AI transcript
0:00:02 (upbeat music)
0:00:07 – Welcome to Raging Moderates, I’m Scott Galloway.
0:00:09 – And I’m Jessica Tarlev.
0:00:10 – Where are you, Jessica?
0:00:13 – I’m at home in New York, not very glamorous, but you.
0:00:14 – Really?
0:00:17 – You’ve had the weekend of the century, right?
0:00:19 – Yeah, so just so you know when I ask you a question,
0:00:21 what I’m really saying is I want you to ask me.
0:00:23 – Yeah, I get it.
0:00:24 Didn’t I do it well enough?
0:00:25 – Yeah, that was perfect.
0:00:27 – It was like two seconds on me, and then right to you.
0:00:28 Okay, good.
0:00:29 – That’s right, very good.
0:00:33 I was in Scotland this weekend in Aberdeen
0:00:35 for my 50th birthday,
0:00:40 and I am now in Keptantib, and it is beautiful here.
0:00:44 So I’m about two glasses of Domain Odd Inn.
0:00:48 So, anyway, I spent, you know, that’s called a weekday.
0:00:51 But yeah, I had an absolutely wonderful weekend
0:00:52 with a bunch of actually, a bunch of people
0:00:53 I think you might know.
0:00:55 And we’ve got a lot to talk about today,
0:00:59 but first and foremost, our first two episodes, Jessica,
0:01:03 had, are going to, did about 100,000 downloads
0:01:06 in 24 hours, which means they’ll probably do about
0:01:09 200,000 over the next 30 days.
0:01:13 And I believe that means more people in our first week
0:01:15 are listening to Raid Dream Moderates
0:01:18 and are viewing 80% of cable news programming.
0:01:22 So we’re stars, Jessica, we’re stars.
0:01:23 – Mostly you.
0:01:24 I’m just here for the ride.
0:01:26 – Yeah, that’s it.
0:01:27 – Did, am I doing this right?
0:01:30 Was that how I was supposed to get it back to you?
0:01:31 No, it’s really exciting.
0:01:34 And also just kind of understanding the viewership
0:01:38 or listenership versus TV is fascinating for me.
0:01:40 So excited all around.
0:01:43 And I’m glad that the listeners have found
0:01:44 that what we’re talking about is resonating with them.
0:01:48 I have seen some comments that were no moderates,
0:01:50 but a moderate can be someone that votes
0:01:52 for the Democrats, by the way.
0:01:55 But we’ll prove it to them over time.
0:01:56 – Today we’re gonna talk about
0:01:58 the second assassination attempt on Donald Trump.
0:02:00 The aftermath following the presidential debate
0:02:04 and whether Tim Walls is benefiting the Democratic ticket.
0:02:07 So all right, we’re under two months away from election
0:02:08 and things are getting more intense.
0:02:11 The Secret Service is investigating another attempt
0:02:13 to assassination on former President Trump
0:02:16 at his international golf club in Florida.
0:02:17 The gunman, three to 500 yards away,
0:02:22 had an AK-47 style rifle, a GoPro and backpacks
0:02:25 when law enforcement intervened.
0:02:27 I know so little about this, Jessica,
0:02:29 ’cause I’ve been eating haggis
0:02:30 and drinking anything within reach.
0:02:32 Can you kind of break down what happened here
0:02:34 and what you know about it?
0:02:36 – Well, you’re behind most people,
0:02:38 but we don’t know a ton yet.
0:02:42 So it’s not that bad that you’re just joining us on this one.
0:02:44 We’re going to find more in the coming days about it.
0:02:48 And there’ll be another Secret Service investigation into it.
0:02:51 No idea how this guy was even able to get,
0:02:54 I think it was like three or 400 yards away
0:02:56 from the former president.
0:02:59 He has a checkered past convicted felon
0:03:02 who’s still allowed to get guns mentally unstable
0:03:05 so we could have the whole gun reform conversation about that.
0:03:08 His voting history is,
0:03:12 I didn’t know there were people like this that existed.
0:03:14 He voted for Trump in 2016 and 2019.
0:03:16 He was really into Tulsi Gavard,
0:03:18 which to me is also kind of like being into Trump,
0:03:23 but then he wanted Biden to win, which worked out.
0:03:27 And then he wanted a Vivek Ramaswamy and Nikki Haley ticket
0:03:32 for 2024, which if you followed the level of vitriol
0:03:34 that the two of them spewed at one another,
0:03:38 you would know that that is maybe slightly more plausible
0:03:42 than a Donald Trump Kamala Harris ticket, but not much.
0:03:45 And the guy was just truly out of his mind.
0:03:50 We don’t know yet what quote unquote inspired him.
0:03:54 The New York Times interviewed him in 2023
0:03:55 and discovered that he was a nut.
0:03:58 He was trying to go and serve in Ukraine,
0:04:01 actually fighting with the Ukrainians.
0:04:02 He’s all over the place.
0:04:04 I’m glad that the former president is safe.
0:04:08 And I think it’s pretty clear that he needs some beefing up
0:04:10 of his detail, which President Biden
0:04:12 said something about that this morning.
0:04:15 And hopefully Congress will just pass something quickly
0:04:17 to give him extra money for protection
0:04:22 because it feels like this is heading towards being a trend.
0:04:25 – What do you think of Elon’s now deleted tweet?
0:04:27 He said, and no one is even trying
0:04:30 to assassinate Biden Kamala.
0:04:33 And he put this out to his 170 million people on X.
0:04:35 Now, what are your thoughts when a guy like that
0:04:38 with so much reach says something like that?
0:04:40 Is it Democrats overreacting and being indignant
0:04:43 as we often are about everything?
0:04:45 Or is it irresponsible?
0:04:46 Or is the answer just yes?
0:04:49 – Yeah, I think it’s yes.
0:04:52 And I actually found his tweet last week
0:04:54 when Taylor Swift endorsed Trump
0:04:56 and he said, okay, I’ll impregnate you
0:04:59 or something like that to be even nuttier
0:05:02 and more offensive than this.
0:05:05 Him saying, why is no one trying to assassinate Biden
0:05:08 /Kamala feels just on brand for someone
0:05:11 who has a level of genius within him
0:05:14 that I’ll never be able to fully grasp even
0:05:18 and has become so terminally online
0:05:22 that he’s incapable of having normal human interaction.
0:05:25 And it fits in nicely with where I think
0:05:29 a certain faction of the Republican party is right now.
0:05:31 And you notice it in the way that JD Vance
0:05:33 has been talking or Donald Trump at the debate
0:05:36 where he just started yelling things that he saw online
0:05:40 or that he saw on TV, which a policy does not make
0:05:43 or a true statement does not make.
0:05:46 But Elon Musk, I think there’s no better encapsulation
0:05:49 of what he has turned Twitter into than that comment.
0:05:53 And when he took it down and justified it, I guess,
0:05:55 by saying, oh, I guess things that you say in private
0:05:58 that are a joke aren’t actually that funny out in the wild.
0:06:01 Like, who was laughing at that in private?
0:06:05 – Yeah, I didn’t, I’m of two minds.
0:06:10 And that is, I think people should be able to say
0:06:11 what they want.
0:06:14 I find that people get very sensitive around,
0:06:16 I don’t know, jumpy around the stuff
0:06:18 when I don’t think people are gonna,
0:06:20 oh, shit, I don’t know, there’s a lot of crazies around there.
0:06:24 But something I’ve thought about is that,
0:06:26 and I think it was my dad said this to me.
0:06:28 He said, have you become more measured
0:06:31 as your audience and followership has grown?
0:06:32 Have you become more measured?
0:06:35 And I said, no, I try to stay as authentic
0:06:36 and as provocative and he’s like,
0:06:38 you should become more measured.
0:06:39 And I said, well, why do you say that?
0:06:41 And he goes, because when you have more reach,
0:06:42 you need to be more thoughtful
0:06:44 about the ramifications of your reach.
0:06:46 And that kind of– – Spider-man, right?
0:06:48 – Right, that just struck me.
0:06:50 And I thought, well, maybe he’s right.
0:06:53 Maybe I should be a little bit more measured or thoughtful.
0:06:56 And not that that’s actually–
0:06:57 – What happened to that?
0:07:00 – Yeah, we’ll see, it’s coming, it’s coming.
0:07:03 – I’m curious, do you think, is there any evidence
0:07:05 the last assassination attempt?
0:07:07 Trump had amazing political instincts.
0:07:10 And that image of him pumping his fist in the air
0:07:12 with blood on his face and the American flag above him,
0:07:16 I believe that will likely be the image of the decade.
0:07:20 I just thought that was, I mean, that was incredible.
0:07:22 And I do think he registered a bit of a bump.
0:07:25 Do you think he’s gonna get a bump from this?
0:07:28 – No, I don’t.
0:07:31 I think that what helped in terms of the bump
0:07:33 with the first assassination attempt is,
0:07:35 first of all, the person got a shot off,
0:07:36 which is not what happened here.
0:07:38 Basically, they took down a guy
0:07:42 who was waiting for Trump a couple holes away.
0:07:46 But someone was unfortunately murdered at that rally
0:07:49 and Trump was bloodied from it hitting his ear.
0:07:51 And then it went into the RNC.
0:07:55 And I think the timing of that worked together,
0:07:59 essentially, to create this martyrdom mood,
0:08:02 which I was feeling firsthand being in Milwaukee.
0:08:04 There was an invincibility about Trump
0:08:06 and the party that happened there.
0:08:09 This feels like an important point of discussion
0:08:11 and something that we need to think about
0:08:15 and how rotten our politics is.
0:08:19 Even if this wasn’t necessarily politics motivated,
0:08:21 but how dangerous it is for politicians,
0:08:23 which is something that we’re seeing across the board.
0:08:27 But I don’t expect Trump will be redeemed
0:08:31 from a bad debate performance by a bump from this guy.
0:08:35 – We’ll be right back.
0:08:42 Support for Prop G comes from Fetch Pet Insurance.
0:08:44 I love doing ads for Fetch.
0:08:45 I am a huge dog person.
0:08:47 I think you’ll notice both Leia and Gangster,
0:08:50 my great-tang, and my Puerto Rican rescue ham.
0:08:53 We think he’s a dog, and by the way, Leia,
0:08:54 Leia’s big and scary-looking.
0:08:57 You can go up and literally poke Leia in the eye
0:08:58 or take her food from her,
0:09:00 and she’s not gonna do anything,
0:09:03 except maybe rear up her hind quarters against you,
0:09:06 whereas the little one will snap your finger off,
0:09:07 the little cute one.
0:09:08 Anyways, pet parents know better than anyone
0:09:11 how much joy and whimsy an animal can bring to a family,
0:09:12 but they also know that it’s only a matter of time
0:09:15 before the unexpected happens,
0:09:16 and the unexpected is also, unfortunately,
0:09:17 usually expensive.
0:09:19 So unless you happen to have thousands of dollars
0:09:21 lying around to drop at the vet,
0:09:23 you might want to try Fetch Pet Insurance.
0:09:26 Fetch is the most comprehensive pet insurance covering,
0:09:28 but other providers charge extra for or don’t cover at all.
0:09:31 Fetch even covers acupuncture.
0:09:32 Get that, acupuncture for dogs.
0:09:35 Fetch covers up to 90% of unexpected vet bills,
0:09:37 and with Fetch, you can use any vet in the U.S. or Canada.
0:09:39 Fetch covers more.
0:09:41 More protection, more savings, more love.
0:09:43 With Fetch, more is more.
0:09:46 Get your free quote today at fetchpet.com/propg.
0:09:49 That’s fetchpet.com/propg.
0:09:51 Fetchpet.com/propg.
0:09:56 Support for the show comes from Monarch.
0:09:58 Managing your money in today’s world
0:09:59 can get complicated fast,
0:10:00 keeping track of your credit cards,
0:10:02 investment accounts, and more.
0:10:04 That’s a lot of tabs to keep open on your browser,
0:10:08 not to mention if you’re combining finances with a partner.
0:10:09 Good problems to have,
0:10:11 but you might want to simplify for that.
0:10:13 You could try Monarch.
0:10:15 The all-in-one personal finance app with Monarch
0:10:17 can get a comprehensive view of all your accounts,
0:10:20 investments, transactions, and more.
0:10:21 You can create custom budgets,
0:10:23 track progress towards financial goals,
0:10:25 and collaborate with your partner, plus.
0:10:26 Monarch can help you make smart money moves
0:10:28 to get you closer to your goals.
0:10:30 With Monarch, you can easily share your accounts
0:10:32 with your partner or even your financial advisor.
0:10:35 You can log into one place, get a comprehensive view,
0:10:37 adjust what you need, and get on with your life.
0:10:40 Run your finances, don’t let your finances run you.
0:10:42 Right now, listeners of the show
0:10:43 will get an extended 30-day free trial
0:10:47 when you go to monarchmoney.com/propg.
0:10:51 That’s M-O-N-A-R-C-H-M-O-N-E-Y,
0:10:55 dot com slash propg for your extended 30-day free trial.
0:11:01 Okay, moving on, let’s talk about the debate.
0:11:03 67 million people tuned in,
0:11:06 15 million more than the Biden-Trump debate back in June.
0:11:07 Pundits are calling it a loss for Trump
0:11:09 and saying Harris baited him
0:11:10 while avoiding going deep into policy,
0:11:13 but ultimately, it’s the voters whose opinion matters.
0:11:16 It’s been somewhere between two thirds and 70% thought
0:11:18 that Harris won the debate,
0:11:21 15 million more than Biden-Trump debates back in June.
0:11:23 Still, plenty of voters didn’t watch it.
0:11:26 The polling data I’ve seen says the following.
0:11:29 She won, and it kind of doesn’t matter.
0:11:30 What are your thoughts?
0:11:35 Agreed, she won, the kind of on the more rosy side of it.
0:11:42 She needed to prove that she was capable of this job,
0:11:44 that she could look presidential
0:11:46 and that she could open herself up
0:11:48 to the public more than she had.
0:11:50 And I might have frankly underestimated
0:11:54 how much that was bugging people who were unsure
0:11:56 or even were going to vote for her,
0:11:58 but wanted her to do a bit more work
0:12:00 in terms of earning that vote.
0:12:01 And it was interesting,
0:12:03 I was listening to the Daily this morning
0:12:05 and they had undecided voters on,
0:12:06 they’ve been, it’s actually really cool.
0:12:08 They have like a long-term tracking study
0:12:11 with these voters following them through everything,
0:12:14 people through Biden being the candidate,
0:12:16 not being the candidate in Trump assassination,
0:12:17 the debate, et cetera.
0:12:18 And there was one woman who they interviewed,
0:12:22 she’s in her 40s, has two daughters.
0:12:26 And she said, I’m still not exactly sure what I’m going to do.
0:12:28 I was leaning towards writing someone in,
0:12:30 but now that I saw the debate,
0:12:31 I feel like I can make more of a choice,
0:12:33 which she didn’t say it was gonna be Kamala Harris,
0:12:36 but that was implied from what she was saying
0:12:39 and her concerns about Donald Trump.
0:12:42 There is that snap reaction polling
0:12:44 that showed that for the undecideds,
0:12:47 her favorability went up pretty substantially
0:12:48 in the double digits,
0:12:50 but there were a slew of polls that came out
0:12:52 over the weekend.
0:12:56 I won’t bore everyone with like 40 minutes on polls,
0:12:59 but what has been really important to see is
0:13:02 she’s crossing the 50% threshold in a couple of them.
0:13:05 And these were all grade A or grade B pollsters,
0:13:07 so not pieces of trash
0:13:09 that people like to run around amplifying.
0:13:11 She’s gaining like an ABC/Ipsos poll,
0:13:14 she’s gaining with Black voters, Latino voters,
0:13:18 and Gen Z voters, critical components of a win.
0:13:20 She’s not quite at Biden’s numbers from 2020,
0:13:21 but inching that way.
0:13:25 And then I don’t know if the Ann Selzer poll from Iowa
0:13:28 permeated the Haggis bubble in Aberdeen.
0:13:30 – Haggis bubble, that’s good.
0:13:33 – Yeah, you can keep that. – You’re learning, that’s good.
0:13:34 – But it was a really big deal.
0:13:36 So Ann Selzer is known to be
0:13:39 one of the most accurate pollsters in the country.
0:13:41 She had Biden down 18 to Trump
0:13:44 when he had Trump won by eight in 2020.
0:13:46 And she just released a survey showing
0:13:47 that Kamala is only down four.
0:13:49 Now, do I think she’s winning Iowa?
0:13:52 Absolutely not, but it’s a really important bellwether
0:13:55 for how white Midwestern voters
0:13:57 are feeling about Kamala Harris.
0:14:00 And that then bodes well for Wisconsin and Michigan as well.
0:14:01 And maybe a little bit of Pennsylvania,
0:14:05 but that seems like it’s going to be the real difficult piece
0:14:09 of this puzzle for the Harris campaign.
0:14:11 – So Trump would never admit defeat,
0:14:13 but we’ve seen some of his most loyal supporters,
0:14:17 including your Fox News colleague, Neil Cavuto,
0:14:21 RFK Jr. and Frank Lund,
0:14:24 saying that the debate likely cost him the election.
0:14:26 How do you, do you think?
0:14:28 I thought it was something like that.
0:14:30 I would have thought, and I guess it’s not his brand,
0:14:33 but you’re, I mean, you’re an expert in messaging and data.
0:14:35 I would have thought that he should have said,
0:14:36 I had a bad night.
0:14:37 She was great, congratulations.
0:14:39 Check out our policies.
0:14:40 I’ll be a better president.
0:14:41 She’s a better debater.
0:14:42 I’ll be a better president.
0:14:44 Instead, he went into the spin room,
0:14:47 which I thought was almost a little bit desperate
0:14:51 and is trying to recast it as, no, just ignore everything.
0:14:52 I won.
0:14:53 How do you think he’s handled the debate?
0:14:54 – Right, like, I hope you blacked out
0:14:56 for the last 97 minutes.
0:14:59 And here I am to tell you about, they’re eating the cats.
0:15:01 They’re eating the dogs.
0:15:03 I now sing that whole thing in TikTok form,
0:15:04 which I don’t have on my phone,
0:15:07 but you can actually go on TikTok on your computer
0:15:10 without inviting it into your life.
0:15:15 You know, Donald Trump, his ego and his need for attention
0:15:16 just kicked into high gear.
0:15:18 And that’s why he went into the spin room
0:15:20 and kind of watching who the Republicans had
0:15:22 versus who the Democrats had.
0:15:23 You know, we had the best in class.
0:15:26 Gavin Newsom out there, Josh Shapiro out there.
0:15:30 But I do think that there is a case to be made
0:15:32 for Donald Trump not hurting himself that badly
0:15:35 in the debate for people who were looking
0:15:37 for a clear vision from Kamala Harris
0:15:40 and actually answering the explicit question.
0:15:42 And we talked about that a little with the,
0:15:43 you know, the first question was,
0:15:45 are you better off today than you were four years ago?
0:15:48 And she didn’t answer that on immigration.
0:15:50 Now, I really, I agree with the answer
0:15:52 that the bipartisan border bill
0:15:53 would make a huge difference.
0:15:56 Lots of conservative Republicans even agree with that.
0:16:00 But like, Secretary Mayorkas is on with Azra Klein
0:16:01 on his latest podcast.
0:16:03 And Azra Klein is really struggling
0:16:05 to get that answer to the question.
0:16:08 Why did you do nothing for three years?
0:16:11 And for people who are going to vote on immigration
0:16:13 or that’s going to be in their top three,
0:16:15 they want at least some sort of answer.
0:16:18 If you want to say, well, we needed more cheap labor,
0:16:20 I accept that.
0:16:24 Or we thought it wasn’t going to get this overwhelming.
0:16:25 I accept that.
0:16:25 It’s a tricky period.
0:16:28 You’re in COVID, everyone’s being held.
0:16:30 Then suddenly the floodgates open.
0:16:31 We were overwhelmed.
0:16:33 We made X, Y, and Z mistakes.
0:16:35 This is what we’re doing to fix it.
0:16:36 And so if you were someone looking
0:16:37 for that kind of specificity,
0:16:39 and like Brett Stevens, for instance,
0:16:40 is someone looking for that,
0:16:44 I hope he’s going to end up voting for her in the end.
0:16:48 But she didn’t satisfy that itch for a lot of people.
0:16:50 And that’s why I think a second debate or town halls
0:16:54 where I think she would really shine would help her case.
0:16:59 – So Trump is now saying it’s not going to debate her again.
0:17:01 Do you think that’s the smart move?
0:17:03 – I think that they could both.
0:17:06 It’s weird, I’m a Pollyanna about many things in life.
0:17:10 And I know that winning is the ultimate goal for everyone.
0:17:12 But I do think that people,
0:17:14 the American public deserves the best person for the job.
0:17:17 And the best person for the job should be the person
0:17:19 who can show up in a bunch of different forums,
0:17:22 explain themselves, connect with people,
0:17:25 have policies that satisfy the widest swath of voters.
0:17:28 And so I think that he should,
0:17:31 for people who are on the fence and saw him behave
0:17:32 like a petulant toddler,
0:17:34 he could do a lot better.
0:17:36 And I think he could also interact with her better.
0:17:39 There’s a clip floating around on Twitter,
0:17:41 or X, whatever I’m supposed to call it,
0:17:43 from 2016 when he was debating Hillary,
0:17:46 and not only is his cognitive decline
0:17:48 on full display up until now,
0:17:51 but he’s really kind of nice to her.
0:17:53 – It’s been defective for a long time, many years,
0:17:56 but the politicians haven’t done anything about it.
0:18:00 Now, an all fair is to Secretary Clinton, yes.
0:18:01 Is that okay?
0:18:04 Good, I want you to be very happy.
0:18:05 It’s very important to me.
0:18:07 But an all fairness to Secretary Clinton.
0:18:09 – He says, I want you to be happy.
0:18:10 I want you to be very happy.
0:18:12 And it made me think back to the night that he won,
0:18:14 which surprised him more than anyone.
0:18:16 Remember, he told her, you come out and you say,
0:18:19 whatever you want, whenever is good for you.
0:18:21 There’s no need for you to make a speech right now
0:18:24 at three o’clock in the morning or whenever it got called.
0:18:28 And he seemed much more humane in that version
0:18:32 versus what we saw or continue to see right now in 2024.
0:18:34 So I think he could help himself.
0:18:37 And I think Kamala would continue to build
0:18:40 on this goodwill that’s beginning to burn for her.
0:18:43 – Your point is a good one that if you’re gonna try
0:18:46 and present or you think that you’re presenting
0:18:47 to the people that you’re the person
0:18:49 that should be presented to carry the flag
0:18:52 in almost any context or the most important contexts,
0:18:53 I should say around the world,
0:18:56 that you should be subject to all sorts of formats.
0:18:59 That one of the reasons we’ve had such exceptional people
0:19:01 as presidents of the nation
0:19:03 is we battle test this shit out of him.
0:19:05 Fred Smith was not gonna be present.
0:19:09 Rudy Giuliani, Herman Cain were all at one point
0:19:11 leading in the polls.
0:19:13 And as soon as they kind of got on stage
0:19:15 and people started battle testing–
0:19:17 – Ted Cruz won Iowa.
0:19:18 – Ted Cruz won Iowa, right.
0:19:20 As soon as we started power washing them
0:19:23 and they went into combat, they just fell away.
0:19:26 And that process does produce really impressive people.
0:19:29 But what you said about as your lead up
0:19:31 that Trump should do another debate,
0:19:33 I would bet that a lot of people
0:19:34 who are Trump supporters are saying,
0:19:37 “Are we talking about Trump or Kamala?”
0:19:41 Because she has not opened herself to a lot of formats.
0:19:42 – I think that’s totally fair.
0:19:46 She did a local ABC Philly interview.
0:19:48 I think he came out on Friday.
0:19:49 But she definitely has to.
0:19:53 And I think Trump had wanted a Fox debate
0:19:55 after the moderators who he said
0:19:56 we’re in the tank for her,
0:19:59 which I do not see that bias existing.
0:20:01 But he says he wants,
0:20:03 it can’t be Brett Bear and Martha McCallum.
0:20:05 Now he wants Sean Hannity and Lauren Grum and Jesse Waters
0:20:06 to do it.
0:20:08 So obviously that’s a non-starter.
0:20:10 But I think that Kamala should just come out and say,
0:20:12 if he’s not gonna debate on Fox,
0:20:15 I’m gonna sit down with Brett Bear and myself.
0:20:18 And Brett will give her a fair interview.
0:20:20 One of the worst interviews that has ever existed
0:20:22 for Donald Trump was actually with Brett
0:20:24 when he read off all the horrible things that people–
0:20:26 – All the secretaries, all the people
0:20:27 who no longer wanna work with him.
0:20:28 – Exactly.
0:20:31 – That Ford is 44 secretaries are supporting him.
0:20:34 – Yeah, it’s very slim pickings over there.
0:20:36 But she should do it.
0:20:37 And it’s a little selfish.
0:20:40 I would love it if she came on the network that I work for.
0:20:42 But it’s also where the persuadable voters are.
0:20:43 And I think that, you know,
0:20:45 Mayor Pete has really proven that out
0:20:48 as being a good strategy for Democrats to show up.
0:20:51 Gavin Newsom as well, Mark Kelly’s been coming on.
0:20:54 I think it’s really good for a public
0:20:57 that might not feel thrilled about their choices
0:21:00 to see you showing up and doing the difficult things.
0:21:02 – Yeah, look, if you wanna be part of the resistance,
0:21:03 you have to get behind enemy lines.
0:21:06 But the people you referenced, Mayor Pete
0:21:07 or Secretary Buttigieg–
0:21:10 – I should say Secretary Pete or I should say Buttigieg.
0:21:13 It’s just so Mayor Pete is so good.
0:21:17 – Well, yeah, but him and Governor Newsom,
0:21:20 they, I believe in my view, they’re better
0:21:22 facing the opposing party than when they’re on their own party
0:21:26 because they are so outstanding at sort of very,
0:21:29 I think when Governor Newsom goes on friendly TV,
0:21:32 I think it’s a handsome vanilla mooring guy.
0:21:34 When he debates Governor DeSantis,
0:21:36 I think he tore him limb from limb and he’s really good.
0:21:38 I think the same is true of Secretary Pete.
0:21:40 Vice President Harris hasn’t demonstrated
0:21:41 that ability to go mind enemy lines.
0:21:44 And I think the people probably advising her
0:21:47 aren’t sure it’s a good idea because I think,
0:21:50 Brett Baird would be fair,
0:21:53 but quite frankly, he’s just gonna put to her
0:21:55 a level of questioning that I’m not sure,
0:21:57 we don’t know if she’d be good at this.
0:21:59 We both believe she should do it.
0:22:01 I’m not sure it’s the right thing to do
0:22:03 from a winning standpoint.
0:22:07 Trump is terrible when he gets in front of an opposing party.
0:22:08 He starts calling them nasty
0:22:11 or starts insulting that network.
0:22:14 I saw what I thought was just a cringe-worthy interview.
0:22:15 I love Dana Bash.
0:22:17 I think she’s very measured.
0:22:19 And I think she’s great at what she does.
0:22:23 And she interviewed Senator Vance.
0:22:25 And talking about this, well, first off,
0:22:28 just in case you’re one of the 2% of people
0:22:31 that haven’t heard it, let’s play the clip from Trump
0:22:34 about locking up Fluffy and Zoe
0:22:36 because they are under threat from Haitian immigrants.
0:22:37 Let’s play that.
0:22:39 – Look at what’s happening to the towns
0:22:41 all over the United States.
0:22:42 And a lot of towns don’t wanna talk.
0:22:44 It’s not gonna be Aurora or Springfield.
0:22:46 A lot of towns don’t wanna talk about it
0:22:48 because they’re so embarrassed by it.
0:22:51 In Springfield, they’re eating the dogs,
0:22:53 the people that came in, they’re eating the cats,
0:22:58 they’re eating the pets of the people that live there.
0:23:02 And this is what’s happening in our country.
0:23:03 And it’s a shame.
0:23:05 – So Senator Vance came on and Dana Bash
0:23:08 immediately said, look, this is causing problems
0:23:13 in Springfield, Ohio, that this is creating
0:23:14 a lot of unnecessary attention.
0:23:16 It’s bad for our economy.
0:23:20 It’s creating a spectacle of Springfield.
0:23:21 We’re worried it’s gonna be bad
0:23:24 in terms of our ability to actually solve the problem.
0:23:26 Can you please stop?
0:23:29 And she said, why are you spreading baseless claims?
0:23:32 And he said, well, when my constituents call me
0:23:35 with a concern, I have a responsibility.
0:23:38 And she kept pressing him and he went on
0:23:40 very much on the offensive and said,
0:23:42 that’s outrageous if you would accuse me
0:23:44 of inciting problems.
0:23:46 He went into the outrage misdirect
0:23:49 and I couldn’t figure out if it was bad for CNN
0:23:52 and Dana or bad for Senator Vance.
0:23:56 But I feel as if Senator Vance and Linda Yacarino
0:23:58 literally have the worst jobs in the world.
0:24:00 That they’re the circus clown falling around,
0:24:03 scooping up the shit of an elephant.
0:24:07 They’re like, okay, you go defend this ridiculousness.
0:24:11 And he has to pretend that this is actually going on
0:24:12 and it was a reasonable thing to say.
0:24:14 I don’t, is this a giant?
0:24:17 Should the Harris campaign continue to press
0:24:19 on the ridiculousness of that statement
0:24:20 or should they move on?
0:24:23 I’m almost getting a little sick of talking about it.
0:24:26 – Again, and I think I said this last week,
0:24:29 we’re not really the target audience anymore for this.
0:24:31 We can evaluate these things.
0:24:33 And I think our opinions are worth something
0:24:36 and hopefully our many listeners agree with that.
0:24:40 But if you need to get out to sometimes low information
0:24:42 undecided voters,
0:24:44 I think you do need to keep talking about these things.
0:24:46 But the way that you do it is important.
0:24:50 Like dunking on JD Vance, like he’s been dunked on a lot
0:24:51 and it’s working, right?
0:24:54 His approval rating is the lowest of anyone,
0:24:56 you know, certainly of his ticket.
0:24:59 Like he’s a point lower even than Trump,
0:25:01 which is astounding.
0:25:02 And Walls is in positive territory
0:25:05 and Kamala is just barely in positive territory,
0:25:06 but she is now.
0:25:08 But I think that what you need to focus on
0:25:10 is the fact that he admitted
0:25:12 that sometimes you have to create stories.
0:25:14 So he owned up to faking it.
0:25:16 And then tie that into the fact
0:25:18 that Trump was talking later
0:25:20 and talking about his deportation force,
0:25:22 that he’s going to go to Springfield.
0:25:24 And these are legal immigrants
0:25:25 that he said that he’s going to round up
0:25:27 and send to Venezuela,
0:25:30 which is not Haiti last time I checked.
0:25:32 – It’s close.
0:25:33 It’s close.
0:25:35 – Close but no cigar on that one.
0:25:39 And I think that when you contextualize it
0:25:42 in terms of how inhumane these people are
0:25:47 in the way they talk about people of immigrants,
0:25:49 people of color as well,
0:25:50 that that’s something that can be resonant
0:25:52 to folks who are on the fence.
0:25:54 Now from the GOP side,
0:25:57 that thinks that our cities are overrun
0:25:59 and the country is going to hell in a handbasket
0:26:01 because of immigration
0:26:03 and isn’t really separating legal
0:26:05 versus illegal immigration.
0:26:07 You know, they’re looking at the fact
0:26:08 that the Harris campaign,
0:26:09 and I referenced before, you know,
0:26:12 my orcas being on and talking about
0:26:13 what’s gone on on the border for a while,
0:26:15 that the Democrats don’t seem to really have
0:26:19 a cogent answer for what the solution is going to be.
0:26:22 So for people who do live in places
0:26:24 where for instance rec centers
0:26:26 that are for low income kids
0:26:29 are being taken over as migrant shelters
0:26:31 or have classrooms that are being flooded
0:26:33 with people that don’t necessarily speak the language
0:26:35 or ERs or all of these very real problems
0:26:38 they’re having as a result of the migrant crisis.
0:26:40 The fact that JD Vance and Donald Trump
0:26:42 are even talking about it at all
0:26:43 versus saying like, oh, you know,
0:26:46 we have a fancy bipartisan bill.
0:26:48 Like a bill is not a solution to people,
0:26:49 especially when they know that the bill
0:26:51 isn’t going to be passed.
0:26:55 And now there’s another survey out in FT survey
0:26:57 that showed Kamala Harris really closing the gap
0:26:58 on the economy.
0:27:00 She was even up a point or two
0:27:01 that people get that she cares about
0:27:03 average Americans, middle class Americans.
0:27:04 He’s for the wealthy.
0:27:06 But if you look at it on the immigration issue,
0:27:08 he’s still up like 14 points on that.
0:27:10 And so whatever she’s messaging on it
0:27:13 isn’t resonating in a way
0:27:15 that I think is going to move the needle in that direction.
0:27:18 And for Nikki Haley voters who are the top,
0:27:20 you know, up for grabs and top priority,
0:27:23 they also said immigration was their top issue
0:27:24 in the primary.
0:27:27 And the campaign hasn’t been that responsive to it.
0:27:30 – Senator Kelly said something
0:27:32 I thought that was pretty, pretty interesting.
0:27:36 He said that Republicans aren’t sincere
0:27:40 about immigration and Democrats don’t understand it.
0:27:43 And what I take more of a,
0:27:45 my sense is money always wins.
0:27:47 And that if you want to look at something,
0:27:51 when I serve on a board and the CEO is behaving strangely
0:27:54 or we can’t figure out why store managers
0:27:56 aren’t collecting email or whatever,
0:27:58 let’s go to the compensation.
0:28:00 Let’s just go to the money, money always wins.
0:28:01 It’s around incentives.
0:28:03 And I believe our lack of an immigration policy
0:28:06 over the last 40 years has primarily been
0:28:08 because, and people don’t talk about this,
0:28:10 people talk a lot about the morality of immigration
0:28:12 and how it’s part of our DNA
0:28:13 in that it’s good for America.
0:28:17 And 20% of the NASDAQ by market capitalization
0:28:22 is from first generation Indian Americans who immigrated here.
0:28:26 So there’s a ton of like spiritual and chest beating
0:28:30 and flag waving notions of immigration.
0:28:31 I think the most beneficial
0:28:32 or one of the most beneficial things
0:28:34 about immigration is a subset of it.
0:28:37 And that is illegal immigration.
0:28:39 And if you think about undocumented workers,
0:28:41 they come across the border,
0:28:43 they pay social security taxes,
0:28:44 but they usually don’t stick around
0:28:46 to collect social security benefits.
0:28:49 They are the most profitable immigrants in history,
0:28:51 specifically undocumented workers
0:28:53 and all this bullshit about,
0:28:56 and you’ll find examples of this of them being criminals,
0:29:00 they actually commit crimes at a lower rate than citizens.
0:29:04 And I think we’ve figured out this flexible workforce
0:29:08 that comes in, picks grapes, takes care of grandma
0:29:12 at a lower cost, lower tax, lower taxation
0:29:14 or lower strain on our social services,
0:29:17 in that we haven’t wanted to fix this problem
0:29:19 because we make a shit ton of money from illegal
0:29:21 or undocumented workers
0:29:22 and we’re willing to pay the price
0:29:23 of some of the externalities.
0:29:25 Now the point, you know, the question is,
0:29:28 at some point does it become so out of control
0:29:29 that it’s no longer worth it?
0:29:31 And I think a lot of people have decided
0:29:33 that we’ve gotten to that point.
0:29:34 Any thoughts?
0:29:36 – No, I totally agree.
0:29:38 My dad was a winemaker in Oregon.
0:29:40 So, you know, dealing with the seasonal workers
0:29:43 was something that was built into conversations
0:29:45 that we were, you know, having around the dinner table
0:29:48 and how also incredible these people were
0:29:51 and what kind of bastions of the community they were.
0:29:53 And I thought a lot about,
0:29:55 do you remember there was a proposal
0:29:58 that came out of the California State Assembly
0:30:01 a few weeks ago about giving loans
0:30:04 to undocumented people to buy a home.
0:30:08 And it became this lightning rod thing,
0:30:11 you know, Newsom was basically like, I’m gonna veto this.
0:30:13 No matter what, the politics are terrible.
0:30:16 Nancy Pelosi was asked about it when she was on Bill Maher.
0:30:21 But I was frustrated that it didn’t get into the conversation
0:30:24 that, A, these were people who were paying taxes,
0:30:25 like you said, as most of them are,
0:30:27 and then they don’t necessarily hang around
0:30:28 to claim it on the backside of it,
0:30:30 but that they were people who had to qualify
0:30:33 by our federal mortgage rate standards.
0:30:36 Like these just weren’t people streaming across the border
0:30:40 where we said, oh, here’s $150,000, go have fun.
0:30:41 You know, these are people who were established
0:30:43 in the community had earned enough
0:30:46 to be able to qualify for a mortgage
0:30:48 to get on the property ladder.
0:30:50 And I think that that’s somewhere
0:30:52 that Democrats can really lean into those conversations,
0:30:54 not necessarily in an election year
0:30:56 where it’s going to be distorted.
0:31:00 And I haven’t gone into the fine tuning of the policy,
0:31:04 I was just surprised to hear how it was being spoken about
0:31:07 without all of the real information behind it
0:31:08 or at least coming to light
0:31:12 to make it a more fair and balanced conversation.
0:31:14 But those are the types of immigration conundrums
0:31:18 that I feel like the American public is ready to deal with.
0:31:20 But when you have border crossings,
0:31:23 the way that it has been kind of before Biden’s executive order,
0:31:25 which I guess is now a couple of months old
0:31:28 and cut it what, 55% or something like that.
0:31:30 You know, if you see these images of people streaming in
0:31:32 and equal pass somewhere
0:31:34 that can only hold 10,000, 15,000 people
0:31:37 is getting thousands a day of people coming there
0:31:39 that no one’s actually going to have
0:31:42 that real conversation about the seasonal workers,
0:31:44 the people who work in your homes
0:31:46 who oftentimes raise your children
0:31:48 and take care of your parents
0:31:51 when they’re dying with the level of empathy and care
0:31:55 that I can’t even fathom summoning from myself
0:31:59 as someone who loved my father deeply.
0:32:02 The people who cared for him, it was next level,
0:32:05 like angel level stuff.
0:32:08 And no one, I guess it’s Markely’s point,
0:32:12 you know, no one really wants to be real about this,
0:32:17 even if now the migrants are in Chicago and New York
0:32:21 and Baltimore at higher rates than they ever had been before.
0:32:24 – Also think, and I’m by no means an expert on this issue,
0:32:27 but I think it’s unhealthy.
0:32:29 I think we need to separate the border
0:32:32 from immigration policy because, I mean,
0:32:34 the majority of my understanding is about half
0:32:38 or more of undocumented workers are just overstayers.
0:32:41 They come here legally on a visa and they just stay.
0:32:43 And I think a disproportionate amount
0:32:46 of undocumented workers get here on a plane.
0:32:49 They fly over any wall that we’re planning on building.
0:32:54 And the other, I’ve always thought at the end of the day,
0:32:56 if we were serious about this,
0:32:58 it wouldn’t be that hard to fix.
0:33:01 And that is use some sort of biometric program
0:33:05 and any employer caught with an undocumented worker
0:33:06 pays a $25,000 fine.
0:33:12 And the moment you have on the demand side shrink up
0:33:13 where people are like, oh shit,
0:33:17 if I have five guys in my kitchen and if I get caught
0:33:21 and I can’t and someone comes in and scans their eyes
0:33:23 and says, this is an undocumented worker.
0:33:24 You did not check.
0:33:28 You did not call us five times 25,000, 125 grand.
0:33:33 In my opinion, the whole thing’s over.
0:33:37 – Yeah, but is that the result that you want?
0:33:40 I mean, do you want people who are busting their asses
0:33:43 working in the kitchens at the restaurants
0:33:46 that we all go and sit in to be thrown out?
0:33:48 – Oh, I want to be clear.
0:33:51 I think this is a boon in the American economy.
0:33:52 I’ll use a personal example.
0:33:57 I was renovating a house and I was trying to fix up a house,
0:34:00 didn’t have a lot of money
0:34:05 and had trouble finding people to do a certain job.
0:34:07 My general contractor said, come with me.
0:34:10 We went to this local 7-Eleven,
0:34:14 bunch of undocumented workers, I assume, rush the pickup.
0:34:17 He asked some questions in Spanish.
0:34:19 Six guys jumped in, went to the site,
0:34:20 went to the construction site.
0:34:23 These guys like, they worked around the clock,
0:34:25 around the clock.
0:34:28 They each had a specific skill.
0:34:29 I mean, Jesus Christ,
0:34:32 this is like the most unbelievable workforce
0:34:33 I have ever seen.
0:34:35 And I thought this is,
0:34:38 no wonder people are turning a blind eye to this
0:34:41 because this is just such a flexible, efficient workforce.
0:34:45 I absolutely think these folks do great work
0:34:47 and deserve more empathy.
0:34:49 What I’m saying is I just think it’s cynical,
0:34:53 all these calls for border protection.
0:34:55 – I take it back, you’re not a bad person.
0:35:00 – If for whatever reason, rationally or irrationally,
0:35:02 you wanted to stem the flow,
0:35:06 just punish the employer because once demand drives it,
0:35:08 but that’s never an option
0:35:10 because those are nice white Republicans
0:35:12 employing those people.
0:35:14 We don’t go to the source.
0:35:15 You’re never gonna,
0:35:17 if you can’t keep drugs out of prison,
0:35:21 the notion that you’re gonna keep talented resourceful people
0:35:24 out of opportunity and economic wellbeing
0:35:25 because there’s some fucking wall
0:35:27 or some sort of border control,
0:35:30 there’s no way you would have to,
0:35:32 it strikes me if we ever got serious
0:35:34 about quote unquote undocumented workers,
0:35:37 it would be a lot less complex than people think,
0:35:39 it would be going after the demand side
0:35:41 and just punishing the employers,
0:35:43 but no one wants to talk about that
0:35:45 ’cause those are good Americans.
0:35:48 Anyways, I don’t think we’re serious about this problem.
0:35:49 – Well, we’re definitely not
0:35:52 and we’re gonna lose elections because of it
0:35:53 or Democrats are.
0:35:55 I mean, it was one of I think the strongest arguments
0:35:58 for putting Mark Kelly on the ticket.
0:36:00 I mean, he has the best bio ever
0:36:05 and Gabby Giffords is otherworldly impressive and inspiring.
0:36:08 I mean, we would have lost,
0:36:09 potentially lost the Arizona Senate seat.
0:36:12 So I think Chuck Schumer lost his mind about that,
0:36:15 but having a Democrat that is conversant
0:36:18 in the mechanics of immigration,
0:36:19 like you say from the border,
0:36:22 but also what happens once they’re here
0:36:27 and what life looks like from a humane and kind perspective,
0:36:29 but also a realist perspective,
0:36:32 I think would have been of huge value.
0:36:36 And I know we’re gonna dip into talking about
0:36:39 whether walls has panned out to be the best choice
0:36:40 for all of that.
0:36:41 If you’re talking about immigration,
0:36:45 I’m picking Mark Kelly 10 times out of 10 over Tim Walls
0:36:48 in terms of talking about it.
0:36:49 – Well, he’s on the border
0:36:51 and he speaks eloquently on it.
0:36:53 Let’s use that.
0:36:55 So by the way, just as I was saying, it didn’t matter.
0:36:56 I’m now looking at some polls
0:36:58 that our producer Caroline pulled together.
0:37:01 And we have new Reuters episodes.
0:37:04 National polls shows Harris leading by five points, 47, 42.
0:37:09 The Economist poll shows Harris up by three, 49 to 46.
0:37:12 A CNN flash poll, a majority of debate watchers
0:37:13 say Harris outperforms Trump.
0:37:15 Yeah, we know that.
0:37:18 But it does look like, my understanding is
0:37:21 she has to solidly get more,
0:37:23 she has to be up by two or three points
0:37:25 to win the electoral college.
0:37:26 That accurate?
0:37:27 – Yeah, that’s right.
0:37:29 And I know you had Nate Silver on
0:37:33 and his probability forecast is a bit of an outlier now,
0:37:36 but he has some new numbers up about the odds
0:37:38 of many different things happening.
0:37:42 But what’s so sick to me about our system
0:37:43 is Republicans don’t even try
0:37:45 to win the popular vote anymore.
0:37:49 Like the idea of trying to win a majority of voters
0:37:50 is out the window.
0:37:52 And it’s just a game of chess,
0:37:55 figuring out what states you can cobble together for this.
0:37:57 And Kamala, yeah, in two points,
0:38:00 I would still be sweating going into election night
0:38:02 if she was three or four points.
0:38:03 People would feel a lot better
0:38:05 about her odds of winning the electoral college.
0:38:08 But I should say the Fox forecast came out
0:38:09 at the end of last week.
0:38:12 And two pivotal states, Georgia and North Carolina,
0:38:16 which were lean Republican, are now toss-ups.
0:38:18 And the Harris campaign is a very serious
0:38:20 about North Carolina.
0:38:23 I mean, they’ve shown a capacity to win Georgia before.
0:38:24 And I think Trump, you know,
0:38:26 whoever gave him his come to Jesus moment
0:38:28 about being nice to Brian Kemp,
0:38:30 you know, finally got through on that one.
0:38:34 But North Carolina would be a fascinating pickup
0:38:35 for Democrats.
0:38:36 – And that’s where money comes in.
0:38:39 They now have the money to sort of put in field offices
0:38:42 and go hard after states where they maybe only have
0:38:43 a one in five chance of winning,
0:38:45 but they have a one in five chance of winning.
0:38:49 It feels like this is where those hundreds of millions
0:38:51 that she’s out raising him right now
0:38:54 would be really powerful.
0:38:57 Stay with us.
0:39:05 I think one of the biggest problems in America
0:39:07 is that we have minority rule.
0:39:10 And that is, you know, 20% of our population
0:39:13 has 80% of the senators, whether you look at gun control.
0:39:17 I mean, there’s just, whether you look at the majority
0:39:19 of Americans favor bodily autonomy.
0:39:20 We really do have minority rule
0:39:22 on some of the most important issues.
0:39:25 And I would argue, I think a lot about marketing,
0:39:29 the three best marketers in the world by sector or groups.
0:39:31 First and foremost, the best marketers in history
0:39:33 were the tobacco guys.
0:39:35 When your product’s primary benefits
0:39:36 are death, disease, and disability,
0:39:38 and you’ve convinced people that it’s cool,
0:39:42 and you sell a product at 96 points a margin, unbelievable.
0:39:43 Actually, I’ll do four.
0:39:46 My industry is the only industry in the world
0:39:48 that can charge a six-figure price tag
0:39:51 at 97 points of gross profit margin,
0:39:53 and artificially creates scarcity,
0:39:55 becoming forces to cast system.
0:39:57 In some, we’re sort of mendacious fox
0:39:58 that wake up every morning and say,
0:40:00 how do I reduce my accountability
0:40:01 while increasing my compensation?
0:40:04 I know despite sitting on the GDP of Costa Rica,
0:40:06 I’m only gonna let in 1,500 people
0:40:08 ’cause it makes me feel good about myself.
0:40:10 We’re the best marketers in the world.
0:40:12 MIT, Stanford, Harvard are the best brands in the world.
0:40:14 It’s not Apple.
0:40:19 Number three would be the industrial financial complex.
0:40:22 Anyone on CNBC, hedge funds, mutual funds,
0:40:24 it’s all a total fucking grift.
0:40:28 If you took every single hedge fund, mutual fund, 401K,
0:40:30 everything you’re in, and you added it all up,
0:40:32 it’s exactly underperformed the S&P
0:40:33 by the amount of the fees.
0:40:36 We should all just put our money in low-cost index funds.
0:40:40 The entire financial industrial complex is a giant grift,
0:40:42 but they put some old guy in suspenders
0:40:44 and the Wall Street Journal on CNBC
0:40:45 and we’re under the impression
0:40:46 he actually understands which way the market
0:40:49 is gonna go, spoiler alert, he doesn’t.
0:40:51 And then my rounding it out,
0:40:53 the fourth best marketers in the world
0:40:54 are the Republican Party,
0:40:55 who as far as I can tell,
0:40:59 spends 70 or 80% of their energies
0:41:01 representing the top 1% in corporations
0:41:04 and yet every year get about 47% of the vote.
0:41:08 That is an incredible feat to convince these people
0:41:12 that yeah, we’re for you when really at the end of the day,
0:41:15 who they really represent our corporations
0:41:16 and the Uber wealthy.
0:41:18 Anyways, that’s my TED Talk around marketing.
0:41:19 Any thoughts, Jessica?
0:41:22 – I agree with it and my question would be,
0:41:24 do you think that the Republicans are really that good
0:41:28 or that the Dems are really that bad?
0:41:32 – Yes, I think that’s the correct question.
0:41:34 So just as we wrap up here,
0:41:37 let’s touch base on Walls being the VP pick.
0:41:38 We had Nate Silver on the property pod
0:41:40 as you referenced a few weeks ago
0:41:45 and he thinks that we should have picked Shapiro.
0:41:48 By the way, I was really hoping for Shapiro
0:41:50 and looking back now,
0:41:52 I actually think Walls was the right choice
0:41:55 because I think capturing younger men
0:41:59 around sort of this aspirational vision of masculinity
0:42:02 is serving them really well.
0:42:03 Republicans argue that Walls
0:42:06 has pushed a very progressive agenda in Minnesota,
0:42:08 whereas Democrats see him as someone
0:42:09 with strong Midwestern appeal
0:42:11 who connects with everyday voters.
0:42:12 What are your thoughts?
0:42:15 How would you evaluate Walls’ performance so far?
0:42:19 – So I’d bifurcate it into two buckets.
0:42:21 So one is the feels bucket
0:42:23 and then one is like the practicality bucket.
0:42:25 And on the feels,
0:42:28 I think that he’s been a fantastic partner for her.
0:42:30 And I don’t wanna make this about gender,
0:42:35 but I think that a female candidate for president,
0:42:37 especially one who has been shaky in the past
0:42:40 and has had a tough time with the press,
0:42:43 she wasn’t successful in the 2020 primary,
0:42:45 obviously to get the Democratic nomination.
0:42:47 I think it matters a hell of a lot
0:42:50 that she picked the person who she felt supported by,
0:42:52 who she connected with,
0:42:55 who’s as a couple, her and Doug connected
0:42:58 with Tim Walls and Gwen Walls.
0:43:00 And I think that she does better
0:43:02 when she feels good about herself.
0:43:03 And you saw that post-debate.
0:43:05 If you watched, she did a rally,
0:43:07 I think it was in North Carolina the day after.
0:43:10 And she was loose and fun.
0:43:12 And there was substance in it,
0:43:14 but there was a joy and not in the
0:43:15 we’re coconut pill joy way,
0:43:20 like a genuine joy in doing this job of campaigning
0:43:22 to be able to be commander in chief.
0:43:25 And I think that Tim Walls is a huge part of that.
0:43:27 In the practicality bucket,
0:43:29 I already referenced the fact that his favorability
0:43:32 of the four people that are vying for these jobs,
0:43:35 so Trump, Kamala, JD Vance and Tim Walls,
0:43:37 he has the highest favorability by far.
0:43:39 I mean, some polls even have it at 11.
0:43:41 I think one had it at 14.
0:43:44 And what Republicans are throwing at him.
0:43:46 Oh, did you hear that he was an assistant coach
0:43:48 and not a coach?
0:43:49 Like that stuff is not sticking.
0:43:52 I think the military conversation about,
0:43:55 whether he retired commander, major sergeant,
0:43:57 I think is the term or not,
0:43:59 that was resonant with some people,
0:44:01 especially in the veteran community,
0:44:03 but he has such a solid record
0:44:05 that isn’t necessarily progressive.
0:44:08 Like he runs the sixth best state in the country
0:44:10 to do business in.
0:44:12 That doesn’t seem like a socialist to me.
0:44:14 So you’re going to talk in point, I didn’t know that.
0:44:16 Oh, you, I leased it to you.
0:44:20 I just know the prince was born and raised there.
0:44:21 That is also important.
0:44:24 And I’m sure they will let him use the music for it.
0:44:28 But if you go back and look at his reelection in 2022,
0:44:30 that was after the summer of Black Lives Matter,
0:44:33 the riots, all of the issues would defund the police.
0:44:35 And he won by eight points.
0:44:38 He paced ahead of Biden’s margin
0:44:40 when he was in the state at 2020.
0:44:42 Originally, his congressional district.
0:44:44 Yeah, and like, I think that people just can’t believe
0:44:49 that the guy whose students staffed his first campaign,
0:44:53 taking on a serious right winger is a bad guy.
0:44:55 Now, Josh Shapiro, you know,
0:44:57 and I think we talked about this maybe in person
0:45:00 and not necessarily on any podcast venue.
0:45:02 Josh Shapiro was great at the DNC.
0:45:04 I expected to be brought to tears, right?
0:45:07 But by this Baruch Obama situation.
0:45:11 And I found him to be incredibly compelling.
0:45:12 Baruch Obama, you’re good.
0:45:13 That’s what we call him.
0:45:14 No, no, it wasn’t me.
0:45:17 The other Jews came up with that first.
0:45:22 But if this somehow comes down to Israel in some way,
0:45:24 Tim Walls wrote a master’s thesis
0:45:26 about being able to teach the Holocaust better
0:45:28 to make sure that we never actually go back
0:45:30 to a time where something like that is possible.
0:45:34 But if you hear it from a Jew, it often sounds better.
0:45:37 And Josh Shapiro has that and he’s tight
0:45:39 and he’s really good.
0:45:40 But at the end of the day,
0:45:42 it didn’t seem like he really wanted that job.
0:45:43 And you know what it’s like.
0:45:45 You’ve, you know, employed thousands of people.
0:45:48 If someone is not into the job that they have,
0:45:51 can they really do it at the level that you need
0:45:52 when the stakes are this high?
0:45:56 And Tim Walls wants that job so bad.
0:45:59 So what I’ve heard, I mean, this is all hearsay.
0:46:01 I don’t know.
0:46:03 I heard on the Friday before the pick,
0:46:07 he had it because quite frankly winning Pennsylvania
0:46:12 would probably, it makes the path to presidency
0:46:14 for her pretty like the landing lights would be on.
0:46:17 He’s very popular in Pennsylvania.
0:46:20 He would inoculate her around the kind of Israel issue.
0:46:25 And also I think he was just primed to be an attack dog
0:46:29 because, which is a VP is supposed to do
0:46:31 because he’s already filed suits against Trump
0:46:35 on election interference.
0:46:38 Yeah, so he was kind of ready to go.
0:46:40 I think it comes down to ego.
0:46:41 I think, I don’t think she wanted someone
0:46:42 who wanted her job.
0:46:43 He doesn’t want that job.
0:46:45 He wants to be president.
0:46:47 And I think she was very drawn to Walls.
0:46:49 And I also heard that a lot of people in the far left
0:46:53 were very uncomfortable with Shapiro on call then.
0:46:56 But let’s talk, what are your predictions
0:46:57 just as we wrap up here?
0:46:59 What are your predictions for the VP of debate
0:47:01 that’s supposed to take place?
0:47:03 I think it’s on October the 1st.
0:47:05 What do you think is going to happen?
0:47:08 I worry that they’re going to talk past each other,
0:47:10 which I think was a little bit of the problem
0:47:11 for people with the Harris-Crom to be.
0:47:13 He’s a great moderator, right?
0:47:13 Who’s moderating it?
0:47:14 Do we know?
0:47:16 Oh, I don’t, I should know.
0:47:20 I just hope my really strong suggestion
0:47:22 is that it’s that David Muir guy again,
0:47:24 except he does it without a shirt on.
0:47:26 Jesus Christ, that guy’s dreamy.
0:47:26 What’s that his name?
0:47:27 David Muir?
0:47:28 What’s his name?
0:47:30 Yes, I saw him at the DNC.
0:47:35 And I stopped and I watched as he watched by.
0:47:38 I said this on Pivot and I hate to recycle points,
0:47:39 but I do it a lot.
0:47:41 I think Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise
0:47:43 would have both been Academy Award winners
0:47:44 in their 20s and 30s.
0:47:47 Him, Tom for “Born on the Fourth of July,”
0:47:51 and Brad Pitt for this odd movie called “12 Monkeys”
0:47:55 with Bruce Willis where he played a mentally ill
0:47:58 as son of a rich kid who ends up starting a global pandemic.
0:47:59 They’re both outstanding actors,
0:48:01 but they’re so good looking
0:48:04 that it diminishes people’s perception of their acting skills.
0:48:06 I think that guy Muir, whatever his name is,
0:48:08 I think he’s just too hot to be taken seriously
0:48:09 as a moderator.
0:48:10 I think he’s so good looking.
0:48:12 Well, I agree with the good looking part,
0:48:13 but you don’t think he was taken seriously?
0:48:15 And Lindsay Davis also beautiful.
0:48:16 Well, I think he’s had, in a weird way,
0:48:18 I think he’s had to work harder.
0:48:20 I thought they did a really good job.
0:48:21 I’ll be curious, that debate–
0:48:24 Well, now they’re saying that they were fed the questions.
0:48:26 You know, there’s always some conspiracy theory.
0:48:27 And it’s like if they were fed the question,
0:48:28 she would have answered them.
0:48:31 Like, I don’t understand that we were drawing a line
0:48:32 between those things.
0:48:33 I agree with you.
0:48:35 That’s gonna be a food fight.
0:48:37 In the next one or two weeks,
0:48:39 any things you’re following
0:48:41 or thinking that are important in terms of this race,
0:48:44 it feels like her momentum continues.
0:48:45 What do you think in the next,
0:48:47 any thoughts about what’s coming up?
0:48:48 That’ll be a big pivotal point
0:48:50 other than the VP debate,
0:48:51 which I think will come and go.
0:48:52 And I think it’ll be entertainment.
0:48:54 I’m not sure it’s gonna have much of an impact.
0:48:58 I’m really focused on getting black men,
0:49:01 in particular, back into the coalition.
0:49:03 You know, the threat of losing them to the couch
0:49:05 or whatever one says.
0:49:08 And then I’m interested as well in the conversion
0:49:12 on these Republicans for Democrats now.
0:49:14 So the democracy voters, you know,
0:49:17 who Liz Cheney is talking about.
0:49:19 And the Harris-Wall’s campaign
0:49:22 is definitely doing a big push for them.
0:49:23 But that is a tricky cohort
0:49:26 because those are people who are maybe bad fellows
0:49:28 for a couple of election cycles,
0:49:30 but odds are, are going back.
0:49:32 So how do you get them for 2024?
0:49:35 And then how also do you make your tent big enough
0:49:38 to keep them around in the longer term?
0:49:39 What about you?
0:49:40 – I like it.
0:49:41 I like it.
0:49:42 That makes sense.
0:49:43 Okay, so that’s all for this episode.
0:49:45 Our producers are Caroline Shagran
0:49:46 and David Toledo.
0:49:48 Andrew Burroughs is our technical director.
0:49:51 You can find Raging Moderates on the Prop G-Pod
0:49:52 every Tuesday again.
0:49:55 You can find Raging Moderates on the Prop G-Pod
0:49:57 every Tuesday.
0:49:59 All right, Jess, we will see you next week.
0:50:01 Thanks everybody for tuning in.
0:50:04 (upbeat music)
0:00:07 – Welcome to Raging Moderates, I’m Scott Galloway.
0:00:09 – And I’m Jessica Tarlev.
0:00:10 – Where are you, Jessica?
0:00:13 – I’m at home in New York, not very glamorous, but you.
0:00:14 – Really?
0:00:17 – You’ve had the weekend of the century, right?
0:00:19 – Yeah, so just so you know when I ask you a question,
0:00:21 what I’m really saying is I want you to ask me.
0:00:23 – Yeah, I get it.
0:00:24 Didn’t I do it well enough?
0:00:25 – Yeah, that was perfect.
0:00:27 – It was like two seconds on me, and then right to you.
0:00:28 Okay, good.
0:00:29 – That’s right, very good.
0:00:33 I was in Scotland this weekend in Aberdeen
0:00:35 for my 50th birthday,
0:00:40 and I am now in Keptantib, and it is beautiful here.
0:00:44 So I’m about two glasses of Domain Odd Inn.
0:00:48 So, anyway, I spent, you know, that’s called a weekday.
0:00:51 But yeah, I had an absolutely wonderful weekend
0:00:52 with a bunch of actually, a bunch of people
0:00:53 I think you might know.
0:00:55 And we’ve got a lot to talk about today,
0:00:59 but first and foremost, our first two episodes, Jessica,
0:01:03 had, are going to, did about 100,000 downloads
0:01:06 in 24 hours, which means they’ll probably do about
0:01:09 200,000 over the next 30 days.
0:01:13 And I believe that means more people in our first week
0:01:15 are listening to Raid Dream Moderates
0:01:18 and are viewing 80% of cable news programming.
0:01:22 So we’re stars, Jessica, we’re stars.
0:01:23 – Mostly you.
0:01:24 I’m just here for the ride.
0:01:26 – Yeah, that’s it.
0:01:27 – Did, am I doing this right?
0:01:30 Was that how I was supposed to get it back to you?
0:01:31 No, it’s really exciting.
0:01:34 And also just kind of understanding the viewership
0:01:38 or listenership versus TV is fascinating for me.
0:01:40 So excited all around.
0:01:43 And I’m glad that the listeners have found
0:01:44 that what we’re talking about is resonating with them.
0:01:48 I have seen some comments that were no moderates,
0:01:50 but a moderate can be someone that votes
0:01:52 for the Democrats, by the way.
0:01:55 But we’ll prove it to them over time.
0:01:56 – Today we’re gonna talk about
0:01:58 the second assassination attempt on Donald Trump.
0:02:00 The aftermath following the presidential debate
0:02:04 and whether Tim Walls is benefiting the Democratic ticket.
0:02:07 So all right, we’re under two months away from election
0:02:08 and things are getting more intense.
0:02:11 The Secret Service is investigating another attempt
0:02:13 to assassination on former President Trump
0:02:16 at his international golf club in Florida.
0:02:17 The gunman, three to 500 yards away,
0:02:22 had an AK-47 style rifle, a GoPro and backpacks
0:02:25 when law enforcement intervened.
0:02:27 I know so little about this, Jessica,
0:02:29 ’cause I’ve been eating haggis
0:02:30 and drinking anything within reach.
0:02:32 Can you kind of break down what happened here
0:02:34 and what you know about it?
0:02:36 – Well, you’re behind most people,
0:02:38 but we don’t know a ton yet.
0:02:42 So it’s not that bad that you’re just joining us on this one.
0:02:44 We’re going to find more in the coming days about it.
0:02:48 And there’ll be another Secret Service investigation into it.
0:02:51 No idea how this guy was even able to get,
0:02:54 I think it was like three or 400 yards away
0:02:56 from the former president.
0:02:59 He has a checkered past convicted felon
0:03:02 who’s still allowed to get guns mentally unstable
0:03:05 so we could have the whole gun reform conversation about that.
0:03:08 His voting history is,
0:03:12 I didn’t know there were people like this that existed.
0:03:14 He voted for Trump in 2016 and 2019.
0:03:16 He was really into Tulsi Gavard,
0:03:18 which to me is also kind of like being into Trump,
0:03:23 but then he wanted Biden to win, which worked out.
0:03:27 And then he wanted a Vivek Ramaswamy and Nikki Haley ticket
0:03:32 for 2024, which if you followed the level of vitriol
0:03:34 that the two of them spewed at one another,
0:03:38 you would know that that is maybe slightly more plausible
0:03:42 than a Donald Trump Kamala Harris ticket, but not much.
0:03:45 And the guy was just truly out of his mind.
0:03:50 We don’t know yet what quote unquote inspired him.
0:03:54 The New York Times interviewed him in 2023
0:03:55 and discovered that he was a nut.
0:03:58 He was trying to go and serve in Ukraine,
0:04:01 actually fighting with the Ukrainians.
0:04:02 He’s all over the place.
0:04:04 I’m glad that the former president is safe.
0:04:08 And I think it’s pretty clear that he needs some beefing up
0:04:10 of his detail, which President Biden
0:04:12 said something about that this morning.
0:04:15 And hopefully Congress will just pass something quickly
0:04:17 to give him extra money for protection
0:04:22 because it feels like this is heading towards being a trend.
0:04:25 – What do you think of Elon’s now deleted tweet?
0:04:27 He said, and no one is even trying
0:04:30 to assassinate Biden Kamala.
0:04:33 And he put this out to his 170 million people on X.
0:04:35 Now, what are your thoughts when a guy like that
0:04:38 with so much reach says something like that?
0:04:40 Is it Democrats overreacting and being indignant
0:04:43 as we often are about everything?
0:04:45 Or is it irresponsible?
0:04:46 Or is the answer just yes?
0:04:49 – Yeah, I think it’s yes.
0:04:52 And I actually found his tweet last week
0:04:54 when Taylor Swift endorsed Trump
0:04:56 and he said, okay, I’ll impregnate you
0:04:59 or something like that to be even nuttier
0:05:02 and more offensive than this.
0:05:05 Him saying, why is no one trying to assassinate Biden
0:05:08 /Kamala feels just on brand for someone
0:05:11 who has a level of genius within him
0:05:14 that I’ll never be able to fully grasp even
0:05:18 and has become so terminally online
0:05:22 that he’s incapable of having normal human interaction.
0:05:25 And it fits in nicely with where I think
0:05:29 a certain faction of the Republican party is right now.
0:05:31 And you notice it in the way that JD Vance
0:05:33 has been talking or Donald Trump at the debate
0:05:36 where he just started yelling things that he saw online
0:05:40 or that he saw on TV, which a policy does not make
0:05:43 or a true statement does not make.
0:05:46 But Elon Musk, I think there’s no better encapsulation
0:05:49 of what he has turned Twitter into than that comment.
0:05:53 And when he took it down and justified it, I guess,
0:05:55 by saying, oh, I guess things that you say in private
0:05:58 that are a joke aren’t actually that funny out in the wild.
0:06:01 Like, who was laughing at that in private?
0:06:05 – Yeah, I didn’t, I’m of two minds.
0:06:10 And that is, I think people should be able to say
0:06:11 what they want.
0:06:14 I find that people get very sensitive around,
0:06:16 I don’t know, jumpy around the stuff
0:06:18 when I don’t think people are gonna,
0:06:20 oh, shit, I don’t know, there’s a lot of crazies around there.
0:06:24 But something I’ve thought about is that,
0:06:26 and I think it was my dad said this to me.
0:06:28 He said, have you become more measured
0:06:31 as your audience and followership has grown?
0:06:32 Have you become more measured?
0:06:35 And I said, no, I try to stay as authentic
0:06:36 and as provocative and he’s like,
0:06:38 you should become more measured.
0:06:39 And I said, well, why do you say that?
0:06:41 And he goes, because when you have more reach,
0:06:42 you need to be more thoughtful
0:06:44 about the ramifications of your reach.
0:06:46 And that kind of– – Spider-man, right?
0:06:48 – Right, that just struck me.
0:06:50 And I thought, well, maybe he’s right.
0:06:53 Maybe I should be a little bit more measured or thoughtful.
0:06:56 And not that that’s actually–
0:06:57 – What happened to that?
0:07:00 – Yeah, we’ll see, it’s coming, it’s coming.
0:07:03 – I’m curious, do you think, is there any evidence
0:07:05 the last assassination attempt?
0:07:07 Trump had amazing political instincts.
0:07:10 And that image of him pumping his fist in the air
0:07:12 with blood on his face and the American flag above him,
0:07:16 I believe that will likely be the image of the decade.
0:07:20 I just thought that was, I mean, that was incredible.
0:07:22 And I do think he registered a bit of a bump.
0:07:25 Do you think he’s gonna get a bump from this?
0:07:28 – No, I don’t.
0:07:31 I think that what helped in terms of the bump
0:07:33 with the first assassination attempt is,
0:07:35 first of all, the person got a shot off,
0:07:36 which is not what happened here.
0:07:38 Basically, they took down a guy
0:07:42 who was waiting for Trump a couple holes away.
0:07:46 But someone was unfortunately murdered at that rally
0:07:49 and Trump was bloodied from it hitting his ear.
0:07:51 And then it went into the RNC.
0:07:55 And I think the timing of that worked together,
0:07:59 essentially, to create this martyrdom mood,
0:08:02 which I was feeling firsthand being in Milwaukee.
0:08:04 There was an invincibility about Trump
0:08:06 and the party that happened there.
0:08:09 This feels like an important point of discussion
0:08:11 and something that we need to think about
0:08:15 and how rotten our politics is.
0:08:19 Even if this wasn’t necessarily politics motivated,
0:08:21 but how dangerous it is for politicians,
0:08:23 which is something that we’re seeing across the board.
0:08:27 But I don’t expect Trump will be redeemed
0:08:31 from a bad debate performance by a bump from this guy.
0:08:35 – We’ll be right back.
0:08:42 Support for Prop G comes from Fetch Pet Insurance.
0:08:44 I love doing ads for Fetch.
0:08:45 I am a huge dog person.
0:08:47 I think you’ll notice both Leia and Gangster,
0:08:50 my great-tang, and my Puerto Rican rescue ham.
0:08:53 We think he’s a dog, and by the way, Leia,
0:08:54 Leia’s big and scary-looking.
0:08:57 You can go up and literally poke Leia in the eye
0:08:58 or take her food from her,
0:09:00 and she’s not gonna do anything,
0:09:03 except maybe rear up her hind quarters against you,
0:09:06 whereas the little one will snap your finger off,
0:09:07 the little cute one.
0:09:08 Anyways, pet parents know better than anyone
0:09:11 how much joy and whimsy an animal can bring to a family,
0:09:12 but they also know that it’s only a matter of time
0:09:15 before the unexpected happens,
0:09:16 and the unexpected is also, unfortunately,
0:09:17 usually expensive.
0:09:19 So unless you happen to have thousands of dollars
0:09:21 lying around to drop at the vet,
0:09:23 you might want to try Fetch Pet Insurance.
0:09:26 Fetch is the most comprehensive pet insurance covering,
0:09:28 but other providers charge extra for or don’t cover at all.
0:09:31 Fetch even covers acupuncture.
0:09:32 Get that, acupuncture for dogs.
0:09:35 Fetch covers up to 90% of unexpected vet bills,
0:09:37 and with Fetch, you can use any vet in the U.S. or Canada.
0:09:39 Fetch covers more.
0:09:41 More protection, more savings, more love.
0:09:43 With Fetch, more is more.
0:09:46 Get your free quote today at fetchpet.com/propg.
0:09:49 That’s fetchpet.com/propg.
0:09:51 Fetchpet.com/propg.
0:09:56 Support for the show comes from Monarch.
0:09:58 Managing your money in today’s world
0:09:59 can get complicated fast,
0:10:00 keeping track of your credit cards,
0:10:02 investment accounts, and more.
0:10:04 That’s a lot of tabs to keep open on your browser,
0:10:08 not to mention if you’re combining finances with a partner.
0:10:09 Good problems to have,
0:10:11 but you might want to simplify for that.
0:10:13 You could try Monarch.
0:10:15 The all-in-one personal finance app with Monarch
0:10:17 can get a comprehensive view of all your accounts,
0:10:20 investments, transactions, and more.
0:10:21 You can create custom budgets,
0:10:23 track progress towards financial goals,
0:10:25 and collaborate with your partner, plus.
0:10:26 Monarch can help you make smart money moves
0:10:28 to get you closer to your goals.
0:10:30 With Monarch, you can easily share your accounts
0:10:32 with your partner or even your financial advisor.
0:10:35 You can log into one place, get a comprehensive view,
0:10:37 adjust what you need, and get on with your life.
0:10:40 Run your finances, don’t let your finances run you.
0:10:42 Right now, listeners of the show
0:10:43 will get an extended 30-day free trial
0:10:47 when you go to monarchmoney.com/propg.
0:10:51 That’s M-O-N-A-R-C-H-M-O-N-E-Y,
0:10:55 dot com slash propg for your extended 30-day free trial.
0:11:01 Okay, moving on, let’s talk about the debate.
0:11:03 67 million people tuned in,
0:11:06 15 million more than the Biden-Trump debate back in June.
0:11:07 Pundits are calling it a loss for Trump
0:11:09 and saying Harris baited him
0:11:10 while avoiding going deep into policy,
0:11:13 but ultimately, it’s the voters whose opinion matters.
0:11:16 It’s been somewhere between two thirds and 70% thought
0:11:18 that Harris won the debate,
0:11:21 15 million more than Biden-Trump debates back in June.
0:11:23 Still, plenty of voters didn’t watch it.
0:11:26 The polling data I’ve seen says the following.
0:11:29 She won, and it kind of doesn’t matter.
0:11:30 What are your thoughts?
0:11:35 Agreed, she won, the kind of on the more rosy side of it.
0:11:42 She needed to prove that she was capable of this job,
0:11:44 that she could look presidential
0:11:46 and that she could open herself up
0:11:48 to the public more than she had.
0:11:50 And I might have frankly underestimated
0:11:54 how much that was bugging people who were unsure
0:11:56 or even were going to vote for her,
0:11:58 but wanted her to do a bit more work
0:12:00 in terms of earning that vote.
0:12:01 And it was interesting,
0:12:03 I was listening to the Daily this morning
0:12:05 and they had undecided voters on,
0:12:06 they’ve been, it’s actually really cool.
0:12:08 They have like a long-term tracking study
0:12:11 with these voters following them through everything,
0:12:14 people through Biden being the candidate,
0:12:16 not being the candidate in Trump assassination,
0:12:17 the debate, et cetera.
0:12:18 And there was one woman who they interviewed,
0:12:22 she’s in her 40s, has two daughters.
0:12:26 And she said, I’m still not exactly sure what I’m going to do.
0:12:28 I was leaning towards writing someone in,
0:12:30 but now that I saw the debate,
0:12:31 I feel like I can make more of a choice,
0:12:33 which she didn’t say it was gonna be Kamala Harris,
0:12:36 but that was implied from what she was saying
0:12:39 and her concerns about Donald Trump.
0:12:42 There is that snap reaction polling
0:12:44 that showed that for the undecideds,
0:12:47 her favorability went up pretty substantially
0:12:48 in the double digits,
0:12:50 but there were a slew of polls that came out
0:12:52 over the weekend.
0:12:56 I won’t bore everyone with like 40 minutes on polls,
0:12:59 but what has been really important to see is
0:13:02 she’s crossing the 50% threshold in a couple of them.
0:13:05 And these were all grade A or grade B pollsters,
0:13:07 so not pieces of trash
0:13:09 that people like to run around amplifying.
0:13:11 She’s gaining like an ABC/Ipsos poll,
0:13:14 she’s gaining with Black voters, Latino voters,
0:13:18 and Gen Z voters, critical components of a win.
0:13:20 She’s not quite at Biden’s numbers from 2020,
0:13:21 but inching that way.
0:13:25 And then I don’t know if the Ann Selzer poll from Iowa
0:13:28 permeated the Haggis bubble in Aberdeen.
0:13:30 – Haggis bubble, that’s good.
0:13:33 – Yeah, you can keep that. – You’re learning, that’s good.
0:13:34 – But it was a really big deal.
0:13:36 So Ann Selzer is known to be
0:13:39 one of the most accurate pollsters in the country.
0:13:41 She had Biden down 18 to Trump
0:13:44 when he had Trump won by eight in 2020.
0:13:46 And she just released a survey showing
0:13:47 that Kamala is only down four.
0:13:49 Now, do I think she’s winning Iowa?
0:13:52 Absolutely not, but it’s a really important bellwether
0:13:55 for how white Midwestern voters
0:13:57 are feeling about Kamala Harris.
0:14:00 And that then bodes well for Wisconsin and Michigan as well.
0:14:01 And maybe a little bit of Pennsylvania,
0:14:05 but that seems like it’s going to be the real difficult piece
0:14:09 of this puzzle for the Harris campaign.
0:14:11 – So Trump would never admit defeat,
0:14:13 but we’ve seen some of his most loyal supporters,
0:14:17 including your Fox News colleague, Neil Cavuto,
0:14:21 RFK Jr. and Frank Lund,
0:14:24 saying that the debate likely cost him the election.
0:14:26 How do you, do you think?
0:14:28 I thought it was something like that.
0:14:30 I would have thought, and I guess it’s not his brand,
0:14:33 but you’re, I mean, you’re an expert in messaging and data.
0:14:35 I would have thought that he should have said,
0:14:36 I had a bad night.
0:14:37 She was great, congratulations.
0:14:39 Check out our policies.
0:14:40 I’ll be a better president.
0:14:41 She’s a better debater.
0:14:42 I’ll be a better president.
0:14:44 Instead, he went into the spin room,
0:14:47 which I thought was almost a little bit desperate
0:14:51 and is trying to recast it as, no, just ignore everything.
0:14:52 I won.
0:14:53 How do you think he’s handled the debate?
0:14:54 – Right, like, I hope you blacked out
0:14:56 for the last 97 minutes.
0:14:59 And here I am to tell you about, they’re eating the cats.
0:15:01 They’re eating the dogs.
0:15:03 I now sing that whole thing in TikTok form,
0:15:04 which I don’t have on my phone,
0:15:07 but you can actually go on TikTok on your computer
0:15:10 without inviting it into your life.
0:15:15 You know, Donald Trump, his ego and his need for attention
0:15:16 just kicked into high gear.
0:15:18 And that’s why he went into the spin room
0:15:20 and kind of watching who the Republicans had
0:15:22 versus who the Democrats had.
0:15:23 You know, we had the best in class.
0:15:26 Gavin Newsom out there, Josh Shapiro out there.
0:15:30 But I do think that there is a case to be made
0:15:32 for Donald Trump not hurting himself that badly
0:15:35 in the debate for people who were looking
0:15:37 for a clear vision from Kamala Harris
0:15:40 and actually answering the explicit question.
0:15:42 And we talked about that a little with the,
0:15:43 you know, the first question was,
0:15:45 are you better off today than you were four years ago?
0:15:48 And she didn’t answer that on immigration.
0:15:50 Now, I really, I agree with the answer
0:15:52 that the bipartisan border bill
0:15:53 would make a huge difference.
0:15:56 Lots of conservative Republicans even agree with that.
0:16:00 But like, Secretary Mayorkas is on with Azra Klein
0:16:01 on his latest podcast.
0:16:03 And Azra Klein is really struggling
0:16:05 to get that answer to the question.
0:16:08 Why did you do nothing for three years?
0:16:11 And for people who are going to vote on immigration
0:16:13 or that’s going to be in their top three,
0:16:15 they want at least some sort of answer.
0:16:18 If you want to say, well, we needed more cheap labor,
0:16:20 I accept that.
0:16:24 Or we thought it wasn’t going to get this overwhelming.
0:16:25 I accept that.
0:16:25 It’s a tricky period.
0:16:28 You’re in COVID, everyone’s being held.
0:16:30 Then suddenly the floodgates open.
0:16:31 We were overwhelmed.
0:16:33 We made X, Y, and Z mistakes.
0:16:35 This is what we’re doing to fix it.
0:16:36 And so if you were someone looking
0:16:37 for that kind of specificity,
0:16:39 and like Brett Stevens, for instance,
0:16:40 is someone looking for that,
0:16:44 I hope he’s going to end up voting for her in the end.
0:16:48 But she didn’t satisfy that itch for a lot of people.
0:16:50 And that’s why I think a second debate or town halls
0:16:54 where I think she would really shine would help her case.
0:16:59 – So Trump is now saying it’s not going to debate her again.
0:17:01 Do you think that’s the smart move?
0:17:03 – I think that they could both.
0:17:06 It’s weird, I’m a Pollyanna about many things in life.
0:17:10 And I know that winning is the ultimate goal for everyone.
0:17:12 But I do think that people,
0:17:14 the American public deserves the best person for the job.
0:17:17 And the best person for the job should be the person
0:17:19 who can show up in a bunch of different forums,
0:17:22 explain themselves, connect with people,
0:17:25 have policies that satisfy the widest swath of voters.
0:17:28 And so I think that he should,
0:17:31 for people who are on the fence and saw him behave
0:17:32 like a petulant toddler,
0:17:34 he could do a lot better.
0:17:36 And I think he could also interact with her better.
0:17:39 There’s a clip floating around on Twitter,
0:17:41 or X, whatever I’m supposed to call it,
0:17:43 from 2016 when he was debating Hillary,
0:17:46 and not only is his cognitive decline
0:17:48 on full display up until now,
0:17:51 but he’s really kind of nice to her.
0:17:53 – It’s been defective for a long time, many years,
0:17:56 but the politicians haven’t done anything about it.
0:18:00 Now, an all fair is to Secretary Clinton, yes.
0:18:01 Is that okay?
0:18:04 Good, I want you to be very happy.
0:18:05 It’s very important to me.
0:18:07 But an all fairness to Secretary Clinton.
0:18:09 – He says, I want you to be happy.
0:18:10 I want you to be very happy.
0:18:12 And it made me think back to the night that he won,
0:18:14 which surprised him more than anyone.
0:18:16 Remember, he told her, you come out and you say,
0:18:19 whatever you want, whenever is good for you.
0:18:21 There’s no need for you to make a speech right now
0:18:24 at three o’clock in the morning or whenever it got called.
0:18:28 And he seemed much more humane in that version
0:18:32 versus what we saw or continue to see right now in 2024.
0:18:34 So I think he could help himself.
0:18:37 And I think Kamala would continue to build
0:18:40 on this goodwill that’s beginning to burn for her.
0:18:43 – Your point is a good one that if you’re gonna try
0:18:46 and present or you think that you’re presenting
0:18:47 to the people that you’re the person
0:18:49 that should be presented to carry the flag
0:18:52 in almost any context or the most important contexts,
0:18:53 I should say around the world,
0:18:56 that you should be subject to all sorts of formats.
0:18:59 That one of the reasons we’ve had such exceptional people
0:19:01 as presidents of the nation
0:19:03 is we battle test this shit out of him.
0:19:05 Fred Smith was not gonna be present.
0:19:09 Rudy Giuliani, Herman Cain were all at one point
0:19:11 leading in the polls.
0:19:13 And as soon as they kind of got on stage
0:19:15 and people started battle testing–
0:19:17 – Ted Cruz won Iowa.
0:19:18 – Ted Cruz won Iowa, right.
0:19:20 As soon as we started power washing them
0:19:23 and they went into combat, they just fell away.
0:19:26 And that process does produce really impressive people.
0:19:29 But what you said about as your lead up
0:19:31 that Trump should do another debate,
0:19:33 I would bet that a lot of people
0:19:34 who are Trump supporters are saying,
0:19:37 “Are we talking about Trump or Kamala?”
0:19:41 Because she has not opened herself to a lot of formats.
0:19:42 – I think that’s totally fair.
0:19:46 She did a local ABC Philly interview.
0:19:48 I think he came out on Friday.
0:19:49 But she definitely has to.
0:19:53 And I think Trump had wanted a Fox debate
0:19:55 after the moderators who he said
0:19:56 we’re in the tank for her,
0:19:59 which I do not see that bias existing.
0:20:01 But he says he wants,
0:20:03 it can’t be Brett Bear and Martha McCallum.
0:20:05 Now he wants Sean Hannity and Lauren Grum and Jesse Waters
0:20:06 to do it.
0:20:08 So obviously that’s a non-starter.
0:20:10 But I think that Kamala should just come out and say,
0:20:12 if he’s not gonna debate on Fox,
0:20:15 I’m gonna sit down with Brett Bear and myself.
0:20:18 And Brett will give her a fair interview.
0:20:20 One of the worst interviews that has ever existed
0:20:22 for Donald Trump was actually with Brett
0:20:24 when he read off all the horrible things that people–
0:20:26 – All the secretaries, all the people
0:20:27 who no longer wanna work with him.
0:20:28 – Exactly.
0:20:31 – That Ford is 44 secretaries are supporting him.
0:20:34 – Yeah, it’s very slim pickings over there.
0:20:36 But she should do it.
0:20:37 And it’s a little selfish.
0:20:40 I would love it if she came on the network that I work for.
0:20:42 But it’s also where the persuadable voters are.
0:20:43 And I think that, you know,
0:20:45 Mayor Pete has really proven that out
0:20:48 as being a good strategy for Democrats to show up.
0:20:51 Gavin Newsom as well, Mark Kelly’s been coming on.
0:20:54 I think it’s really good for a public
0:20:57 that might not feel thrilled about their choices
0:21:00 to see you showing up and doing the difficult things.
0:21:02 – Yeah, look, if you wanna be part of the resistance,
0:21:03 you have to get behind enemy lines.
0:21:06 But the people you referenced, Mayor Pete
0:21:07 or Secretary Buttigieg–
0:21:10 – I should say Secretary Pete or I should say Buttigieg.
0:21:13 It’s just so Mayor Pete is so good.
0:21:17 – Well, yeah, but him and Governor Newsom,
0:21:20 they, I believe in my view, they’re better
0:21:22 facing the opposing party than when they’re on their own party
0:21:26 because they are so outstanding at sort of very,
0:21:29 I think when Governor Newsom goes on friendly TV,
0:21:32 I think it’s a handsome vanilla mooring guy.
0:21:34 When he debates Governor DeSantis,
0:21:36 I think he tore him limb from limb and he’s really good.
0:21:38 I think the same is true of Secretary Pete.
0:21:40 Vice President Harris hasn’t demonstrated
0:21:41 that ability to go mind enemy lines.
0:21:44 And I think the people probably advising her
0:21:47 aren’t sure it’s a good idea because I think,
0:21:50 Brett Baird would be fair,
0:21:53 but quite frankly, he’s just gonna put to her
0:21:55 a level of questioning that I’m not sure,
0:21:57 we don’t know if she’d be good at this.
0:21:59 We both believe she should do it.
0:22:01 I’m not sure it’s the right thing to do
0:22:03 from a winning standpoint.
0:22:07 Trump is terrible when he gets in front of an opposing party.
0:22:08 He starts calling them nasty
0:22:11 or starts insulting that network.
0:22:14 I saw what I thought was just a cringe-worthy interview.
0:22:15 I love Dana Bash.
0:22:17 I think she’s very measured.
0:22:19 And I think she’s great at what she does.
0:22:23 And she interviewed Senator Vance.
0:22:25 And talking about this, well, first off,
0:22:28 just in case you’re one of the 2% of people
0:22:31 that haven’t heard it, let’s play the clip from Trump
0:22:34 about locking up Fluffy and Zoe
0:22:36 because they are under threat from Haitian immigrants.
0:22:37 Let’s play that.
0:22:39 – Look at what’s happening to the towns
0:22:41 all over the United States.
0:22:42 And a lot of towns don’t wanna talk.
0:22:44 It’s not gonna be Aurora or Springfield.
0:22:46 A lot of towns don’t wanna talk about it
0:22:48 because they’re so embarrassed by it.
0:22:51 In Springfield, they’re eating the dogs,
0:22:53 the people that came in, they’re eating the cats,
0:22:58 they’re eating the pets of the people that live there.
0:23:02 And this is what’s happening in our country.
0:23:03 And it’s a shame.
0:23:05 – So Senator Vance came on and Dana Bash
0:23:08 immediately said, look, this is causing problems
0:23:13 in Springfield, Ohio, that this is creating
0:23:14 a lot of unnecessary attention.
0:23:16 It’s bad for our economy.
0:23:20 It’s creating a spectacle of Springfield.
0:23:21 We’re worried it’s gonna be bad
0:23:24 in terms of our ability to actually solve the problem.
0:23:26 Can you please stop?
0:23:29 And she said, why are you spreading baseless claims?
0:23:32 And he said, well, when my constituents call me
0:23:35 with a concern, I have a responsibility.
0:23:38 And she kept pressing him and he went on
0:23:40 very much on the offensive and said,
0:23:42 that’s outrageous if you would accuse me
0:23:44 of inciting problems.
0:23:46 He went into the outrage misdirect
0:23:49 and I couldn’t figure out if it was bad for CNN
0:23:52 and Dana or bad for Senator Vance.
0:23:56 But I feel as if Senator Vance and Linda Yacarino
0:23:58 literally have the worst jobs in the world.
0:24:00 That they’re the circus clown falling around,
0:24:03 scooping up the shit of an elephant.
0:24:07 They’re like, okay, you go defend this ridiculousness.
0:24:11 And he has to pretend that this is actually going on
0:24:12 and it was a reasonable thing to say.
0:24:14 I don’t, is this a giant?
0:24:17 Should the Harris campaign continue to press
0:24:19 on the ridiculousness of that statement
0:24:20 or should they move on?
0:24:23 I’m almost getting a little sick of talking about it.
0:24:26 – Again, and I think I said this last week,
0:24:29 we’re not really the target audience anymore for this.
0:24:31 We can evaluate these things.
0:24:33 And I think our opinions are worth something
0:24:36 and hopefully our many listeners agree with that.
0:24:40 But if you need to get out to sometimes low information
0:24:42 undecided voters,
0:24:44 I think you do need to keep talking about these things.
0:24:46 But the way that you do it is important.
0:24:50 Like dunking on JD Vance, like he’s been dunked on a lot
0:24:51 and it’s working, right?
0:24:54 His approval rating is the lowest of anyone,
0:24:56 you know, certainly of his ticket.
0:24:59 Like he’s a point lower even than Trump,
0:25:01 which is astounding.
0:25:02 And Walls is in positive territory
0:25:05 and Kamala is just barely in positive territory,
0:25:06 but she is now.
0:25:08 But I think that what you need to focus on
0:25:10 is the fact that he admitted
0:25:12 that sometimes you have to create stories.
0:25:14 So he owned up to faking it.
0:25:16 And then tie that into the fact
0:25:18 that Trump was talking later
0:25:20 and talking about his deportation force,
0:25:22 that he’s going to go to Springfield.
0:25:24 And these are legal immigrants
0:25:25 that he said that he’s going to round up
0:25:27 and send to Venezuela,
0:25:30 which is not Haiti last time I checked.
0:25:32 – It’s close.
0:25:33 It’s close.
0:25:35 – Close but no cigar on that one.
0:25:39 And I think that when you contextualize it
0:25:42 in terms of how inhumane these people are
0:25:47 in the way they talk about people of immigrants,
0:25:49 people of color as well,
0:25:50 that that’s something that can be resonant
0:25:52 to folks who are on the fence.
0:25:54 Now from the GOP side,
0:25:57 that thinks that our cities are overrun
0:25:59 and the country is going to hell in a handbasket
0:26:01 because of immigration
0:26:03 and isn’t really separating legal
0:26:05 versus illegal immigration.
0:26:07 You know, they’re looking at the fact
0:26:08 that the Harris campaign,
0:26:09 and I referenced before, you know,
0:26:12 my orcas being on and talking about
0:26:13 what’s gone on on the border for a while,
0:26:15 that the Democrats don’t seem to really have
0:26:19 a cogent answer for what the solution is going to be.
0:26:22 So for people who do live in places
0:26:24 where for instance rec centers
0:26:26 that are for low income kids
0:26:29 are being taken over as migrant shelters
0:26:31 or have classrooms that are being flooded
0:26:33 with people that don’t necessarily speak the language
0:26:35 or ERs or all of these very real problems
0:26:38 they’re having as a result of the migrant crisis.
0:26:40 The fact that JD Vance and Donald Trump
0:26:42 are even talking about it at all
0:26:43 versus saying like, oh, you know,
0:26:46 we have a fancy bipartisan bill.
0:26:48 Like a bill is not a solution to people,
0:26:49 especially when they know that the bill
0:26:51 isn’t going to be passed.
0:26:55 And now there’s another survey out in FT survey
0:26:57 that showed Kamala Harris really closing the gap
0:26:58 on the economy.
0:27:00 She was even up a point or two
0:27:01 that people get that she cares about
0:27:03 average Americans, middle class Americans.
0:27:04 He’s for the wealthy.
0:27:06 But if you look at it on the immigration issue,
0:27:08 he’s still up like 14 points on that.
0:27:10 And so whatever she’s messaging on it
0:27:13 isn’t resonating in a way
0:27:15 that I think is going to move the needle in that direction.
0:27:18 And for Nikki Haley voters who are the top,
0:27:20 you know, up for grabs and top priority,
0:27:23 they also said immigration was their top issue
0:27:24 in the primary.
0:27:27 And the campaign hasn’t been that responsive to it.
0:27:30 – Senator Kelly said something
0:27:32 I thought that was pretty, pretty interesting.
0:27:36 He said that Republicans aren’t sincere
0:27:40 about immigration and Democrats don’t understand it.
0:27:43 And what I take more of a,
0:27:45 my sense is money always wins.
0:27:47 And that if you want to look at something,
0:27:51 when I serve on a board and the CEO is behaving strangely
0:27:54 or we can’t figure out why store managers
0:27:56 aren’t collecting email or whatever,
0:27:58 let’s go to the compensation.
0:28:00 Let’s just go to the money, money always wins.
0:28:01 It’s around incentives.
0:28:03 And I believe our lack of an immigration policy
0:28:06 over the last 40 years has primarily been
0:28:08 because, and people don’t talk about this,
0:28:10 people talk a lot about the morality of immigration
0:28:12 and how it’s part of our DNA
0:28:13 in that it’s good for America.
0:28:17 And 20% of the NASDAQ by market capitalization
0:28:22 is from first generation Indian Americans who immigrated here.
0:28:26 So there’s a ton of like spiritual and chest beating
0:28:30 and flag waving notions of immigration.
0:28:31 I think the most beneficial
0:28:32 or one of the most beneficial things
0:28:34 about immigration is a subset of it.
0:28:37 And that is illegal immigration.
0:28:39 And if you think about undocumented workers,
0:28:41 they come across the border,
0:28:43 they pay social security taxes,
0:28:44 but they usually don’t stick around
0:28:46 to collect social security benefits.
0:28:49 They are the most profitable immigrants in history,
0:28:51 specifically undocumented workers
0:28:53 and all this bullshit about,
0:28:56 and you’ll find examples of this of them being criminals,
0:29:00 they actually commit crimes at a lower rate than citizens.
0:29:04 And I think we’ve figured out this flexible workforce
0:29:08 that comes in, picks grapes, takes care of grandma
0:29:12 at a lower cost, lower tax, lower taxation
0:29:14 or lower strain on our social services,
0:29:17 in that we haven’t wanted to fix this problem
0:29:19 because we make a shit ton of money from illegal
0:29:21 or undocumented workers
0:29:22 and we’re willing to pay the price
0:29:23 of some of the externalities.
0:29:25 Now the point, you know, the question is,
0:29:28 at some point does it become so out of control
0:29:29 that it’s no longer worth it?
0:29:31 And I think a lot of people have decided
0:29:33 that we’ve gotten to that point.
0:29:34 Any thoughts?
0:29:36 – No, I totally agree.
0:29:38 My dad was a winemaker in Oregon.
0:29:40 So, you know, dealing with the seasonal workers
0:29:43 was something that was built into conversations
0:29:45 that we were, you know, having around the dinner table
0:29:48 and how also incredible these people were
0:29:51 and what kind of bastions of the community they were.
0:29:53 And I thought a lot about,
0:29:55 do you remember there was a proposal
0:29:58 that came out of the California State Assembly
0:30:01 a few weeks ago about giving loans
0:30:04 to undocumented people to buy a home.
0:30:08 And it became this lightning rod thing,
0:30:11 you know, Newsom was basically like, I’m gonna veto this.
0:30:13 No matter what, the politics are terrible.
0:30:16 Nancy Pelosi was asked about it when she was on Bill Maher.
0:30:21 But I was frustrated that it didn’t get into the conversation
0:30:24 that, A, these were people who were paying taxes,
0:30:25 like you said, as most of them are,
0:30:27 and then they don’t necessarily hang around
0:30:28 to claim it on the backside of it,
0:30:30 but that they were people who had to qualify
0:30:33 by our federal mortgage rate standards.
0:30:36 Like these just weren’t people streaming across the border
0:30:40 where we said, oh, here’s $150,000, go have fun.
0:30:41 You know, these are people who were established
0:30:43 in the community had earned enough
0:30:46 to be able to qualify for a mortgage
0:30:48 to get on the property ladder.
0:30:50 And I think that that’s somewhere
0:30:52 that Democrats can really lean into those conversations,
0:30:54 not necessarily in an election year
0:30:56 where it’s going to be distorted.
0:31:00 And I haven’t gone into the fine tuning of the policy,
0:31:04 I was just surprised to hear how it was being spoken about
0:31:07 without all of the real information behind it
0:31:08 or at least coming to light
0:31:12 to make it a more fair and balanced conversation.
0:31:14 But those are the types of immigration conundrums
0:31:18 that I feel like the American public is ready to deal with.
0:31:20 But when you have border crossings,
0:31:23 the way that it has been kind of before Biden’s executive order,
0:31:25 which I guess is now a couple of months old
0:31:28 and cut it what, 55% or something like that.
0:31:30 You know, if you see these images of people streaming in
0:31:32 and equal pass somewhere
0:31:34 that can only hold 10,000, 15,000 people
0:31:37 is getting thousands a day of people coming there
0:31:39 that no one’s actually going to have
0:31:42 that real conversation about the seasonal workers,
0:31:44 the people who work in your homes
0:31:46 who oftentimes raise your children
0:31:48 and take care of your parents
0:31:51 when they’re dying with the level of empathy and care
0:31:55 that I can’t even fathom summoning from myself
0:31:59 as someone who loved my father deeply.
0:32:02 The people who cared for him, it was next level,
0:32:05 like angel level stuff.
0:32:08 And no one, I guess it’s Markely’s point,
0:32:12 you know, no one really wants to be real about this,
0:32:17 even if now the migrants are in Chicago and New York
0:32:21 and Baltimore at higher rates than they ever had been before.
0:32:24 – Also think, and I’m by no means an expert on this issue,
0:32:27 but I think it’s unhealthy.
0:32:29 I think we need to separate the border
0:32:32 from immigration policy because, I mean,
0:32:34 the majority of my understanding is about half
0:32:38 or more of undocumented workers are just overstayers.
0:32:41 They come here legally on a visa and they just stay.
0:32:43 And I think a disproportionate amount
0:32:46 of undocumented workers get here on a plane.
0:32:49 They fly over any wall that we’re planning on building.
0:32:54 And the other, I’ve always thought at the end of the day,
0:32:56 if we were serious about this,
0:32:58 it wouldn’t be that hard to fix.
0:33:01 And that is use some sort of biometric program
0:33:05 and any employer caught with an undocumented worker
0:33:06 pays a $25,000 fine.
0:33:12 And the moment you have on the demand side shrink up
0:33:13 where people are like, oh shit,
0:33:17 if I have five guys in my kitchen and if I get caught
0:33:21 and I can’t and someone comes in and scans their eyes
0:33:23 and says, this is an undocumented worker.
0:33:24 You did not check.
0:33:28 You did not call us five times 25,000, 125 grand.
0:33:33 In my opinion, the whole thing’s over.
0:33:37 – Yeah, but is that the result that you want?
0:33:40 I mean, do you want people who are busting their asses
0:33:43 working in the kitchens at the restaurants
0:33:46 that we all go and sit in to be thrown out?
0:33:48 – Oh, I want to be clear.
0:33:51 I think this is a boon in the American economy.
0:33:52 I’ll use a personal example.
0:33:57 I was renovating a house and I was trying to fix up a house,
0:34:00 didn’t have a lot of money
0:34:05 and had trouble finding people to do a certain job.
0:34:07 My general contractor said, come with me.
0:34:10 We went to this local 7-Eleven,
0:34:14 bunch of undocumented workers, I assume, rush the pickup.
0:34:17 He asked some questions in Spanish.
0:34:19 Six guys jumped in, went to the site,
0:34:20 went to the construction site.
0:34:23 These guys like, they worked around the clock,
0:34:25 around the clock.
0:34:28 They each had a specific skill.
0:34:29 I mean, Jesus Christ,
0:34:32 this is like the most unbelievable workforce
0:34:33 I have ever seen.
0:34:35 And I thought this is,
0:34:38 no wonder people are turning a blind eye to this
0:34:41 because this is just such a flexible, efficient workforce.
0:34:45 I absolutely think these folks do great work
0:34:47 and deserve more empathy.
0:34:49 What I’m saying is I just think it’s cynical,
0:34:53 all these calls for border protection.
0:34:55 – I take it back, you’re not a bad person.
0:35:00 – If for whatever reason, rationally or irrationally,
0:35:02 you wanted to stem the flow,
0:35:06 just punish the employer because once demand drives it,
0:35:08 but that’s never an option
0:35:10 because those are nice white Republicans
0:35:12 employing those people.
0:35:14 We don’t go to the source.
0:35:15 You’re never gonna,
0:35:17 if you can’t keep drugs out of prison,
0:35:21 the notion that you’re gonna keep talented resourceful people
0:35:24 out of opportunity and economic wellbeing
0:35:25 because there’s some fucking wall
0:35:27 or some sort of border control,
0:35:30 there’s no way you would have to,
0:35:32 it strikes me if we ever got serious
0:35:34 about quote unquote undocumented workers,
0:35:37 it would be a lot less complex than people think,
0:35:39 it would be going after the demand side
0:35:41 and just punishing the employers,
0:35:43 but no one wants to talk about that
0:35:45 ’cause those are good Americans.
0:35:48 Anyways, I don’t think we’re serious about this problem.
0:35:49 – Well, we’re definitely not
0:35:52 and we’re gonna lose elections because of it
0:35:53 or Democrats are.
0:35:55 I mean, it was one of I think the strongest arguments
0:35:58 for putting Mark Kelly on the ticket.
0:36:00 I mean, he has the best bio ever
0:36:05 and Gabby Giffords is otherworldly impressive and inspiring.
0:36:08 I mean, we would have lost,
0:36:09 potentially lost the Arizona Senate seat.
0:36:12 So I think Chuck Schumer lost his mind about that,
0:36:15 but having a Democrat that is conversant
0:36:18 in the mechanics of immigration,
0:36:19 like you say from the border,
0:36:22 but also what happens once they’re here
0:36:27 and what life looks like from a humane and kind perspective,
0:36:29 but also a realist perspective,
0:36:32 I think would have been of huge value.
0:36:36 And I know we’re gonna dip into talking about
0:36:39 whether walls has panned out to be the best choice
0:36:40 for all of that.
0:36:41 If you’re talking about immigration,
0:36:45 I’m picking Mark Kelly 10 times out of 10 over Tim Walls
0:36:48 in terms of talking about it.
0:36:49 – Well, he’s on the border
0:36:51 and he speaks eloquently on it.
0:36:53 Let’s use that.
0:36:55 So by the way, just as I was saying, it didn’t matter.
0:36:56 I’m now looking at some polls
0:36:58 that our producer Caroline pulled together.
0:37:01 And we have new Reuters episodes.
0:37:04 National polls shows Harris leading by five points, 47, 42.
0:37:09 The Economist poll shows Harris up by three, 49 to 46.
0:37:12 A CNN flash poll, a majority of debate watchers
0:37:13 say Harris outperforms Trump.
0:37:15 Yeah, we know that.
0:37:18 But it does look like, my understanding is
0:37:21 she has to solidly get more,
0:37:23 she has to be up by two or three points
0:37:25 to win the electoral college.
0:37:26 That accurate?
0:37:27 – Yeah, that’s right.
0:37:29 And I know you had Nate Silver on
0:37:33 and his probability forecast is a bit of an outlier now,
0:37:36 but he has some new numbers up about the odds
0:37:38 of many different things happening.
0:37:42 But what’s so sick to me about our system
0:37:43 is Republicans don’t even try
0:37:45 to win the popular vote anymore.
0:37:49 Like the idea of trying to win a majority of voters
0:37:50 is out the window.
0:37:52 And it’s just a game of chess,
0:37:55 figuring out what states you can cobble together for this.
0:37:57 And Kamala, yeah, in two points,
0:38:00 I would still be sweating going into election night
0:38:02 if she was three or four points.
0:38:03 People would feel a lot better
0:38:05 about her odds of winning the electoral college.
0:38:08 But I should say the Fox forecast came out
0:38:09 at the end of last week.
0:38:12 And two pivotal states, Georgia and North Carolina,
0:38:16 which were lean Republican, are now toss-ups.
0:38:18 And the Harris campaign is a very serious
0:38:20 about North Carolina.
0:38:23 I mean, they’ve shown a capacity to win Georgia before.
0:38:24 And I think Trump, you know,
0:38:26 whoever gave him his come to Jesus moment
0:38:28 about being nice to Brian Kemp,
0:38:30 you know, finally got through on that one.
0:38:34 But North Carolina would be a fascinating pickup
0:38:35 for Democrats.
0:38:36 – And that’s where money comes in.
0:38:39 They now have the money to sort of put in field offices
0:38:42 and go hard after states where they maybe only have
0:38:43 a one in five chance of winning,
0:38:45 but they have a one in five chance of winning.
0:38:49 It feels like this is where those hundreds of millions
0:38:51 that she’s out raising him right now
0:38:54 would be really powerful.
0:38:57 Stay with us.
0:39:05 I think one of the biggest problems in America
0:39:07 is that we have minority rule.
0:39:10 And that is, you know, 20% of our population
0:39:13 has 80% of the senators, whether you look at gun control.
0:39:17 I mean, there’s just, whether you look at the majority
0:39:19 of Americans favor bodily autonomy.
0:39:20 We really do have minority rule
0:39:22 on some of the most important issues.
0:39:25 And I would argue, I think a lot about marketing,
0:39:29 the three best marketers in the world by sector or groups.
0:39:31 First and foremost, the best marketers in history
0:39:33 were the tobacco guys.
0:39:35 When your product’s primary benefits
0:39:36 are death, disease, and disability,
0:39:38 and you’ve convinced people that it’s cool,
0:39:42 and you sell a product at 96 points a margin, unbelievable.
0:39:43 Actually, I’ll do four.
0:39:46 My industry is the only industry in the world
0:39:48 that can charge a six-figure price tag
0:39:51 at 97 points of gross profit margin,
0:39:53 and artificially creates scarcity,
0:39:55 becoming forces to cast system.
0:39:57 In some, we’re sort of mendacious fox
0:39:58 that wake up every morning and say,
0:40:00 how do I reduce my accountability
0:40:01 while increasing my compensation?
0:40:04 I know despite sitting on the GDP of Costa Rica,
0:40:06 I’m only gonna let in 1,500 people
0:40:08 ’cause it makes me feel good about myself.
0:40:10 We’re the best marketers in the world.
0:40:12 MIT, Stanford, Harvard are the best brands in the world.
0:40:14 It’s not Apple.
0:40:19 Number three would be the industrial financial complex.
0:40:22 Anyone on CNBC, hedge funds, mutual funds,
0:40:24 it’s all a total fucking grift.
0:40:28 If you took every single hedge fund, mutual fund, 401K,
0:40:30 everything you’re in, and you added it all up,
0:40:32 it’s exactly underperformed the S&P
0:40:33 by the amount of the fees.
0:40:36 We should all just put our money in low-cost index funds.
0:40:40 The entire financial industrial complex is a giant grift,
0:40:42 but they put some old guy in suspenders
0:40:44 and the Wall Street Journal on CNBC
0:40:45 and we’re under the impression
0:40:46 he actually understands which way the market
0:40:49 is gonna go, spoiler alert, he doesn’t.
0:40:51 And then my rounding it out,
0:40:53 the fourth best marketers in the world
0:40:54 are the Republican Party,
0:40:55 who as far as I can tell,
0:40:59 spends 70 or 80% of their energies
0:41:01 representing the top 1% in corporations
0:41:04 and yet every year get about 47% of the vote.
0:41:08 That is an incredible feat to convince these people
0:41:12 that yeah, we’re for you when really at the end of the day,
0:41:15 who they really represent our corporations
0:41:16 and the Uber wealthy.
0:41:18 Anyways, that’s my TED Talk around marketing.
0:41:19 Any thoughts, Jessica?
0:41:22 – I agree with it and my question would be,
0:41:24 do you think that the Republicans are really that good
0:41:28 or that the Dems are really that bad?
0:41:32 – Yes, I think that’s the correct question.
0:41:34 So just as we wrap up here,
0:41:37 let’s touch base on Walls being the VP pick.
0:41:38 We had Nate Silver on the property pod
0:41:40 as you referenced a few weeks ago
0:41:45 and he thinks that we should have picked Shapiro.
0:41:48 By the way, I was really hoping for Shapiro
0:41:50 and looking back now,
0:41:52 I actually think Walls was the right choice
0:41:55 because I think capturing younger men
0:41:59 around sort of this aspirational vision of masculinity
0:42:02 is serving them really well.
0:42:03 Republicans argue that Walls
0:42:06 has pushed a very progressive agenda in Minnesota,
0:42:08 whereas Democrats see him as someone
0:42:09 with strong Midwestern appeal
0:42:11 who connects with everyday voters.
0:42:12 What are your thoughts?
0:42:15 How would you evaluate Walls’ performance so far?
0:42:19 – So I’d bifurcate it into two buckets.
0:42:21 So one is the feels bucket
0:42:23 and then one is like the practicality bucket.
0:42:25 And on the feels,
0:42:28 I think that he’s been a fantastic partner for her.
0:42:30 And I don’t wanna make this about gender,
0:42:35 but I think that a female candidate for president,
0:42:37 especially one who has been shaky in the past
0:42:40 and has had a tough time with the press,
0:42:43 she wasn’t successful in the 2020 primary,
0:42:45 obviously to get the Democratic nomination.
0:42:47 I think it matters a hell of a lot
0:42:50 that she picked the person who she felt supported by,
0:42:52 who she connected with,
0:42:55 who’s as a couple, her and Doug connected
0:42:58 with Tim Walls and Gwen Walls.
0:43:00 And I think that she does better
0:43:02 when she feels good about herself.
0:43:03 And you saw that post-debate.
0:43:05 If you watched, she did a rally,
0:43:07 I think it was in North Carolina the day after.
0:43:10 And she was loose and fun.
0:43:12 And there was substance in it,
0:43:14 but there was a joy and not in the
0:43:15 we’re coconut pill joy way,
0:43:20 like a genuine joy in doing this job of campaigning
0:43:22 to be able to be commander in chief.
0:43:25 And I think that Tim Walls is a huge part of that.
0:43:27 In the practicality bucket,
0:43:29 I already referenced the fact that his favorability
0:43:32 of the four people that are vying for these jobs,
0:43:35 so Trump, Kamala, JD Vance and Tim Walls,
0:43:37 he has the highest favorability by far.
0:43:39 I mean, some polls even have it at 11.
0:43:41 I think one had it at 14.
0:43:44 And what Republicans are throwing at him.
0:43:46 Oh, did you hear that he was an assistant coach
0:43:48 and not a coach?
0:43:49 Like that stuff is not sticking.
0:43:52 I think the military conversation about,
0:43:55 whether he retired commander, major sergeant,
0:43:57 I think is the term or not,
0:43:59 that was resonant with some people,
0:44:01 especially in the veteran community,
0:44:03 but he has such a solid record
0:44:05 that isn’t necessarily progressive.
0:44:08 Like he runs the sixth best state in the country
0:44:10 to do business in.
0:44:12 That doesn’t seem like a socialist to me.
0:44:14 So you’re going to talk in point, I didn’t know that.
0:44:16 Oh, you, I leased it to you.
0:44:20 I just know the prince was born and raised there.
0:44:21 That is also important.
0:44:24 And I’m sure they will let him use the music for it.
0:44:28 But if you go back and look at his reelection in 2022,
0:44:30 that was after the summer of Black Lives Matter,
0:44:33 the riots, all of the issues would defund the police.
0:44:35 And he won by eight points.
0:44:38 He paced ahead of Biden’s margin
0:44:40 when he was in the state at 2020.
0:44:42 Originally, his congressional district.
0:44:44 Yeah, and like, I think that people just can’t believe
0:44:49 that the guy whose students staffed his first campaign,
0:44:53 taking on a serious right winger is a bad guy.
0:44:55 Now, Josh Shapiro, you know,
0:44:57 and I think we talked about this maybe in person
0:45:00 and not necessarily on any podcast venue.
0:45:02 Josh Shapiro was great at the DNC.
0:45:04 I expected to be brought to tears, right?
0:45:07 But by this Baruch Obama situation.
0:45:11 And I found him to be incredibly compelling.
0:45:12 Baruch Obama, you’re good.
0:45:13 That’s what we call him.
0:45:14 No, no, it wasn’t me.
0:45:17 The other Jews came up with that first.
0:45:22 But if this somehow comes down to Israel in some way,
0:45:24 Tim Walls wrote a master’s thesis
0:45:26 about being able to teach the Holocaust better
0:45:28 to make sure that we never actually go back
0:45:30 to a time where something like that is possible.
0:45:34 But if you hear it from a Jew, it often sounds better.
0:45:37 And Josh Shapiro has that and he’s tight
0:45:39 and he’s really good.
0:45:40 But at the end of the day,
0:45:42 it didn’t seem like he really wanted that job.
0:45:43 And you know what it’s like.
0:45:45 You’ve, you know, employed thousands of people.
0:45:48 If someone is not into the job that they have,
0:45:51 can they really do it at the level that you need
0:45:52 when the stakes are this high?
0:45:56 And Tim Walls wants that job so bad.
0:45:59 So what I’ve heard, I mean, this is all hearsay.
0:46:01 I don’t know.
0:46:03 I heard on the Friday before the pick,
0:46:07 he had it because quite frankly winning Pennsylvania
0:46:12 would probably, it makes the path to presidency
0:46:14 for her pretty like the landing lights would be on.
0:46:17 He’s very popular in Pennsylvania.
0:46:20 He would inoculate her around the kind of Israel issue.
0:46:25 And also I think he was just primed to be an attack dog
0:46:29 because, which is a VP is supposed to do
0:46:31 because he’s already filed suits against Trump
0:46:35 on election interference.
0:46:38 Yeah, so he was kind of ready to go.
0:46:40 I think it comes down to ego.
0:46:41 I think, I don’t think she wanted someone
0:46:42 who wanted her job.
0:46:43 He doesn’t want that job.
0:46:45 He wants to be president.
0:46:47 And I think she was very drawn to Walls.
0:46:49 And I also heard that a lot of people in the far left
0:46:53 were very uncomfortable with Shapiro on call then.
0:46:56 But let’s talk, what are your predictions
0:46:57 just as we wrap up here?
0:46:59 What are your predictions for the VP of debate
0:47:01 that’s supposed to take place?
0:47:03 I think it’s on October the 1st.
0:47:05 What do you think is going to happen?
0:47:08 I worry that they’re going to talk past each other,
0:47:10 which I think was a little bit of the problem
0:47:11 for people with the Harris-Crom to be.
0:47:13 He’s a great moderator, right?
0:47:13 Who’s moderating it?
0:47:14 Do we know?
0:47:16 Oh, I don’t, I should know.
0:47:20 I just hope my really strong suggestion
0:47:22 is that it’s that David Muir guy again,
0:47:24 except he does it without a shirt on.
0:47:26 Jesus Christ, that guy’s dreamy.
0:47:26 What’s that his name?
0:47:27 David Muir?
0:47:28 What’s his name?
0:47:30 Yes, I saw him at the DNC.
0:47:35 And I stopped and I watched as he watched by.
0:47:38 I said this on Pivot and I hate to recycle points,
0:47:39 but I do it a lot.
0:47:41 I think Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise
0:47:43 would have both been Academy Award winners
0:47:44 in their 20s and 30s.
0:47:47 Him, Tom for “Born on the Fourth of July,”
0:47:51 and Brad Pitt for this odd movie called “12 Monkeys”
0:47:55 with Bruce Willis where he played a mentally ill
0:47:58 as son of a rich kid who ends up starting a global pandemic.
0:47:59 They’re both outstanding actors,
0:48:01 but they’re so good looking
0:48:04 that it diminishes people’s perception of their acting skills.
0:48:06 I think that guy Muir, whatever his name is,
0:48:08 I think he’s just too hot to be taken seriously
0:48:09 as a moderator.
0:48:10 I think he’s so good looking.
0:48:12 Well, I agree with the good looking part,
0:48:13 but you don’t think he was taken seriously?
0:48:15 And Lindsay Davis also beautiful.
0:48:16 Well, I think he’s had, in a weird way,
0:48:18 I think he’s had to work harder.
0:48:20 I thought they did a really good job.
0:48:21 I’ll be curious, that debate–
0:48:24 Well, now they’re saying that they were fed the questions.
0:48:26 You know, there’s always some conspiracy theory.
0:48:27 And it’s like if they were fed the question,
0:48:28 she would have answered them.
0:48:31 Like, I don’t understand that we were drawing a line
0:48:32 between those things.
0:48:33 I agree with you.
0:48:35 That’s gonna be a food fight.
0:48:37 In the next one or two weeks,
0:48:39 any things you’re following
0:48:41 or thinking that are important in terms of this race,
0:48:44 it feels like her momentum continues.
0:48:45 What do you think in the next,
0:48:47 any thoughts about what’s coming up?
0:48:48 That’ll be a big pivotal point
0:48:50 other than the VP debate,
0:48:51 which I think will come and go.
0:48:52 And I think it’ll be entertainment.
0:48:54 I’m not sure it’s gonna have much of an impact.
0:48:58 I’m really focused on getting black men,
0:49:01 in particular, back into the coalition.
0:49:03 You know, the threat of losing them to the couch
0:49:05 or whatever one says.
0:49:08 And then I’m interested as well in the conversion
0:49:12 on these Republicans for Democrats now.
0:49:14 So the democracy voters, you know,
0:49:17 who Liz Cheney is talking about.
0:49:19 And the Harris-Wall’s campaign
0:49:22 is definitely doing a big push for them.
0:49:23 But that is a tricky cohort
0:49:26 because those are people who are maybe bad fellows
0:49:28 for a couple of election cycles,
0:49:30 but odds are, are going back.
0:49:32 So how do you get them for 2024?
0:49:35 And then how also do you make your tent big enough
0:49:38 to keep them around in the longer term?
0:49:39 What about you?
0:49:40 – I like it.
0:49:41 I like it.
0:49:42 That makes sense.
0:49:43 Okay, so that’s all for this episode.
0:49:45 Our producers are Caroline Shagran
0:49:46 and David Toledo.
0:49:48 Andrew Burroughs is our technical director.
0:49:51 You can find Raging Moderates on the Prop G-Pod
0:49:52 every Tuesday again.
0:49:55 You can find Raging Moderates on the Prop G-Pod
0:49:57 every Tuesday.
0:49:59 All right, Jess, we will see you next week.
0:50:01 Thanks everybody for tuning in.
0:50:04 (upbeat music)
Scott and Jessica discuss the second assassination attempt on former president Donald Trump, how each presidential candidate has shaped up following the debate, the latest polls, and whether Tim Walz is benefiting the Democratic ticket.
Follow Jessica Tarlov, @JessicaTarlov.
Follow Prof G, @profgalloway.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices