19:31 all seem like adults, all seem qualified.
0:19:33 I don’t think many of them are gonna go
0:19:34 for this tariff thing, at least nothing.
0:19:36 I think they’ll throw them a bone and say,
0:19:38 okay, we’ll increase tariffs here, here and here.
0:19:41 But the first quarter, or even the first month,
0:19:44 where it looks like there’s a spike,
0:19:47 a re-spike in inflation, or a reigniting of inflation,
0:19:50 and it’s reverse engineered to tariffs,
0:19:52 oh, there’s trouble in Mudville.
0:19:56 Because the thing that brings down nations
0:19:58 is not usually that they get invaded,
0:20:01 it’s they either go broke or there’s inflation.
0:20:03 Because you wanna talk about rage,
0:20:06 when you have to go from meat to chicken, chicken to rice,
0:20:08 and then you can’t pay for your kid’s summer camp,
0:20:10 you don’t care who’s in office.
0:20:11 When they realize 88% of gifts
0:20:14 under the Christmas tree are from China,
0:20:17 and that their prices might go up 10, 20, 50%,
0:20:19 and that to a certain extent,
0:20:23 Trump becomes a lame duck president sooner rather than later,
0:20:26 I think they find their backbone and say,
0:20:29 no, I am not down with these tariffs at all.
0:20:33 And the moment, the moment inflation starts to spike back,
0:20:36 which we’re already seeing some evidence of,
0:20:39 in someone reverse engineers it to tariffs, boom,
0:20:40 that dog won’t hunt.
0:20:43 I think this is much more,
0:20:45 much more hat than cattle, what’s the term?
0:20:47 That’s a Brian Williams term, hat and cattle.
0:20:49 All hat, no cattle.
0:20:50 All chip, no salsa.
0:20:51 – Sounds very Yellowstone.
0:20:53 – There you go.
0:20:54 By the way, I could never get into Yellowstone.
0:20:55 Did you like it?
0:20:56 – Really?
0:20:57 I did the first couple of years,
0:20:59 and then I just thought it was ridiculous, but.
0:21:01 – I just didn’t buy it, I just didn’t buy it.
0:21:04 I thought it was succession for Republicans.
0:21:05 I didn’t buy it.
0:21:07 – Well, they deserve to have joy too.
0:21:09 – Yeah, I don’t know, I don’t get it.
0:21:10 – Just to add to that,
0:21:13 it was interesting to see when Scott Besant
0:21:17 was the treasury pick, the market bumped up.
0:21:19 Was very excited with the news.
0:21:22 The next day, this was after his truth social post
0:21:24 about the tariffs coming, market goes down, right?
0:21:26 It was the same thing with RFK Junior, right?
0:21:30 Then all of the pharmaceutical stocks tanked.
0:21:33 So Trump is going to have to figure out
0:21:36 where his levers are, like how much he can push things,
0:21:41 how much he can pull things in order to keep us making 30%,
0:21:44 or whatever crazy amount the market has been going up,
0:21:47 because that is the only thing
0:21:49 that people are grading these administrations on.
0:21:51 It’s crazy, because all this other stuff
0:21:53 that went on during the Trump administration,
0:21:54 no one remembers it.
0:21:56 They only remember this feeling of,
0:21:59 this is what my gas costs, this is how much toilet paper was,
0:22:01 this is how before COVID came,
0:22:03 when obviously everything became terrible
0:22:03 and super expensive,
0:22:05 and people didn’t even blame him for that,
0:22:07 which is very annoying to me as a partisan,
0:22:11 but he just wants to leave with a good economic record
0:22:14 and probably put away some enemies if he can,
0:22:17 Hunter Biden included, definitely was gonna be on the list.
0:22:21 So I think he’ll just be watching those numbers closely.
0:22:23 And I remember when we first started
0:22:24 talking about the potential picks,
0:22:28 and you said, why not bring back Steve Mnuchin?
0:22:31 And Steve Mnuchin left completely unscathed, right?
0:22:33 His wife was this incredible viral meme
0:22:35 that I enjoyed all the time.
0:22:37 And it seems like he did a pretty good job,
0:22:39 and I imagine Scott Bassant will be similar.
0:22:41 Yeah. – He’s an adult.
0:22:43 And by the way, just you were right,
0:22:45 Mexico is now our biggest trading partner.
0:22:46 In the last seven years,
0:22:50 China’s gone from 22% of US imports,
0:22:53 it’s dropped to 14, that’s a dramatic decrease.
0:22:56 And Mexico has gone up from approximately 13
0:22:58 to now close to 16,
0:23:03 and Canada has gone from about 12 and a half to about 14.
0:23:08 So Mexico and Canada, it’s so interesting.
0:23:11 Trade is still largely a function of proximity.
0:23:14 Almost every country’s biggest trading partners usually,
0:23:15 they usually share a border with.
0:23:17 Anyways, some more fascinating insight
0:23:19 from the Northwestern School of Business.
0:23:22 All right, Jess, let’s take a quick break, stay with us.
0:23:29 Support for Prop G comes from Quintz.
0:23:32 Let’s be honest, not every gift we pick is a home run.
0:23:33 But what if I told you,
0:23:35 there was a secret reliable way
0:23:36 to get everyone on your list,
0:23:38 something they’ll actually enjoy,
0:23:39 one that doesn’t cost a fortune.
0:23:43 Okay, it’s not a secret actually, it’s just Quintz.
0:23:45 Quintz makes it easy to treat everyone in your life
0:23:48 to luxury quality clothing at frankly,
0:23:50 ridiculously affordable prices,
0:23:53 pieces including their iconic Mongolian cashmere sweaters,
0:23:54 which started just 50 bucks,
0:23:56 are guaranteed crowd pleasers.
0:23:58 They’re warm, stylish, and best of all, affordable.
0:24:01 In fact, all of Quintz’s luxury items are priced
0:24:03 50 to 80% less than similar brands.
0:24:06 Plus, Quintz says they only work with factories
0:24:07 that use safe, ethical,
0:24:10 and responsible manufacturing practices.
0:24:12 Our own Caroline Shagerin got to try out Quintz,
0:24:14 and she says she loves it.
0:24:16 Caroline loves her sage green Quintz sheets.
0:24:19 They’re comfortable and well made.
0:24:20 Gift luxury this holiday season
0:24:22 without the luxury price tag,
0:24:26 go to quintz.com/propg for 365 day returns,
0:24:28 plus free shipping on your order.
0:24:31 That’s Q-U-I-N-C-E.com/propg
0:24:34 to get free shipping and 365 day returns.
0:24:36 Quintz.com/propg.
0:24:42 Support for PropG comes from GiveDirectly.
0:24:43 The holidays are a great time
0:24:45 to make a charitable donation to a cause you care about.
0:24:46 But how do you know if your money
0:24:48 is actually helping the people who need it most?
0:24:51 Well, if you want to get cash directly to people in need,
0:24:54 consider donate to GiveDirectly.
0:24:56 GiveDirectly believes that cash allows people
0:24:58 the dignity and freedom to make their own decisions
0:25:00 about how they can improve their lives.
0:25:01 That’s because every person,
0:25:03 regardless of their financial status,
0:25:06 has their own specific needs, preferences, and aspirations.
0:25:09 And people living in poverty deserve to have a say
0:25:11 in how to best invest in their future,
0:25:14 whether that’s housing, education, business support,
0:25:14 and more.
0:25:18 In fact, many academic studies show that cash transfers
0:25:20 can improve earnings, health, education, and much more.
0:25:24 That’s why GiveDirectly lets you do exactly that.
0:25:25 GiveDirectly to those who need it.
0:25:27 Your donation this holiday season has the power
0:25:30 to lift families and entire communities
0:25:31 out of extreme poverty.
0:25:34 To learn more and send money directly to people
0:25:35 living in extreme poverty,
0:25:38 visit GiveDirectly.org/profty.
0:25:43 Support for Profty comes from open phone.
0:25:46 Running a small business means you’re wearing a lot of hats.
0:25:48 Your personal phone becomes your business phone,
0:25:49 and before you know it,
0:25:51 your juggling customer calls day and night.
0:25:53 As your team grows, it becomes impossible
0:25:54 to manage with your personal number.
0:25:56 That’s where open phone comes in.
0:25:59 Open phone is the business phone system
0:26:00 that can help you separate your personal life
0:26:03 from your growing business for just $15 a month.
0:26:06 Open phone works through an app on your phone or computer
0:26:09 and integrates with HubSpot and hundreds of other systems.
0:26:11 Their AI-powered transcription feature
0:26:13 can even summarize your phone calls
0:26:15 with action items as soon as you hang up.
0:26:16 And if you miss a call,
0:26:19 automated messages are sent directly to your customer,
0:26:20 meaning you’ll never miss an opportunity
0:26:22 to engage with them.
0:26:24 Right now, open phone is offering 20% off
0:26:28 your first six months when you go to openphone.com/profty.
0:26:31 That’s O-P-E-N-P-H-O-N-E.
0:26:35 .com/profty for 20% off six months.
0:26:37 Open phone.com/profty.
0:26:40 And if you have existing numbers with another service,
0:26:43 open phone will port them over at no extra charge.
0:26:49 – Welcome back on Saturday.
0:26:51 Trump shook things up.
0:26:52 That’s another statement.
0:26:55 By picking Cash Patel, a controversial maga loyalist
0:26:58 and deep state conspiracy theorist to lead the FBI.
0:27:00 This is an unusual move because FBI directors
0:27:03 typically serve 10-year terms to stay above politics.
0:27:06 This all comes as Trump considers firing Christopher Wray,
0:27:08 his own appointee with three years left on his term,
0:27:10 all while doubling down on promises
0:27:12 to prosecute political opponents.
0:27:14 What’s your take on this, Josh?
0:27:16 – Same as every week.
0:27:17 This is bad, no bueno.
0:27:18 This is very bad.
0:27:20 I mean, there’s so much to go through
0:27:23 in the craziness of Cash Patel.
0:27:26 But something that does stick out to me
0:27:31 is that other Trump loyalists have a worldview
0:27:34 that they come to the table with.
0:27:36 Like Steve Bannon wasn’t born the day
0:27:38 that Trump came down the golden staircase, right?
0:27:42 And Stephen Miller has had his views for a very long time.
0:27:46 Cash Patel is like a blank slate
0:27:49 that was created in Trump’s ideological likeness.
0:27:53 Like he has nothing seemingly that he believes in
0:27:56 that existed before Donald Trump.
0:28:00 And that’s what makes him uniquely frightening to me
0:28:03 because he just lives to please this guy.
0:28:06 I mean, he even wrote a children’s book about him.
0:28:09 Like he mimics everything he has.
0:28:14 He like hawks clothes.
0:28:15 He has a clothing line.
0:28:18 He works his business.
0:28:19 I think it’s the Cash Foundation,
0:28:21 which gives to people affected
0:28:24 by the terrible atrocities of January 6th,
0:28:27 like families of January 6thers, J6ers,
0:28:29 I think we’re supposed to call them.
0:28:31 He produced Justice for All,
0:28:32 which is a version of the national anthem
0:28:35 that the January 6th defendants
0:28:36 that Trump played at his first campaign rally.
0:28:40 Like he is so enmeshed in this world.
0:28:45 He feels like a Trump child more than the others do.
0:28:46 To me.
0:28:48 – Yeah, this guy is a little bit,
0:28:51 during his time where I believe he was,
0:28:52 what did he do?
0:28:54 He was a prosecutor.
0:28:54 – Yeah, he was a prosecutor.
0:28:56 He worked for Devin Nunes.
0:28:58 You remember him, who was crazy.
0:28:59 – Okay.
0:29:01 – And he did have some high level intel jobs.
0:29:04 He was the deputy to acting DNI, Rick Grinnell.
0:29:07 – He supposedly also fed Trump back channel information
0:29:09 on Ukraine that contributed to Trump’s plot
0:29:11 to push that nation to help him smear
0:29:14 his political opponents during his time.
0:29:17 Patel also authored a memo arguing that it was disloyal
0:29:19 for then defense secretary, Mark Esper,
0:29:20 who I’ve met and strikes me
0:29:22 as a world-class high character person,
0:29:25 to oppose a request by Trump to deploy military troops
0:29:26 against American citizens,
0:29:30 protesting police violence against black people.
0:29:32 After Trump lost to President Biden in 2020,
0:29:35 Patel pushed lies about the election being stolen
0:29:37 and argued that reporters debunking Trump’s election lies
0:29:39 should be targeted by the government.
0:29:42 He said, open quote, yes,
0:29:44 we’re going to come after the people in the media
0:29:46 who lied about American citizens
0:29:48 who helped Joe Biden rig presidential elections.
0:29:52 We’re going to come after you, close quote.
0:29:53 I mean, I don’t know.
0:29:56 And he’s also authored three children’s books
0:29:58 that are pro-Trump fan fiction.
0:30:01 So going after your political enemies
0:30:03 and finding time to write children’s books,
0:30:04 you gotta give it to the guy.
0:30:06 He’s at least a little,
0:30:08 he’s sort of a Renaissance man in hell, so to speak.
0:30:13 He’s just sort of this, he’s a bit of an odd duck.
0:30:14 And also I’ve always found that,
0:30:19 I thought Christopher Wray, it’s exactly what you want
0:30:22 as an appointee because when he sat in front of Congress,
0:30:24 I couldn’t tell if he was a Democrat or a Republican.
0:30:26 I just thought he was, you know,
0:30:29 like Joe Friday from “Dragonate”, just a fax, ma’am.
0:30:32 And he was, I just thought he was so good
0:30:33 and landed so much credibility
0:30:35 to the Trump administration that, okay,
0:30:37 in these important roles,
0:30:40 you have someone like this, you see above partisanship,
0:30:42 but, you know, the same way,
0:30:46 I do think he’s acting that way on the economics appointments.
0:30:47 And he used to act that way,
0:30:49 at least a little bit on security appointments
0:30:50 and defense appointments.
0:30:53 He seems to have totally lost that now.
0:30:57 And it’s so, just culturally,
0:30:59 it’s gotta be so demoralizing.
0:31:01 There are FBI agents.
0:31:04 I mean, first off, Tulsi Gabbard to me is by far,
0:31:06 other than gets as the most outrageous,
0:31:10 I actually think the most dangerous
0:31:11 is Representative Gabbard,
0:31:15 ’cause there are people that spend their entire lives,
0:31:16 the majority of their professional lives,
0:31:18 putting themselves in harm’s way,
0:31:19 knowing that if they caught,
0:31:20 they’re not just gonna be killed,
0:31:22 they’re gonna be tortured and killed,
0:31:24 implanting themselves in high-level positions
0:31:27 with a lot of access within our adversaries.
0:31:30 And there are only two people who know who they are.
0:31:34 There are Case Handler and the head of, you know,
0:31:37 the CIA or the head of the security services.
0:31:40 And I just gotta think, if I’m that person,
0:31:43 I do not want Representative Gabbard knowing who I am.
0:31:45 This is someone who met with Assad,
0:31:47 who’s been an apologist for the Kremlin.
0:31:49 There’s no evidence he’s an actual asset,
0:31:51 but I can see here, like,
0:31:55 if I’m an undercover agent or officer with the CIA,
0:31:57 and I think this individual might decide
0:32:01 it’s good for America to out all undercover assets
0:32:03 in the Kremlin, I’m out.
0:32:07 I’m not risking my life in limb and staying away
0:32:11 from my family when this person who doesn’t seem,
0:32:14 who seems to be more fond of Putin than of Democrats,
0:32:15 I’m out.
0:32:18 And the one thing that the majority of, I think,
0:32:21 our presidents and our directors of national security
0:32:23 and the heads of CIA have had,
0:32:26 I think George Bush was the head of the CIA and president.
0:32:27 I believe most case officers of the CIA
0:32:29 probably thought George Bush would die for me.
0:32:32 This is someone who would die for his country.
0:32:34 And I think these people are like,
0:32:37 no, they would let me die under some fucked up notion
0:32:41 of what they think is some sort of conspiracy theory.
0:32:43 This is, she is a dangerous appointment
0:32:46 and having this guy as head of the FBI,
0:32:51 I just gotta think that is so incredibly damaging
0:32:53 to morale ’cause I’ve always thought of the FBI
0:32:57 is there’s just a few places where they really,
0:32:59 they put country above politics.
0:33:02 They say, presidents are gonna come and go,
0:33:05 political parties are gonna come and go,
0:33:07 I am about our country, fidelity to the country
0:33:10 and finding bad guys.
0:33:14 And now this place has been weaponized politically
0:33:17 and I don’t know if I can trust these people.
0:33:18 – But there are millions of people who think
0:33:21 that it was the Democrats that weaponized the FBI
0:33:24 who look at Andy McCabe and his text messages
0:33:28 with Lisa Page, they go back to Jim Comey.
0:33:31 I mean, listen, the firing of Jim Comey,
0:33:34 I will never understand since I think he was
0:33:37 the key ingredient in Trump being able to win,
0:33:39 actually him coming out 11 days before the election
0:33:43 and saying, we looked at Anthony Wiener’s laptop again,
0:33:44 like no biggie though.
0:33:46 And then everyone thought that,
0:33:49 she had done something unbelievably evil.
0:33:54 But this is, Cash Patel is part of the wrecking ball approach
0:33:56 to all of these institutions.
0:34:01 And I don’t think that he would be able to get confirmed,
0:34:05 but it seems like that’s not even necessarily the approach
0:34:07 that Trump feels like he needs to go.
0:34:10 So Christopher Wray has a 10 year term,
0:34:11 so he’s three years left on his term,
0:34:12 but he can be fired.
0:34:16 So let’s say that happens January 21st, right, 2025.
0:34:19 And then using the federal vacancies reform act,
0:34:23 Patel can be there, I think 210 days without being confirmed.
0:34:28 So we might just again have a cabinet full of acting ex job.
0:34:32 And that’s how he’ll be able to do it.
0:34:36 The standard of luminaries within our party,
0:34:38 you know, lifelong Republicans,
0:34:40 people who have served, you know,
0:34:44 great Republican presidents like the Bill Bars of the world,
0:34:47 they just, it doesn’t matter anymore.
0:34:51 The general populace doesn’t believe in these institutions.
0:34:52 I mean, these quotes are crazy.
0:34:54 Like from Bill Bars book,
0:34:56 he said that Patel would be the deputy director
0:34:58 of the FBI over my dead body.
0:35:02 You have Mark Milley, who told him life looks really shitty
0:35:04 from behind bars.
0:35:06 Gina Haspel, who was the head of the CIA,
0:35:09 threatened to resign when Trump was gonna make him
0:35:11 the deputy director of the CIA.
0:35:13 Like these are all people that you,
0:35:15 you know, whether you like their politics or not,
0:35:18 and I certainly don’t like Bill Bars politics,
0:35:22 but I never felt like he couldn’t do the job.
0:35:24 I thought he, what he did around the Mueller report,
0:35:27 writing that little four page summary
0:35:29 was extremely deceptive,
0:35:33 but I never thought that he couldn’t do it.
0:35:34 You know what I mean?
0:35:35 Like I didn’t like that decision,
0:35:39 but it wasn’t someone that I would fear like a Cache Patel
0:35:42 who’s just there honestly to pay no reverence
0:35:45 to the institution at all.
0:35:46 He’s just there to break it
0:35:48 and that he will destroy, like you said,
0:35:51 the morale of the rank and file agents
0:35:54 who are what make it great and that our allies
0:35:58 and our enemies just will laugh at us for four years
0:36:00 and our allies won’t be sharing with us,
0:36:03 which is the big Tulsi Gabbard problem there for sure,
0:36:05 that everyone will just go about their business
0:36:07 and kind of cut us out.
0:36:10 Patel is concerning on a whole host of issues,
0:36:12 but that’s really it.
0:36:13 I just, I don’t want to,
0:36:15 I understand the argument for America first.
0:36:18 I understand how that resonated with voters
0:36:23 who didn’t feel like American lives were being prioritized,
0:36:27 whether it comes to the economy, national security, immigration,
0:36:30 but to me, this just doesn’t feel like the answer,
0:36:32 that you can find competent people
0:36:36 that have a little bit of your emphasis
0:36:38 on rooting out corruption within institutions
0:36:42 without having Cache Patel as the head of the FBI.
0:36:43 – What you mentioned,
0:36:44 which I think is really one of the,
0:36:47 probably the key drawback is that no one nation
0:36:49 is big enough or strong enough
0:36:51 to effectively monitor the world
0:36:53 or secure itself from all threats.
0:36:55 And one of the most powerful things we have
0:36:59 and with NATO and some of these alliances is that,
0:37:04 MI6, the Mossad, the CIA, our security services,
0:37:08 their security services, we share information.
0:37:11 And whether it’s Israel coordinating with Jordan
0:37:12 and the kingdom of South America
0:37:14 around incoming missile barrage, Moran,
0:37:18 the whole is greater than some of its parts,
0:37:20 and around intelligence and information,
0:37:23 identifying threats, whether it’s terrorist activity
0:37:26 or IP theft of key chip technology,
0:37:30 if all of a sudden our allies are much more remiss
0:37:33 to share information with us because they don’t trust us
0:37:35 and they think this guy has no business
0:37:37 and they don’t wanna compromise their own assets
0:37:39 or their own intelligence,
0:37:42 then we lose what is supposed to be,
0:37:44 largely what has kept the peace
0:37:47 is that in general democracies have said, all right,
0:37:48 we’re gonna create something,
0:37:52 we’re gonna create a unified military structure called NATO,
0:37:54 and we’re gonna cooperate with each other,
0:37:57 not only economically but around intelligence and militarily
0:38:00 because if we do in fact present a united front
0:38:01 and cooperate with each other,
0:38:03 we’re just much harder to fuck with.
0:38:07 And that has largely created unprecedented peace
0:38:10 and prosperity over the last since World War II,
0:38:13 over the last, what is that now, 80 years.
0:38:15 And if that goes away under this notion of America first
0:38:17 and some arrogance, I really do think we suffer
0:38:20 from too much prosperity and this delusion
0:38:23 that we can go it alone, we can’t.
0:38:26 There, you know, the European economy is as big
0:38:29 as the US economy, which largely indicates
0:38:32 their security services and their access to information
0:38:35 and their intelligence units are just as valuable
0:38:37 and have a diversity of thought,
0:38:40 a diversity of information, a diversity of sources.
0:38:42 And when we share information with each other,
0:38:44 you can bet there are a lot of bad things
0:38:46 that never happened that we can’t be grateful for
0:38:49 because they didn’t happen.
0:38:50 And this notion that our allies
0:38:52 might no longer share information with us
0:38:55 and we might no longer share information with them
0:38:58 is how you defeat an enemy and that as you atomize them,
0:39:00 you get them fighting with each other
0:39:01 and that is happening here.
0:39:04 – Okay, we have one more quick break, stay with us.
0:39:12 – Support for this show comes from Amazon Prime.
0:39:14 The feeling that makes the holidays so special
0:39:16 is made up of countless elements,
0:39:19 a classic dish here, a piece of decor there,
0:39:22 a song or movie you always go back to.
0:39:24 Amazon Prime can help you get the most
0:39:26 out of that holiday feeling.
0:39:28 Find everything you need to warm up your home
0:39:30 for the cold days ahead.
