How we built a government that can’t build anything

0
0
AI transcript
s of th of people from all over the world
for the er Electronics Show,
ek tryi ell each other
gets yo er seen in your entire life.
rgecast talking all about
g at CE
AI gad the humanoid robots
oping m meday do your laundry
s.
ore on gecast,
dcasts.
contrad .
love i ality,
te coll projects and national purpose.
‘s fait e people,
on one
h in th on the other.
s been best,
built
ed some n the middle of those dueling impulses.
ldly,
est.

onal to ly keep the government open,
or real nything at scale.

em to w more?

y Area.
rk Dunk
ng Work
,
Back.
at
nce
nian dr build
n drive ist power.
,
olitica e-sac.
institu nough to act collectively,
them t problems.
n the s
e got h
to fix
come to ow.
, thank
ur book
is Why Works.
case he America,
, is br
cusatio

y I’m t o connect
l frust
used t le to do

of doi the mundane.

e of so er wrongness
ng in A
s to do le of things
ight?
ve a sa
at impa r lives
to be e d
ntial t
tension
nto pro e thought.
all th ack
the cou
bout th
d Jeffe
f this .

from t nning
ry,
and bet o impulses.
pulses,
e found ument,
Indepen
ly frig
r.
s that t.
an impu say
ureaucr


e don’t o do.
that wo e us
om that
Declara Independence is.
rs crea ependence for us,
em
of Conf on.
re a sy
haos, r
states
nationa nment
execut nch.
cally h power

nment
ibuster
ny give .
uld fil anything.
,
t
esis
nial ru
alized,

r the A

rsed


ectivel
chaos.

ium,
itution
d
ment,
n in-be
on,
rt of
e


have ta further

influen

ck powe
thority


ic soci
es
hings

d ideas
empowe
cision
ons
est.
now,
author

about,
a chall
rywhere
there.
unique



wer?
umans,
out








m






ianism,









.
ort of,





xtreme







t

sively



st






acism




ion
tors





,
aven’t
worthy

g way

icament
ust
public
confide

ight.
period






,
otion


hines


ne,

ne
vel

itician






epartme


ystem.






ments
g


h.

s,





e.
pening
volutio


ion
h
ense







ns


.

ine








es
m



















y

.
es
lized
















oles?













y





al.







es




s.



k
overish




h.












rs
think


nse.

y.
oosevel
nt,
was




s






ee
























ry,




on.


tal
ning




.





.

s



s








ector












t


cale

,

do,
t.



e






.




nes

















e











.
d rail,

























































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































s
t


n























































e
























.























es.

































n





















ll


s
t



es,






























y


































ve.































.










































t





nts.











nally















ical
















































ent

















t,

















































































tal





































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































y




























.




t










um






om



















,
.

w

so



nd





nge






a
tive,
d
to
and

hit


are
rt-spec
,
g,
ll



also
h the
rpa
new
ede
t on

ried

he
er a

e.


y

o
ay
ray
ur

dot
, code
ut.
rth
ng you
peek at
ndowed
bruary

ecause
serves
ctually
e, not
okie
vice
r us.
l
ding
,
idence
nancial
want.
ther
ok.
taking
ancial
g the
gives
m and

wed
are
to
tionshi

‘s
u get
tch on


t
000

not
e
y


rying t
rail
L.A.
as
o show
y study
wsuit
eads to
no one
o just
doing


s that
es, you
in.
ot the

, Mark?
to make
n hard
utiful
ing,
if you’
San
oing to
value
straigh

ogressi
o empow
ly in t
o make
voters
e who a
d by

aking,
lution

ems whe
e, unli
ys, whe
voice,
to, whi
today,
tem
ncern
y the
don’t
you don
some
o upend
d it

rks
the sor
rrent
still

that i
allenge

aking

e feel



for
le
aven’t
t

on to
of
f
and
?
of the
ght?
have a
ust as
ing
t

it, we
arly
f five

, do

k.
igure i
.


guess t
f we do
ing
ivers,
to a


this
t
America
that,
ke up i
ury wit
ernment
like
stories
Americ
urn of

in
you
ou can
bill or

‘t
ivate
e bills
at that
f
ducing
clude
sion
l war.
right?

een
nd they
o the
ivate

tely

o would
t that
orrupt,

n’t
t
going
with
tutions
o the
t David
t
do 50

that
t

you
ne
5.
e he is
ne mile

Robert
in
powerfu
of New
agains
m doing
in the

ard
oing
n Chica
s all
country

es are
ke, it
h there
at is
ol of t
ou know
n the
ely
hem fro
Vietna
ountry
want.
tablish
impervi

have
ion tha
e, like
the
seems,
n’t,
e.
d a

ese
n histo
n a
now,
ight
w, how
o

and, li
ble to

f
oing
that
o see
public
re

lic
re
l say,
s is
e
roducin


me tha
ense th
ht now
t will
ven by
ight.
ally
, like,
can
and
ing to
and

em,
ll

there.
n.
nk by

really


y good
sort of
and not
big
but
very
can be
e done

after

at.
e on.
for me
k is
Works.


ds, I
is

a lot,
you did

ant to
, so

m, or
message
l line

eview,
dcast.
row.
oduced
edited
neered
fact
Hirsch,
wrote

Grey
s,
be.
Vox.
alism
ership

member
you
ecause
s know.
pported
old

tion
this

time.
time.
time.
time.
time.

Why is it so hard for America to build things?

Bridges take years to construct. Housing costs are soaring. Transit systems are crumbling. And we’re struggling to update our infrastructure to prepare for the climate crisis. Even when there’s broad agreement that something needs to be done, collective action feels impossible. Why is that?

Today’s guest is Marc Dunkelman, author of Why Nothing Works, a book about the modern American experience of watching government fail. He argues that by giving too many people the power to say “no,” we’ve stymied our collective progress.

Marc and Sean discuss an inherent tension in American politics: the need for effective, centralized power and a deep fear of its abuse. They trace how that tension has played out across American history, from the clashes between Jefferson and Hamilton, through the New Deal’s Tennessee Valley Authority, to the backlash against figures like Robert Moses. Marc argues that our current system — born out of a reaction to too much top-down authority during the late 20th century — has produced paralysis, dysfunction, and a deep distrust of government.

Host: Sean Illing (@SeanIlling)

Guest: Guest: Marc Dunkelman (@MarcDunkelman), author of Why Nothing Works: Who Killed Progress — and How to Bring It Back.

We would love to hear from you. To tell us what you thought of this episode, email us at thegrayarea@vox.com or leave us a voicemail at 1-800-214-5749. Your comments and questions help us make a better show.

And you can watch new episodes of The Gray Area on YouTube.Listen to The Gray Area ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: vox.com/members

This episode was supported by a grant from Arnold Ventures. Vox had full discretion over the content of this reporting.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Leave a Reply

The Gray Area with Sean IllingThe Gray Area with Sean Illing
Let's Evolve Together
Logo