0:39:32 Maybe you just need a few more stocking stuffers,
0:39:34 one more set of string lights
0:39:36 and some candles to tie the room together.
0:39:39 With Prime, you can get fast delivery
0:39:42 on all your last minute supplies, gifts and decor.
0:39:45 And when it comes to gifts, you can even get creative
0:39:48 and curate a playlist for someone on Amazon Music.
0:39:50 And when you’re ready to curl up on the couch
0:39:51 for your holiday movie marathon,
0:39:54 pull up the classics on Prime Video.
0:39:56 Whatever you’re into this holiday season
0:39:58 from streaming to shopping, it’s on Prime.
0:40:00 Visit amazon.com/prime
0:40:02 to get more out of whatever you’re into.
0:40:06 – Support for this show comes from Seven Rooms.
0:40:08 What’s the recipe for taking your restaurant
0:40:09 to the next level?
0:40:11 Well, restaurant operators know a key part of it
0:40:15 is making more money and making sure it keeps coming in.
0:40:17 That’s why you wanna bring Seven Rooms to the table.
0:40:20 Seven Rooms is an all-in-one CRM marketing
0:40:23 and operations platform that helps you make more money
0:40:26 for your operation and more magic for your guests.
0:40:28 It equips your staff with the tools you need
0:40:30 to deliver service that keeps your guests
0:40:32 coming back for more.
0:40:34 You can wow diners with a host of tools
0:40:37 that let you create personalized experiences,
0:40:39 organize unforgettable events,
0:40:41 and deepen patron loyalty.
0:40:44 From direct reservations to smart table management
0:40:46 and targeted email marketing,
0:40:49 Seven Rooms helps you grow your brand and your covers
0:40:51 and not your workload.
0:40:53 Learn more at SevenRooms.com.
0:40:57 Seven Rooms, make magic, make money.
0:41:00 – Support for this episode comes from AWS.
0:41:02 AWS Generative AI gives you the tools
0:41:05 to power your business forward with the security
0:41:08 and speed of the world’s most experienced cloud.
0:41:12 – Welcome back.
0:41:15 Walmart announced its scaling back its diversity, equity,
0:41:17 and inclusion DEI efforts.
0:41:19 This includes ending racial equity training for employees,
0:41:22 reevaluating programs supporting minority-owned suppliers,
0:41:25 and winding down its center for racial equity and nonprofit
0:41:28 it created to address systemic racism.
0:41:29 Walmart isn’t alone.
0:41:33 Other major companies, including Lowe’s, Ford, Harley-Davidson,
0:41:36 and John Deere are also pulling back on DEI initiatives
0:41:38 as well as reducing their support for Pride marches
0:41:40 and LGBTQ events.
0:41:42 Many had embraced DEI programs in response
0:41:44 to the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests
0:41:47 and the murder of George Floyd.
0:41:49 Jess, do you think these changes are happening
0:41:51 because Trump won the election?
0:41:53 What do you think is inspiring
0:41:55 this kind of pullback or rollback?
0:41:58 – Well, it’s been going on for a while
0:41:59 for the last couple of years.
0:42:02 I think that it’s getting more intense
0:42:06 because of what life will be like under a Trump presidency
0:42:09 and the kind of folks that he’s associated with,
0:42:12 but also who are just kind of in the ecosystem,
0:42:15 like activists like Christopher Rufo,
0:42:19 who was the principal kind of attack hound
0:42:22 over Claudine Gay, the president of Harvard,
0:42:25 who was pushed out for a multitude of reasons,
0:42:28 including the response to the anti-Semitism issues
0:42:30 on campus, but also the plagiarism scandal
0:42:34 which came from Chris Rufo originally.
0:42:38 But the numbers on the DEI roles going down
0:42:40 are pretty astronomical.
0:42:43 So there was a 29% uptick after George Floyd was murdered
0:42:47 between November, 2020 and November, 2021.
0:42:50 Then there was a 23% decline in the amount of jobs posting
0:42:55 with DEI in the title between November, 2022 and 2023.
0:42:58 And it’s down as much as 43% as of this summer.
0:43:02 So that’s obviously the trend line and where we’re going.
0:43:04 And that’s in part, I think that a lot of these roles
0:43:08 were invented for self-soothing to make people feel better
0:43:12 about it, also to communicate to consumers
0:43:14 and internal stakeholders.
0:43:16 We really care about these issues
0:43:18 without having a thoughtful plan of how to do it
0:43:20 or what you actually need.
0:43:23 Like, do you need there to be 100 roles like this?
0:43:25 Or do you need 10 really good people
0:43:28 that are gonna come in and make important changes
0:43:31 and help you reflect your values?
0:43:34 Which is what you hear over and over from organizations
0:43:36 that they need help being able to communicate
0:43:38 what their values are to internal
0:43:40 and external stakeholders.
0:43:42 So I think it’s the combination of everything coupled
0:43:45 with as well the affirmative action decision
0:43:49 from the Supreme Court, which has changed the way
0:43:52 a lot of people think about admissions to college
0:43:56 and beyond meritocracy in terms of getting your jobs.
0:44:00 And I know the UC system doesn’t do race-based admissions,
0:44:00 right?
0:44:03 – I think this is what often happens
0:44:07 with democratic initiatives or an orthodoxy
0:44:10 and that is it’s a good idea and then the world chains
0:44:12 they don’t change with it or it goes too far.
0:44:17 I still think there’s a need to focus on diversity
0:44:21 or ensuring that if you have a company
0:44:23 where the majority of your consumers
0:44:26 and endorsed athletes are non-white, i.e. Nike,
0:44:28 and pretty much your entire board is white dude
0:44:31 so you have a problem and you should be called out for it.
0:44:34 So there’s still work to be done here.
0:44:37 I have generally found that any company
0:44:41 or any university with a DEI officer or department
0:44:43 is already one of the most diverse
0:44:45 and inclusive places on the planet.
0:44:50 And what I have generally found at universities
0:44:54 is DEI is filled with a lot of virtue signaling
0:44:56 and they become impervious.
0:44:58 These jobs are impossible to do away with
0:45:01 because you’re kind of called implicitly
0:45:02 although what’s happening now are racist
0:45:05 if you’re in any way question them.
0:45:07 And they’re generally very expensive.
0:45:08 They never go away.
0:45:10 It’s resulted this among other things
0:45:12 whether it’s ethics or leadership, that’s my favorite.
0:45:13 We teach ethics at Stern.
0:45:15 Give me a fucking break.
0:45:18 I can’t give my 14 year old to make us bed
0:45:21 and I’m gonna teach a 28 year old to be more ethical.
0:45:22 These departments never go away.
0:45:25 We bring in formerly important people.
0:45:26 We pay them a lot of money
0:45:28 so they can talk about war stories,
0:45:30 teach them leadership or anything
0:45:32 with the term studies on it means that
0:45:34 if you take this course you might get four stars
0:45:37 instead of three as an Uber driver or barista.
0:45:40 We have totally lost the mission in my opinion in the script.
0:45:43 There are now 16 employees at MIT
0:45:46 for everyone who actually teaches.
0:45:48 And we invent these departments.
0:45:52 Sustainability, leadership, ethics, DEI
0:45:56 and all of this translates to student debt.
0:45:58 And where we’ve lost the script around DEI
0:46:02 is we’ve decided okay, essentially the easiest way
0:46:06 to identify or put forward an orthodoxy around DEI
0:46:10 is it oppressors over here, oppressed over here.
0:46:13 Oh and by the way, if you’re white and wealthy
0:46:14 you’re probably an oppressor
0:46:19 and whose ground zero for white and wealthy, Jews.
0:46:22 And what you have seen on campus is a level of bigotry
0:46:23 that I don’t think you’ve seen
0:46:26 in other American institutions in a long time.
0:46:29 And a lot of it started and was inspired
0:46:31 by this weird virtue signaling
0:46:33 and everyone barking up the same tree,
0:46:38 largely inspired or somewhat inspired by these DEI initiatives.
0:46:40 I can’t wait to see these things go on campus.
0:46:44 We, the whole DEI initiative on campus
0:46:46 has been nothing but a misdirect.
0:46:50 And that is Harvard obsesses over quote unquote diversity.
0:46:52 Meanwhile, they sit on an endowment
0:46:55 that’s the GDP of Costa Rica, $54 billion
0:46:58 and they refuse to expand their freshman class.
0:47:00 They’ve grown their endowment 4,000%.
0:47:03 They’ve grown their freshman class in 40 years, 4%.
0:47:07 So they create a misdirect around who gets in.
0:47:09 The conversation shouldn’t be around who gets in.
0:47:11 It should be around how many get in.
0:47:14 Let in more trans kids, let in more black kids,
0:47:17 let in more gay kids, let in more white kids
0:47:19 from rural states.
0:47:20 The question shouldn’t be who gets in.
0:47:21 It should be how many.
0:47:24 You know who doesn’t have a DEI problem?
0:47:26 Junior colleges.
0:47:28 Because they say if you show up and you want to better yourself
0:47:31 and you can pay a couple hundred bucks per credit, you’re in.
0:47:33 And the reason all this bullshit agita,
0:47:37 it also ends up creating more racism than it solves on campus
0:47:40 because the kid next to you who might not be non-white,
0:47:42 you wonder if he or she deserves to be there.
0:47:44 And it creates all of this resentment
0:47:47 among good kids who don’t get into school
0:47:48 because they don’t have a story of adversity.
0:47:50 And you brought up the University of California,
0:47:54 one of the great gifts to American society.
0:47:57 In 1990, was either four or seven, they said,
0:48:00 we’re no longer about race-based affirmative action.
0:48:03 We’re about an adversity score.
0:48:05 And I’m a beneficiary of affirmative action
0:48:07 because my household income was less than $40,000.
0:48:10 I got free Pell Grants or I got Pell Grants
0:48:12 or aren’t even loans.
0:48:13 So the DEI apparatus,
0:48:17 I hope it is disassembled immediately across campuses.
0:48:20 I still think there’s work to be done in corporations
0:48:22 as someone who serves on boards,
0:48:24 who knows a lot of senior management.
0:48:27 There’s still too many people with outdoor plumbing
0:48:28 running these companies.
0:48:30 And I don’t think it’s ever gonna be 50/50
0:48:31 ’cause I think more women will decide
0:48:34 to exit the workforce for a variety of reasons.
0:48:36 Anyways, that was my TED Talk.
0:48:37 Any thoughts?
0:48:38 – I think I actually have heard that
0:48:39 as one of your TED Talks.
0:48:41 And I enjoyed it then and I enjoyed it this time as well.
0:48:42 – Oh!
0:48:45 – No, I generally agree with it.
0:48:48 And I also, I thought that Harvard’s response
0:48:51 after the Supreme Court decision made a lot of sense
0:48:53 where they said, okay, well, we’re going to find a way
0:48:55 to ensure that we have a diverse class
0:48:57 no matter how you say we need to do it.
0:49:00 And there are other things that you can look at
0:49:02 in terms of an application or a background of a student
0:49:06 to make sure that you have the widest swath
0:49:09 of students represented.
0:49:11 And increasingly, this is a conversation
0:49:12 that I’m having with my friends
0:49:14 even down to the preschool level
0:49:15 where people aren’t as concerned anymore
0:49:18 about racial diversity because knock on wood,
0:49:22 thank God we have generally become less racist, right?
0:49:25 Like the Cheerios commercial with the biracial couple
0:49:27 that kind of broke all testing standards
0:49:29 where little kids, they showed it to a five-year-old
0:49:32 and to their parents and all the parents noticed
0:49:35 that it was a biracial couple and none of the kids did
0:49:38 because that’s life for them now, that they see mixed race,
0:49:41 everything is getting more of a melting pot
0:49:42 and that is a good thing.
0:49:46 But what is not happening is we are just hanging out
0:49:48 with people from our same socioeconomic background.
0:49:51 And that’s really what people are hunting
0:49:52 in terms of diversity.
0:49:53 Like I think about that all the time.
0:49:56 Will Cleo, my daughter have friends
0:49:59 who don’t have every toy that they want, right?
0:50:00 Will she go to someone’s house
0:50:03 who doesn’t have a playroom in the building?
0:50:07 You know, those kinds of things are much more top of mind
0:50:10 for us than worrying about whether she’s going to think
0:50:14 that a kid who is black or brown is less than.
0:50:16 And it was so important, I think for the evolution
0:50:19 of this discussion, that it was Asian Americans
0:50:22 that brought that lawsuit about being discriminated against
0:50:24 versus making it, we always think of it
0:50:27 as a black, brown issue or a person of color issue.
0:50:31 And we don’t tend to lump in Asians in that bucket,
0:50:33 which is something that they’ve had to be up against.
0:50:35 And I’ve had a lot of difficulty with that.
0:50:38 And it made me think about the change in New York City
0:50:39 as I’ve grown up.
0:50:43 So when I went and took the test to get into Stuyvesant,
0:50:46 which is a premier public school here in New York,
0:50:48 one of the main filters to Harvard,
0:50:51 it was predominantly white kids that were getting in.
0:50:53 And now, and I live in the neighborhood,
0:50:55 I rarely see a kid coming out of Stuyvesant
0:50:57 who is an Asian, right?
0:50:59 It is totally meritocratic.
0:51:02 However, you do on the test is whether you get in or not.
0:51:06 And the fact that they were then going on to be discriminated
0:51:09 against in terms of getting into these top universities,
0:51:10 which we should note as well as something
0:51:12 that happened to Jewish students at a certain point,
0:51:13 like a couple of decades ago,
0:51:15 then it started being pushed back against Jews,
0:51:17 there were too many of them getting in
0:51:19 as a proportion of the population,
0:51:20 then it moved on to Asians.
0:51:22 And I think that it allowed us
0:51:25 to actually have a more honest conversation
0:51:28 about these admission systems and how society is structured
0:51:31 because it wasn’t a black versus white issue
0:51:33 because everyone just tunes out then and just says,
0:51:37 well, of course I’m for equal opportunity.
0:51:40 And the reframing has led to more discussions like this,
0:51:43 which I think are important for people to have
0:51:45 and then to also integrate into it
0:51:47 the socioeconomic aspect of it,
0:51:50 which is the real dividing line in all of this.
0:51:54 Like there aren’t enough opportunities for poor white kids
0:51:56 to be able to get on the ladder,
0:51:57 whether it’s about going to school
0:51:59 or getting the jobs that they want,
0:52:01 the same way that we would have discussions
0:52:05 about poor black kids or poor Latino kids.
0:52:06 Anyway, that was my TED talk.
0:52:08 I don’t know if I would have gotten it though.
0:52:09 It was good, all right.
0:52:11 – In the United States today,
0:52:16 you would rather be born non-white or gay than poor.
0:52:20 54% of gay men will get a college degree,
0:52:22 it’s 34% for straight men,
0:52:25 and that goes into a variety of issues.
0:52:27 But affirmative action is a wonderful thing.
0:52:28 We should lift people up.
0:52:29 There’s just some people,
0:52:31 and I even think a majority of Republicans feel that,
0:52:34 okay, there’s some people with so much wind in their face,
0:52:37 let’s widen their aperture, let’s widen the perspective,
0:52:38 let’s give some people a hand up.
0:52:39 I just think,
0:52:41 I gotta think most people believe that, that okay,
0:52:42 it’s easy to talk about.
0:52:44 – And they’ve been beneficiaries of it to some degree,
0:52:46 however it has manifested.
0:52:47 Yeah.
0:52:50 – Case in point, Pell Grants for a straight white male,
0:52:52 but it should be based on color.
0:52:55 And that color is the following, green.
0:52:57 We should help poor kids.
0:52:58 They’re the ones,
0:52:59 they’re the ones,
0:53:01 the biggest forward-looking indicator of your success,
0:53:03 unfortunately in our nation,
0:53:05 has become how rich your parents are.
0:53:07 Basically your zip code and your parents’ income.
0:53:10 And we need something that helps kids
0:53:11 brought up in low-income neighborhoods,
0:53:13 regardless of the color of their skin,
0:53:15 regardless of their sexual orientation,
0:53:18 regardless of their gender.
0:53:20 All right, you have grown up
0:53:21 in what is in a capitalist society,
0:53:23 the biggest headwind in your face,
0:53:25 and that is you don’t have money.
0:53:29 And I think it would solve so many problems
0:53:31 and move away from this identity politics
0:53:34 where unfortunately the Democratic Party
0:53:36 has become totally obsessed.
0:53:39 So we’re gonna save the easy stuff for the end here, Jess.
0:53:41 – Can I say before we do the end?
0:53:41 – Of course.
0:53:45 – But in the dissent and the SCOTUS opinion,
0:53:49 Justice Jackson essentially accuses Clarence Thomas
0:53:51 of turning his back on the system
0:53:53 that got Clarence Thomas where he was going.
0:53:56 And I don’t know if I’m ready to fully throw the baby out
0:53:59 with the bathwater and say that there should be no,
0:54:01 race should not be considered at all.
0:54:03 Because I think there are systemic challenges
0:54:06 that face people of color that are different
0:54:09 than the socioeconomic challenges that are out there.
0:54:13 I just, I’m like 75% there.
0:54:18 And I thought that there was some compelling arguments
0:54:21 made by the liberal justices to maintain it.
0:54:22 – But wouldn’t most of that,
0:54:24 so the reason, one of the reasons I love economic based
0:54:27 affirmative action is that it would actually
0:54:30 impact 70% of the same people.
0:54:32 ‘Cause we do still have, you could argue,
0:54:34 an economic apartheid in the United States.
0:54:37 If you’re the daughter of a private equity billionaire
0:54:39 from Taiwan, that’s not diversity.
0:54:41 You don’t need our help, right?
0:54:46 And a lot of kids or a lot of non-whites, like I said,
0:54:50 if you have money, most of those problems
0:54:52 can be addressed and handled.
0:54:54 Anyways, point taken.
0:54:56 This week is a big moment for transgender rights
0:54:59 as the Supreme Court takes on its biggest case yet.
0:55:02 The issue at hand is a Tennessee law banning puberty blockers
0:55:05 and hormone treatments for transgender minors
0:55:07 with over two dozen states having similar laws.
0:55:10 The case is sparking tensions among conservatives
0:55:12 even challenging their usual stance on parental rights.
0:55:16 Jess, what do you think might happen here?
0:55:17 – I mean, it’s a conservative court.
0:55:22 So I imagine it’ll go as many things have now
0:55:23 and they’ll go six, three.
0:55:27 But 26 states now have laws restricting treatments
0:55:28 like puberty blocking drugs.
0:55:30 And what’s interesting about this case,
0:55:32 and it’ll be used as the model.
0:55:36 So it’s the ACLU plus the Biden administration, the DOJ,
0:55:38 I should say, not the Biden administration bringing this.
0:55:41 The problem or what they’re identifying or using
0:55:43 is the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment
0:55:46 that essentially these drugs are being authorized
0:55:48 for non-transgender youths.
0:55:51 So all of the kids that are bringing this case
0:55:53 have been diagnosed with gender dysphoria.
0:55:56 So there are doctors that have said you have this
0:55:58 and they are not getting access to these medications
0:56:02 that kids who do not have gender dysphoria have access to.
0:56:04 So they’re saying it’s discrimination on the basis
0:56:07 of Equal Protection because they’re transgender.
0:56:10 Again, I imagine it’ll get shot down by the court.
0:56:12 I like that they’re taking it at least
0:56:14 and so that we can have this discussion.
0:56:16 It’s when you think that this is going on in 206 states
0:56:18 and even how prominent of a role it played
0:56:22 in our election, conversations around trans issues
0:56:25 and people believing that kids go to school
0:56:27 and come home a different gender.
0:56:29 It’s obviously top of mind for people,
0:56:32 but I’m not optimistic that they’re going to rule
0:56:35 in favor of as one transgender girl
0:56:38 and two transgender boys that have brought the case.
0:56:40 – Yeah, I thought that was great
0:56:42 and I’m gonna plead the fifth on this.
0:56:45 This is something we talk a lot about on Pivot
0:56:47 and I finally come to the conclusion
0:56:49 that I have no fucking idea what I’m talking about
0:56:54 and this issue is so sensitive, so complicated
0:56:59 that I can just see all sides of this issue
0:57:01 or not all sides.
0:57:04 I empathize with so many different viewpoints
0:57:07 and I think this is really another instance
0:57:10 of where government should kind of be out of people’s lives
0:57:15 and let the family and the doctor and the right professionals
0:57:17 and the American Pediatric Association
0:57:19 decide the best solution here.
0:57:21 I think it’s government outreach.
0:57:23 I think the Democratic party has become too obsessed
0:57:26 with this issue and it’s cost us dearly.
0:57:29 At the same time, I’m just absolutely horrified
0:57:31 by the demonization of this group.
0:57:34 At this one, I really do think this is government.
0:57:39 I understand cases that get elevated to the Supreme Court.
0:57:41 This does feel, it’s just so weird.
0:57:44 I feel like Republicans talk such a big game
0:57:46 about staying out of people’s lives and small government
0:57:51 and on the most sensitive, complex, nuanced decisions
0:57:56 they wanna weigh in and it just feels like law enforcement,
0:58:01 the courts should not be in the business of this.
0:58:03 – To that point, the Dobs decision is referenced
0:58:08 over 10 times in this suit for that exact reason.
0:58:13 So small government no more when it comes to sex,
0:58:18 reproduction, trans issues, yeah.
0:58:20 – Yeah, when the left and the right agree on something
0:58:22 it’s usually reckless spending.
0:58:24 All right, that’s all for this episode.
0:58:26 Thank you for listening to Raging Moderates.
0:58:28 Our producers are Caroline Shagren and David Toledo.
0:58:30 Our technical director is Drew Burroughs.
0:58:33 You can find Raging Moderates on its own feed every Tuesday.
0:58:37 That’s right, please if you’re enjoying this episode,
0:58:40 please subscribe to Raging Moderates on its own feed.
0:58:42 Do it right now, follow it up.
0:58:45 Please follow us wherever you get your podcasts.
0:58:47 Just have a great rest of the week.
0:58:48 I’m glad you’re doing it.
0:58:49 – You too, have a great move.
0:58:50 – Yeah.
0:58:58 – Support for this episode comes from AWS.
0:59:01 AWS Generative AI gives you the tools
0:59:03 to power your business forward
0:59:04 with the security and speed
0:59:06 of the world’s most experienced cloud.
0:59:10 (upbeat music)
0:59:14 Autograph Collection Hotels offer over 300
0:59:16 independent hotels around the world,
0:59:19 each exactly like nothing else.
0:59:21 Hands selected for their inherent craft,
0:59:24 each hotel tells its own unique story
0:59:26 through distinctive design and immersive experiences
0:59:30 from medieval falconry to volcanic wine tasting.
0:59:33 Autograph Collection is part of the Marriott Bonvoy
0:59:37 portfolio of over 30 hotel brands around the world.
0:59:40 Find the unforgettable at AutographCollection.com.
0:59:42 you
Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov discuss the implications of President Biden’s pardon for his son, Hunter. Then, they get into Trump’s tariff proposals, whether Kash Patel is fit to run the FBI, and why companies are eliminating their DEI initiatives.
Follow Jessica Tarlov, @JessicaTarlov.
Follow Prof G, @profgalloway.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices